Philosophy › Section L · Contemporary philosophy and social theory › Topic L.5
Postmodernism
Modern thought hoped that science, reason and history were leading towards universal truths. Postmodern thinkers doubted those grand stories and asked how language and power shape what counts as true. This topic sets out their main ideas, the strongest case for them and the strongest objections.
Doubting the grand stories
Modernity, in this debate, means the outlook running from the Enlightenment through Marxism: a confidence that reason and science reveal universal truths and that history is moving towards freedom. Jean-François Lyotard's The Postmodern Condition (1979) defined the postmodern as distrust of metanarratives, grand stories that claim to explain and justify everything, such as the Enlightenment tale of progress or the Marxist tale of class struggle ending in a classless society. In their place, Lyotard saw many local practices, or language games (a term borrowed from Wittgenstein), each with its own rules. Postmodernism is less a single doctrine than a family of suspicions about universal claims.
Structuralism: meaning from difference
Postmodern thought grew out of a reaction to structuralism. The Swiss linguist Ferdinand de Saussure (1857-1913), in the Course in General Linguistics (1916), compiled after his death from students' notes, treated a sign as a pairing of a signifier, a sound or mark, with a signified, a concept. The link is arbitrary: nothing about the sound "tree" resembles a tree. A word means what it does through its differences from other words in the language system, which he called langue, as distinct from parole, individual speech. Claude Lévi-Strauss applied the method to myths and kinship, seeking universal structures beneath cultural variety.
Post-structuralism: meaning that will not stay fixed
Post-structuralists kept Saussure's point that meaning comes from difference but denied that the system is stable or complete. If each sign points to other signs, meaning is always shifting and never finally pinned down. Roland Barthes's essay "The Death of the Author" (1967) argued that a text's meaning is made in reading, not settled by the author's intention. The self, too, was treated as constructed through language, upbringing and social pressure rather than given before them. Post-structuralists also suspected that structures presented as universal often reflect the interests of those who define them.
Derrida and deconstruction
Jacques Derrida (1930-2004), born in French Algeria, launched deconstruction in works such as Of Grammatology (1967). Western thought, he argued, is built on binary oppositions in which one term is privileged: speech over writing, presence over absence, reason over emotion, man over woman. Deconstruction shows that the privileged term depends on the one it excludes, which unsettles the hierarchy. His coinage différance combines the French senses of differing and deferring: meaning arises from differences and is always postponed. Derrida denied that deconstruction means anything goes; he insisted on close, careful reading.
Worked example: deconstructing "natural"
A food label praises "natural" products over "artificial" ones. 1. Identify the opposition: natural against artificial, with natural privileged as pure and safe. 2. Show the dependence: "natural" has meaning only by contrast with "artificial"; the label must invoke what it rejects. 3. Find the instability: crops shaped by thousands of years of breeding, or juice that has been pasteurised, sit on both sides of the line. 4. Reverse the hierarchy for a moment: some natural substances are poisonous, and some artificial ones save lives. 5. Conclude: the opposition does real work in marketing, but it is not a fixed fact about the world. Deconstruction exposes the hierarchy without claiming that nothing is safe.
From Nietzsche's genealogy to Foucault's power
Friedrich Nietzsche was a forerunner. On the Genealogy of Morality (1887) traced values to historical origins: he argued that ancient nobles called themselves good and the lowly bad, until the resentment of the powerless reversed this into a morality of good and evil that praised meekness. Genealogy shows that values presented as eternal have histories. Michel Foucault (1926-1984) applied it to institutions. In Discipline and Punish (1975) he traced the shift from public torture to prisons and timetables, and used Jeremy Bentham's panopticon, a prison where inmates might always be watched, as a model of power that makes people police themselves. Power, for Foucault, is everywhere and productive, and it shapes knowledge.
Worked example: monitoring software at work
A company installs software that records each employee's keystrokes and active minutes. Analyse it as Foucault might. 1. Look for surveillance: like the panopticon, staff cannot tell when a manager is looking, so they act as if always watched. 2. Look for normalisation: dashboards rank everyone against an average, defining a "normal" productive worker. 3. Look for knowledge produced by power: the data create new categories, such as "idle time", that then guide decisions. 4. Look for self-discipline: employees start timing their own breaks. 5. Conclude: no one need give orders; power works through the system. A critic would add that productivity data can also be accurate and useful.
Postmodern ideas in politics
These ideas fed political movements. Critical race theory arose in US legal scholarship in the 1970s and 1980s, with Derrick Bell and Kimberlé Crenshaw, who coined the term intersectionality in 1989. It treats race as a social construction and argues that racism has been built into law and institutions, not only into individual attitudes; it grew mainly from critical legal studies and civil-rights scholarship, with some debts to French theory. Its critics argue that it judges individuals by group identity and that its claims about systemic racism are hard to test, while defenders cite legal history. Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe (1985) proposed a radical democracy in which disagreement is never finally settled.
The case for postmodernism
Defenders argue that postmodern thinkers rarely deny that anything is true. Their point is that claims presented as universal and neutral have often hidden particular interests, as when science or law classified some peoples as inferior. Foucault's histories of prisons, madness and sexuality changed how historians study institutions. Deconstruction trained readers to notice what a text excludes. Suspicion of metanarratives, defenders add, is a sensible lesson from a century in which grand historical schemes justified terrible violence. On this view postmodernism continues the Enlightenment's critical spirit by turning it on the Enlightenment's own claims.
The strongest objections
Critics press hard. The first objection is self-refutation: the claim that there is no objective truth seems to present itself as objectively true, and distrust of all metanarratives is itself a sweeping story. Habermas, in The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (1985), argued that critics who use reason to unmask reason fall into a performative contradiction. Nancy Fraser (1981) asked how Foucault, seeing power everywhere, could say why any power is wrong. The physicist Alan Sokal's 1996 hoax, a deliberately nonsensical article accepted by the journal Social Text, was used to charge parts of the field with obscurity. Critics also fear relativism leaves no ground to call propaganda false.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating postmodernism with the bare slogan that nothing is true; most of its thinkers make narrower claims about language, history and power. Second, confusing structuralism with post-structuralism: the first seeks stable underlying systems, the second denies they are stable or complete. Third, reading deconstruction as destruction: it exposes and unsettles hierarchies within concepts. Fourth, thinking Foucault saw power only as rulers forcing subjects; he stressed power that runs through institutions and self-discipline. Fifth, assuming every critic of postmodernism is a conservative: Habermas, Fraser and Sokal all wrote from the left.
Key takeaways
Lyotard (1979) defined the postmodern as distrust of metanarratives. Saussure's structuralism found meaning in differences within a language system; post-structuralists such as Barthes argued that meaning and the self never stay fixed. Derrida's deconstruction unsettles privileged binary oppositions, and différance joins differing and deferring. Nietzsche's genealogy and Foucault's analysis of disciplinary power trace values and knowledge to history and power. Critical race theory and radical democracy drew on these ideas. Defenders see a needed critique of false universality; critics charge self-refutation, performative contradiction, obscurity and relativism.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A grand story claiming to explain and justify all of history
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did Lyotard define the postmodern in 1979?
Question 2 of 5
According to Saussure, what gives a word its meaning?
Question 3 of 5
What does a deconstruction of the opposition reason/emotion aim to show?
Question 4 of 5
Why did Foucault find Bentham's panopticon a useful model of modern power?
Question 5 of 5
What is the self-refutation objection to postmodernism?
