Philosophy › Section F · Metaphysics › Topic F.1

Substance: monism, pluralism, naturalism

Before asking what a self is or whether God exists, metaphysics asks a more basic question: what is reality ultimately made of, and how many kinds of basic thing are there? The earliest answers, from Greece and India, still shape how we think about matter, change and science.

Looking for what is really real

A wooden chair can be repainted, scratched and repaired, yet we call it the same chair. Something seems to stay put while its features come and go. Metaphysics is the part of philosophy that asks what is fundamental: what exists in its own right, what everything else depends on, and how anything can change while staying itself. The name comes from the ancient editors of Aristotle, who placed his work on "first philosophy" after (in Greek, meta) his Physics.

Substance and ontology

Substance comes from the Latin substantia, "what stands under". A substance is something that exists in its own right and bears properties, as a particular oak bears its height, colour and age. Properties exist only in a substance, and accidental ones, or accidents, can change while the substance remains. The study of what exists, and of the most general kinds of being, is ontology, from the Greek on, "being". Two of its oldest questions are how many basic kinds of thing there are, and whether the basic things are material, like water or atoms, or something else, like unchanging forms.

Monism: reality is one

Monism holds that fundamental reality is one. The Greek thinkers before Socrates, called the pre-Socratics, gave rival monist answers. In the sixth century BCE, Thales of Miletus said everything is ultimately water; Aristotle guessed that Thales noticed that nourishment and seeds are always moist. Anaximander proposed a boundless, undefined stuff, and Anaximenes chose air, which thickens into water and earth and thins into fire. Heraclitus made fire basic and stressed constant flux. Parmenides, in the early fifth century BCE, went furthest: what is not cannot exist, so being is one, whole and unchanging, and change and plurality are illusions of the senses. Monism has modern forms too: Baruch Spinoza's Ethics (1677) argued that there is only one substance, God or Nature.

Pluralism: reality is many

Pluralism holds that fundamental reality consists of many basic things or kinds. The pluralists accepted Parmenides' point that true being cannot come from nothing or vanish, but explained change as the mixing and separating of permanent ingredients. Empedocles named four roots, earth, air, fire and water, moved by the forces Love and Strife. Leucippus and Democritus, around the fifth century BCE, proposed atoms, from atomos, "uncuttable": countless tiny, unchanging bodies differing in shape, size and arrangement, moving in empty space. Colours and tastes, Democritus held, exist only in our perception; in reality there are atoms and void. Much later, René Descartes counted two kinds of created substance, mind and matter.

Atomism in Indian philosophy

Indian philosophers developed atomism independently. The Vaiśeṣika school, traditionally founded by the sage Kaṇāda, whose dates are uncertain (scholars' estimates span roughly the sixth to the second century BCE), held that physical things are made of eternal, partless atoms of four kinds: earth, water, fire and air. Unlike Democritus's atoms, each kind carries its own quality: earth has smell, water taste, fire colour and air touch. Two atoms join to form a dyad, and three dyads form a triad, the smallest visible particle. The school later merged with Nyāya, a school of logic, to form Nyāya-Vaiśeṣika.

Worked example: why division must stop

Indian atomists gave an argument from reason, not observation, for partless atoms. 1. Every visible thing has parts, and those parts have parts. 2. Suppose division never ended. Then a mountain and a mustard seed would each contain infinitely many parts. 3. Things with the same number of parts would be the same size, so the mountain would be no bigger than the seed. 4. That is absurd, so division must end in parts that have no parts: atoms. 5. Evaluate: step 3 is the weak link. Having the same number of parts does not fix size: a 2 cm line and a 1 cm line contain exactly as many points, since the points can be paired off one to one, yet one line is twice as long.

Plato: forms as true being

Plato looked for reality in what never changes. Physical things decay and differ endlessly; no drawn circle is perfectly round. Yet we recognise many different things as circles, or as beautiful, or as dogs. Plato explained this with forms: perfect, unchanging, non-physical patterns, such as Circularity itself, that particular things imitate or share in. Because everything in the physical world changes, the forms must exist apart from it, known by reason rather than the senses. This is one answer to the problem of universals, what many things of a kind share: realists say universals such as circularity really exist, while nominalists say only particular things exist. His allegory of the cave pictures ordinary people as prisoners who take passing shadows for reality, while the philosopher climbs out to see things as they are.

Aristotle: form within matter

Aristotle, Plato's student, objected that forms existing in a separate realm could not explain or cause anything in this one. In his Categories he calls individual things, such as this horse or this person, primary substances. In later works he analyses each such thing as a compound of matter and form, a view now called hylomorphism, from the Greek hyle, "wood" or "matter", and morphe, "form". The form is not elsewhere: it is the organising nature in the thing itself. Change becomes intelligible as a movement from potentiality to actuality. An acorn is potentially an oak, and its form directs its growth until it is actually one.

Worked example: the four causes of a bowl

Aristotle held that full understanding of a thing answers four questions, his four causes. Apply them to a clay bowl. 1. Material cause, what it is made of: the clay. 2. Formal cause, what makes it this kind of thing: its bowl shape and structure, which a potter could repeat in other clay. 3. Efficient cause, what brought it about: the potter shaping and firing it. 4. Final cause, what it is for: holding food. 5. Check against hylomorphism: the material and formal causes are the bowl's matter and form; the efficient and final causes explain how and why that form came to be in this clay.

Naturalism and its critics

Naturalism holds that only natural things and causes exist, the kinds that can in principle be studied by observation and science, and that no supernatural beings or forces are needed to explain anything. Methodological naturalism makes a narrower claim: inquiry should proceed as if only natural causes operate. Supernaturalism accepts beings beyond nature, such as gods or souls. Naturalism gained strength as modern science explained more without the supernatural. Critics ask whether numbers, moral values and conscious experience fit inside a purely natural inventory, a question later topics in this section take up.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, ancient atomism is not modern atomic theory: Democritus's atoms were indivisible by definition, while modern atoms have parts. Second, monism does not mean only one object exists in every version; for Thales, many things exist but all are water. Third, Plato's forms are not ideas in anyone's head; they exist independently of minds. Fourth, Aristotle did not abandon form: he relocated it inside things. Fifth, full naturalism is a claim about what exists; only methodological naturalism is a rule for inquiry.

Key takeaways

A substance exists in its own right and bears changing properties; ontology studies what exists. Monists such as Thales and Parmenides held reality to be one, and Parmenides denied change itself. Pluralists such as Empedocles and the atomists explained change by rearranging permanent ingredients. Vaiśeṣika atomism gave atoms qualities and built things from dyads and triads. Plato placed true being in separate, unchanging forms; Aristotle put form in matter, with four causes and a movement from potentiality to actuality. Naturalism admits only natural things and causes.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Substance

Something that exists in its own right and bears properties

From the Latin for "what stands under".

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which thinker argued that change and plurality are illusions because what is not cannot exist?

Question 2 of 5

How did Vaiśeṣika atoms differ from the atoms of Democritus?

Question 3 of 5

In Aristotle's analysis of a clay bowl, which cause is the potter shaping and firing it?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement would Aristotle accept but Plato reject?

Question 5 of 5

What is the main weakness in the argument that endless division would make a mountain and a mustard seed the same size?

← Previous topicNext topic →