Philosophy › Section E · Logic and reasoning › Topic E.5

Informal fallacies

Most bad reasoning in the wild has nothing wrong with its form. The trouble lies in what it says: reasons that are irrelevant, too weak, quietly assumed or simply beside the point. Learning to spot these moves protects you from being persuaded by them, and from making them.

Formal and informal fallacies

A fallacy is an error in reasoning that can nonetheless seem persuasive. A formal fallacy is a defect of form, such as affirming the consequent, met in the topic "Deductive, inductive, and abductive inference". An informal fallacy depends on content: to see it, you must ask whether the reasons actually bear on the conclusion and support it well enough. Names help, but recognising the move matters more. A common scheme sorts informal fallacies into four families, by how the reasoning fails: relevance, weak induction, unwarranted assumption and diversion. Textbooks classify some fallacies differently, so focus on why each one fails.

Fallacies of relevance

Here the reasons feel relevant but have no real bearing on the conclusion. An appeal to emotion offers pity, fear or flattery in place of evidence: "Think how upset the team will be if you mark my project down." An appeal to popularity, or bandwagon, treats wide belief as proof: "Millions use this remedy, so it must work." An appeal to inappropriate authority cites someone outside their expertise, such as a film star on a heart drug, or vague unnamed "experts". Citing a genuine expert speaking within their field is different: it is reasonable evidence, though not proof.

Ad hominem

An ad hominem, Latin for "to the person", attacks the arguer instead of the argument. The abusive form insults character: "He's an idiot, so ignore his budget plan." The circumstantial form points to motives: "She only backs the bill because she works in that industry." Tu quoque, "you too", alleges hypocrisy: "You tell me to quit smoking, but you smoked for years." Each fails because an argument's strength does not depend on who offers it. One caution: when a person's testimony is itself the evidence, as with a witness in court, questioning their honesty or reliability is relevant, not fallacious.

Fallacies of weak induction

Here the evidence is relevant but too weak. A hasty generalisation rests on too few cases, while a biased sample uses unrepresentative ones, such as surveying gym members to learn how much the public exercises. An appeal to ignorance treats a lack of proof as proof: no one has shown X false, so X is true. False cause infers causation from correlation, or from mere sequence, the pattern called post hoc, "after this, therefore because of this"; ice-cream sales and drownings rise together because hot weather drives both. A slippery slope claims one step will set off a chain of consequences without supporting each link.

Fallacies of unwarranted assumption

These arguments rest on a premise that needs support but gets none. A false dilemma presents too few options: "Either we ban phones in school or grades will collapse." Its form may be a valid disjunctive syllogism; the fault lies in the premise, which ignores other possibilities. Begging the question assumes what the argument is supposed to prove, either openly in a circle, "This website is trustworthy because it says so", or by quietly taking the disputed point for granted. In everyday speech "that begs the question" often means "that raises the question", but in logic it names this fallacy.

Fallacies of diversion

These pull attention away from the real issue, usually in front of an audience. A straw man misrepresents an opponent's position, often as more extreme, then knocks down the distorted version: the original view is left untouched. A red herring changes the subject to something loosely related, as when a minister questioned about hospital waiting times talks about new road-building instead. The remedy for the straw man is the principle of charity: restate the other side's view in its strongest reasonable form before you criticise it.

Worked example: auditing a letter

A letter says: "The new cycle lane is a disaster. Its main backer, Councillor Reyes, doesn't even own a car, so what would she know about traffic? Everyone on my street hates the idea. When the town added a crossing on Elm Road last year, two shops there closed soon after. If we allow this lane, next they'll ban cars from the centre entirely." 1. Conclusion: reject the cycle lane. 2. The car remark is circumstantial ad hominem: owning a car does not change the traffic facts. 3. One street's opinion is a biased sample of the town. 4. The shops closing after the crossing is post hoc reasoning. 5. The car ban prediction is a slippery slope with no supported links. 6. What is missing: any evidence about the lane's actual effects on safety or trade.

Worked example: fallacy or fair point?

Context decides. 1. "Most geologists agree that the Earth is about 4.5 billion years old, so that is probably right." Experts speaking within their field: reasonable inductive evidence. 2. "A famous footballer says this heart drug is dangerous." Inappropriate authority. 3. "We searched every room and found no cat, so the cat is not in the house." A thorough search that would have found it: reasonable. 4. "No one has proved ghosts do not exist, so they do." Appeal to ignorance. 5. "The witness has twice been convicted of perjury, so we should doubt her testimony." Her reliability is the evidence, so this is relevant, not ad hominem. 6. Pattern: ask whether the reason really bears on the conclusion, and how strongly.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling every personal criticism ad hominem; it is fallacious only when it replaces engagement with the argument. Second, concluding that a claim is false because someone argued for it fallaciously; a bad argument can have a true conclusion. Third, confusing a straw man, which distorts the opponent's view, with a red herring, which changes the subject. Fourth, treating every appeal to authority or every absence of evidence as a fallacy. Fifth, using "begs the question" to mean "raises the question". Sixth, naming a fallacy without explaining why the reasoning fails.

Key takeaways

Formal fallacies are defects of form; informal fallacies are defects of content. Fallacies of relevance include appeals to emotion, popularity and inappropriate authority, and ad hominem attacks, including tu quoque. Fallacies of weak induction include hasty generalisation, biased samples, appeals to ignorance, false cause and slippery slopes. Fallacies of unwarranted assumption include false dilemmas and begging the question. Fallacies of diversion include the straw man and the red herring. Context matters: genuine expertise, thorough searches and doubts about a witness can be legitimate reasons.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Formal fallacy

An error in an argument's form

Affirming the consequent.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

"You tell me to eat less junk food, but you eat it all the time!" Which fallacy is this?

Question 2 of 5

"Since the new coach arrived, the team has lost four games, so the coach must be the cause." Which fallacy is most clearly committed?

Question 3 of 5

"Either we cancel the school trip completely, or a student will certainly get hurt." Which fallacy is this?

Question 4 of 5

Priya argues that school should start an hour later. Sam replies, "So Priya thinks students should sleep all day and never work." What has Sam done?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these is a reasonable use of evidence rather than a fallacy?

← Previous topicNext topic →