Philosophy › Section A · Introduction to philosophy › Topic A.3
Socrates as a model philosopher
Socrates wrote nothing, held no office and was put to death by his own city, yet he became the model of what a philosopher is. His life shows the method of questioning, the honesty about ignorance, and the moral seriousness that philosophy still asks for.
A philosopher who wrote nothing
Socrates lived in Athens from about 470 to 399 BCE. He left no writings, so everything we know comes from others. The comic playwright Aristophanes mocked him in The Clouds (423 BCE) as a fraud who taught clever tricks with words. The soldier and historian Xenophon wrote admiring memoirs. Above all, his student Plato made Socrates the main speaker in most of his dialogues. These portraits do not always agree, and the question of how much of "Plato's Socrates" is the real man is called the Socratic problem. Many scholars think Plato's early dialogues come closest to the historical Socrates.
Trial and death
In 399 BCE three Athenians, Meletus, Anytus and Lycon, charged Socrates with impiety, failing to honour the city's gods and introducing new divine beings, and with corrupting the young. A jury of about 500 citizens convicted him and sentenced him to death. Plato wrote several dialogues around these events. The Apology presents his defence speech. In the Crito, his friend urges him to escape from prison, and Socrates argues that it would be unjust to break the city's laws. The Phaedo describes his final conversation, about whether the soul is immortal, and his death by poison, traditionally identified as hemlock. His execution became a lasting symbol of the clash between free inquiry and political power.
The oracle and human wisdom
In the Apology, Socrates explains how his reputation began. His friend Chaerephon asked the oracle at Delphi whether anyone was wiser than Socrates, and the priestess answered that no one was. Socrates was puzzled, since he believed he had no wisdom at all, so he set out to find someone wiser. He questioned politicians, then poets, then craftsmen. The craftsmen really did know their trades, but like the others they assumed they also understood the most important matters, and they did not. Socrates concluded that the god meant that human wisdom is worth little, and that he was wisest only because he did not think he knew what he did not know.
Worked example: reconstructing the oracle argument
Set out Socrates's reasoning as numbered steps. 1. The oracle says no one is wiser than Socrates. 2. Socrates believes he knows nothing important, yet assumes the god does not lie. 3. Test: if he finds someone wiser, the oracle seems refuted. 4. Each expert he questions claims knowledge about the most important things but cannot defend it. 5. Socrates also lacks that knowledge, but he does not claim it. 6. Conclusion: his only advantage is awareness of his own ignorance, so in that limited sense the oracle is right. 7. Check: notice that Socrates turns the oracle into a hypothesis to test, not a command to accept.
The unexamined life
After his conviction, Socrates was invited to propose a lesser penalty. He rejected exile, since he would simply keep questioning people elsewhere, and he refused to promise silence. In Benjamin Jowett's translation he says that "the unexamined life is not worth living". What does examination involve? First, self-examination, in the spirit of the Delphic inscription "know thyself": testing whether your beliefs are consistent and whether you can defend them. Second, curiosity about the world around you. A person who never questions their beliefs lives by ideas that have never been tested.
The Socratic method
Socrates rarely lectured. He asked others to define a virtue, such as courage, piety or justice, and then drew out consequences of their answer until it clashed with something else they believed. This method of testing by questioning is called elenchus. Why did he work this way? He said he was obeying the god, and he claimed not to know the answers himself. Some readers suspect irony: that he pretended ignorance in order to trap people. In Plato's Theaetetus he offers another picture. His mother was a midwife, and he calls himself a midwife of ideas, who helps others give birth to their own understanding rather than handing it to them.
Worked example: questioning courage
In Plato's Laches, a general named Laches tries to define courage. 1. First definition: courage is standing your ground in battle and not running away. 2. Counterexample: some soldiers fight bravely while retreating, so the definition is too narrow. 3. Second definition: courage is endurance of the soul. 4. Test: courage is always admirable, but stubborn endurance in a foolish cause is not, so not all endurance is courage. 5. Third attempt: courage is wise endurance. 6. Test: someone untrained who dives into a well seems braver than a trained diver who does the same, though the trained diver's endurance is the wiser one. 7. Result: the dialogue ends without a definition, but both sides now see the problem more clearly.
No one does wrong willingly
Socrates claimed little knowledge, but he held two striking moral views. First, no one willingly chooses what is bad for themselves. Everyone wants what is good, so people who do wrong act from ignorance: they mistakenly believe that what they do will benefit them. Second, a person who harms others harms themselves. Socrates thought the worst harm is damage to your own soul, or character, and every unjust act corrupts the soul of the one who does it. That is why, in Plato's Gorgias, he argues that doing injustice is worse than suffering it, and why, in the Apology, he says his accusers can kill him but cannot harm a good man.
Comparison: Socrates and ahimsa
Indian philosophy offers a revealing parallel. Ahimsa, Sanskrit for non-harming, is a central value in Hindu, Jain and Buddhist traditions. Jain monks and nuns take it as the first of five great vows, avoiding harm even to insects; in the twentieth century Mohandas Gandhi made it the basis of non-violent resistance to British rule. Like Socrates, these traditions teach that harming others harms the one who harms, but by a different route. For Socrates the damage is to your character now. In the Indian traditions, harmful acts create karma, consequences that bind the self to samsara, the cycle of rebirth, across lifetimes. Both also link wrongdoing to ignorance.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, Socrates did not write the dialogues; Plato did, so "Socrates says" usually means "Plato's Socrates says". Second, Socratic ignorance is not a claim to know nothing whatsoever; it is refusing to claim knowledge you lack. Third, the oracle story does not show that Socrates thought he was cleverer than everyone; it shows the limits of human wisdom. Fourth, "no one does wrong willingly" does not deny that people do wrong; it explains wrongdoing as ignorance. Fifth, the comparison with ahimsa notes a shared conclusion, not identical reasons: one tradition points to character, the other to karma and rebirth.
Key takeaways
Socrates (about 470 to 399 BCE) wrote nothing; we know him through Plato, Xenophon and Aristophanes, and the Socratic problem asks which portrait is accurate. Tried for impiety and corrupting the young, he was executed in 399 BCE, as told in Plato's Apology, Crito and Phaedo. He read the Delphic oracle as saying that human wisdom is worth little. He held that the unexamined life is not worth living, tested beliefs by elenchus, and called himself a midwife of ideas. He taught that no one does wrong willingly and that wrongdoing harms the wrongdoer, a conclusion shared, for different reasons, by Indian teachings on ahimsa.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Athenian philosopher, about 470 to 399 BCE, who wrote nothing
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why do scholars speak of a Socratic problem?
Question 2 of 5
How did Socrates finally interpret the oracle's claim that no one was wiser than he?
Question 3 of 5
Laches defines courage as standing your ground in battle. Socrates points to soldiers who fight bravely while retreating. What is Socrates doing?
Question 4 of 5
According to Socrates, why does a person who harms others harm themselves?
Question 5 of 5
What is the main difference between Socrates's harm principle and the Indian teaching on ahimsa?
