Philosophy › Section B · Critical thinking, reading, and writing › Topic B.5
Reading philosophy
Philosophical texts are arguments to be followed, tested and answered, not information to be absorbed. A three-stage method, a simple annotation code and a habit of tracking whose voice is speaking will turn baffling pages into a conversation you can join.
Why philosophy is hard to read
Many students meet their first philosophy reading and find themselves rereading a paragraph three times with no clear idea of what the author thinks. That is normal. Philosophical texts are dense, use familiar words in technical senses, and move back and forth between the author's view and views the author rejects. These difficulties are predictable, so they can be met with method, and with practice you move from decoding a text to arguing with it.
A different kind of reading
A novel is read for its story and a manual for its instructions. A philosophical text is written to make you think: it poses a problem, defends a position and invites you to judge whether the defence works. So the goal is not to collect facts but to reach your own understanding of the issue, whether you end up agreeing or not. Speed should follow understanding: fast where the argument is familiar, slow where it is new. And you need not read only in order. Jumping ahead to see where an argument lands, or back to compare two claims, is often the right move.
Preparing to read
Choose a place where you can concentrate for a solid block of time, away from your phone's notifications; what counts as the right amount of quiet varies from person to person. Have a way of marking the text: a pencil on paper, or the note tools in a digital reader. Go easy on the highlighter. Reviews of study techniques have rated highlighting as one of the least useful, partly because readers tend to mark too much. Brief margin notes in a code of your own work better, for instance T for thesis, D for definition, A for argument, O for objection, R for reply and ? for something you do not understand.
Stage one: pre-read
Before reading closely, gather context. Title, author and date: who wrote this, when, and in answer to what? A sentence or two from an encyclopedia entry can place the work in its debate. Publisher and form: is this a journal article, a chapter of a book, a lecture? Structure: scan the contents page, section headings, and the first and last paragraphs, which usually state what the text sets out to do and what it concludes. References: as you learn the field, the names an author cites show which conversation they belong to.
Stage two: first read
Read once at a steady pace for the shape of the argument, without stopping at every difficulty. Look for the key claims, often signalled by phrases such as "I shall argue", "my aim is" or "it follows that". Note what support each claim gets: a logical argument, a thought experiment, an appeal to intuition or empirical evidence. Flag what you meet with your margin code, including words and passages you do not yet understand. Some flags will turn out wrong. That is fine: the first read is a sketch map, and you will correct it.
Whose voice is this?
Philosophy often proceeds by dialectic: views are set against objections and replies, so that what survives has a better claim to truth. Plato wrote in dialogues, and modern authors stage the same exchange in prose. This is a common trap for new readers, who quote a sentence as the author's view when the author was presenting a rival position in order to reject it. Watch for signals. "Some philosophers hold", "one might object" and "on this view" usually introduce someone else's position. "But", "however" and "I reply" often mark the author's response. Label each strand in the margin.
Reading with charity
The principle of charity asks you to interpret an author in the most reasonable way the text allows. If a passage seems to say something obviously foolish, first suspect your reading: check whether a term has a technical sense, whether the author is presenting a rival view, or whether the point is answered a few pages later. Assume a careful author has anticipated simple objections, and look for the answer. Charity is not agreement. It ensures that when you criticise, you criticise what the author actually argued, in its strongest form.
Worked example: tracking the dialectic
Passage (an original example): "Some say lying is always wrong because trust would collapse if everyone lied. But this shows only that lying must stay rare, not that each lie is wrong. I shall argue instead that lying is wrong when it uses the listener as a mere tool. Someone may reply that kind lies help the listener. Yet even a kind lie decides for her what she may know." 1. "Some say" introduces a rival argument: label it as a rival view. 2. "But" begins the author's criticism of it. 3. "I shall argue" gives the author's thesis: mark T. 4. "Someone may reply" raises an objection to that thesis: mark O. 5. "Yet" gives the author's reply: mark R. 6. Check: quoting the first sentence as the author's view would be a serious misreading.
Stage three: close read
Now read slowly enough to think alongside the author. Follow up your flags: look up terms and revisit unclear passages. Question the text as you go. Does this claim follow from that one? What is the evidence, and is it enough? What would the author say to an obvious objection? When something bothers you, write a one-line objection in the margin, even if you cannot yet say exactly what is wrong. Give reasons for your own reactions too. A good test of a close read is whether you can state the argument in your own words.
Worked example: reconstructing an argument
Passage (original): "If you cannot be certain you are not dreaming, you cannot be certain of anything you perceive. Nothing in experience could prove you are awake. So certainty about the world of the senses is out of reach." 1. Find the conclusion, signalled by "So": we cannot be certain of anything we perceive. 2. Premise 1: if we cannot be certain we are not dreaming, we cannot be certain of what we perceive. 3. Premise 2, restated from the middle sentence: we cannot be certain we are not dreaming. 4. Structure: if P then Q; P; therefore Q, which is valid, as the topic Arguments, validity, and soundness explains. 5. Evaluation: since the form is valid, any challenge must target a premise. Many philosophers question premise 2, as the topic Skepticism shows.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading philosophy like a novel, straight through once, and expecting to understand it. Second, highlighting whole pages instead of writing brief, coded notes. Third, quoting a view the author presents only in order to reject it. Fourth, getting stuck on every hard sentence during the first read. Fifth, dismissing an author because a passage looks foolish, without checking for a more charitable reading. Sixth, finishing a close read without being able to state the main argument in your own words.
Key takeaways
Read philosophy for arguments, at the pace understanding needs. Use a margin code rather than a highlighter. Pre-read for context and structure, first-read for the key claims and their support, then close-read to question, object and reconstruct. Track the dialectic: signal phrases show when the author is presenting a rival view, an objection or a reply. Read with charity, so that your criticism targets the strongest version of what was argued. Reconstruct arguments as premises and conclusion to see where they can be challenged.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Reading to follow, test and answer an argument
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A paragraph begins "One might object that..." and then sets out a view. What is the most likely role of that view?
Question 2 of 5
What is the main purpose of the first read in the three-stage method?
Question 3 of 5
A passage of Descartes seems to say something plainly absurd. What does the principle of charity advise first?
Question 4 of 5
"If we cannot be certain we are not dreaming, we cannot be certain of what we perceive. We cannot be certain we are not dreaming. So we cannot be certain of what we perceive." Where should a critic aim?
Question 5 of 5
Why is heavy highlighting a weak way to annotate a philosophical text?
