Philosophy › Section L · Contemporary philosophy and social theory › Topic L.4
The Frankfurt School
Why did workers in Europe turn to fascism instead of the revolution Marx predicted? A group of German thinkers set out to answer that question and built critical theory, a philosophy meant not only to explain society but to free people within it. This topic sets out its main ideas, its defenders and its critics.
A Marxist institute without orthodoxy
The Institute for Social Research in Frankfurt, Germany, was founded in 1923, funded by the wealthy socialist Felix Weil, and opened in 1924. Under Max Horkheimer (1895-1973), director from 1930, its members came to be called the Frankfurt School: Theodor Adorno, Herbert Marcuse, Erich Fromm, Friedrich Pollock and Leo Löwenthal, with Walter Benjamin closely associated. They began from Marx, as described in "The Marxist solution", but asked why his predictions had failed. When the Nazis took power in 1933 the mostly Jewish group fled, first to Geneva and then to Columbia University in New York. The institute reopened in Frankfurt in the early 1950s.
Traditional and critical theory
In his essay "Traditional and Critical Theory" (1937), Horkheimer contrasted two ideas of knowledge. Traditional theory, the model of the natural sciences, treats facts as simply given and the theorist as a neutral observer who organises them into general laws. Critical theory sees social facts as products of human activity that could be otherwise, and it admits that the theorist stands inside the society studied. Its aim is emancipation: freeing people from conditions that dominate them. On a common reading of Horkheimer, a critical theory must at once explain what is wrong with society, identify who can change it, and supply clear standards for criticism and achievable goals.
Dialectic of Enlightenment
Horkheimer and Adorno wrote Dialectic of Enlightenment in American exile; it first circulated in 1944 and was published in 1947. Its thesis is that enlightenment and myth are entangled: myth was already an early attempt to explain and control nature, and enlightenment, pushed to an extreme, turns back into a new myth. Reason narrowed into instrumental reason, the calculation of efficient means to given ends, which never asks whether the ends are good. The domination of nature then extends to the domination of people, by bureaucracy, markets and ultimately totalitarian states. Their chapter on the culture industry is discussed in the Sociology topic "Theoretical perspectives on culture".
Fromm, Marcuse and Benjamin
Several members combined Marx with Freud's psychoanalysis. Erich Fromm's Escape from Freedom (1941) argued that people cut loose from traditional ties may flee the anxiety of freedom by submitting to authoritarian leaders. Herbert Marcuse's One-Dimensional Man (1964) argued that affluent consumer societies absorb opposition by creating false needs, so people no longer imagine alternatives; the book was widely read by the student New Left. Walter Benjamin (1892-1940), in "On the Concept of History", written shortly before he died fleeing the Nazis, rejected faith in steady progress. He hoped instead for messianic moments that interrupt history's course and open new possibilities.
Worked example: two theories of one fact
Fact: most workers at a warehouse accept compulsory 10-hour shifts without complaint. 1. Traditional theory: measure acceptance, correlate it with pay and age, and predict staff turnover; the fact is taken as given. 2. Critical theory: ask why acceptance seems rational to the workers, perhaps because there are few local jobs. 3. Ask whose interests the arrangement serves and whether it could be otherwise. 4. Name the standard of criticism: for example, a life in which work does not crowd out everything else. 5. Identify agents of change, such as unions, legislators or the workers themselves. 6. Notice the difference: the second approach builds evaluation into explanation, its purpose and, critics say, its weakness.
Habermas: the public sphere and communicative action
Jürgen Habermas (1929-2026) led a second generation and took over Horkheimer's Frankfurt chair in 1964. Against Dialectic of Enlightenment, he defended a reformed Enlightenment reason. The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere (1962) traced how 18th-century coffeehouses, salons and newspapers let private citizens debate public affairs. The Theory of Communicative Action (1981) contrasts strategic action, which uses people to reach one's goals, with communicative action, aimed at mutual understanding through reasons. Speakers implicitly claim truth, rightness and sincerity, and others may challenge these claims. A norm is legitimate when all affected could agree to it in free debate, moved only by the better argument.
Worked example: a debate over a new road
A town debates a road through a park. 1. Strategic action: a developer funds fake grassroots groups and threatens to move jobs elsewhere; agreement is pushed, not reasoned. 2. Communicative action: residents, the council and the developer state their reasons in an open meeting. 3. Test the validity claims: is the traffic data true, is the plan fair to park users, are the speakers sincere about their interests? 4. Check the conditions: could everyone affected speak, and was anyone shut out or intimidated? 5. Conclude, in Habermas's terms: the decision is legitimate to the degree that it rests on reasons all could accept, not on money or pressure.
Freire's critical pedagogy
The Brazilian educator Paulo Freire (1921-1997), drawing on Marx, Hegel and Fromm among others, applied related ideas to schooling in Pedagogy of the Oppressed (written in 1968, published in English in 1970). He criticised the banking concept of education, in which teachers deposit facts into passive students. He proposed problem-posing education instead: teachers and students investigate real problems in students' lives together, asking why things are as they are. Its goal is conscientização, critical consciousness, the ability to see one's situation as changeable and to act on it. He first developed these methods teaching adult literacy in Brazil.
The case for critical theory
Defenders credit the school with asking the right questions at a dark moment: why educated, industrial societies produced fascism, and why people may consent to their own domination. It joined philosophy to empirical work, such as The Authoritarian Personality (1950), a study by Adorno and colleagues of the attitudes behind prejudice. Its warning about instrumental reason, technology serving ends no one examines, is often applied to modern bureaucracy and data-driven systems. Habermas's account of legitimacy through public reasoning helped found the theory of deliberative democracy, and Freire's pedagogy shaped adult education around the world.
The strongest objections
Critics reply sharply. In a 1961 debate known as the positivism dispute, Karl Popper argued against Adorno that claims about society as a whole must be clear and testable, and that much critical theory was neither. György Lukács (1962) mocked the first generation for despairing comfortably in a Grand Hotel Abyss, theorising about revolution without acting. Adorno's dismissal of jazz and popular culture is often called elitist, and audience research suggests people interpret media actively. Methodologists criticised The Authoritarian Personality's questionnaire design. Nancy Fraser (1990) argued that Habermas's public sphere excluded women and workers, and other critics doubt that power can ever be removed from debate.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating the Frankfurt School as a unified party line: its members disagreed, and Habermas rejected much of Dialectic of Enlightenment. Second, thinking it simply rejected reason; it attacked instrumental reason in the name of a fuller reason. Third, equating critical theory with orthodox Marxism: it questioned Marx's predictions of inevitable revolution and his neglect of culture and psychology. Fourth, confusing communicative with strategic action; persuasion by threats or bribes is strategic. Fifth, assuming the label critical theory always means this school; today it also names a wider family of approaches.
Key takeaways
The Institute for Social Research (founded 1923) developed critical theory under Horkheimer, fled the Nazis in 1933 and returned in the early 1950s. Horkheimer (1937) contrasted neutral traditional theory with emancipatory critical theory. Horkheimer and Adorno (1944, 1947) argued that instrumental reason turns enlightenment back into myth. Fromm and Marcuse joined Marx with Freud; Benjamin rejected steady progress. Habermas defended communicative reason, the public sphere and legitimacy through free debate. Freire attacked banking education. Defenders praise its questions; critics such as Popper, Lukács and Fraser charge vagueness, inaction, elitism and exclusion.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Frankfurt institute founded in 1923, home of the Frankfurt School
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did Horkheimer distinguish critical theory from traditional theory?
Question 2 of 5
What is the central thesis of Dialectic of Enlightenment?
Question 3 of 5
In Habermas's terms, which of these is communicative action?
Question 4 of 5
What did Paulo Freire mean by the banking concept of education?
Question 5 of 5
What was Nancy Fraser's criticism of Habermas's public sphere?
