Philosophy › Section B · Critical thinking, reading, and writing › Topic B.6
Writing philosophy papers
A philosophy paper does one thing: it argues for a claim. Learning to choose a modest thesis, support it honestly, face the strongest objection and lay it all out clearly is the core skill of the subject, and it carries over to any writing that must persuade.
What a philosophy paper is
A philosophy paper is not a report on what philosophers said, and it is not a statement of personal opinion. It defends a specific claim with reasons, in a way a thoughtful reader who starts out unconvinced could follow and check. Summary has a place, because you must explain the views you discuss, but it serves the argument rather than replacing it. Instructors differ in their requirements, so read the assignment carefully. The advice here describes the argumentative paper that most introductory courses expect.
A thesis you can defend
The thesis is the claim your paper defends, stated as a declarative sentence. A question is not a thesis, and neither is a topic. Good theses are narrow and modest: "free will is an illusion" is too large for five pages, even for a professor, while a precise claim about one argument can be defended properly. A thesis should also go beyond description. "Descartes argues that mind and body are distinct" is true but merely reports; a thesis says something about that argument, such as where it succeeds or fails, which a reader could reasonably dispute.
Five routes to a thesis
Several kinds of thesis work well in short papers. Compare: show how two philosophers' positions differ and what follows from the difference. Criticise: identify a weak premise or piece of evidence in an argument and explain why the weakness matters. Strengthen: offer a new argument or example that supports a philosopher's position. Apply: use a philosophical view to illuminate a contemporary case and show what it reveals. Draw out an implication: show that a position commits its holder to something further, which may count for or against it. Each gives you a clear job to do.
Worked example: sharpening a thesis
Draft 1: "Mill's utilitarianism is very interesting." 1. Problem: this is a reaction, not a claim anyone could dispute. Draft 2: "Mill says some pleasures are higher than others." 2. Problem: true, but merely descriptive. Draft 3: "Mill's test for higher pleasures fails." 3. Better, but too broad: fails how? Draft 4: "I argue that Mill's test, the preference of judges who have experienced both pleasures, cannot rank pleasures by quality, because when such judges disagree Mill settles the matter by majority, which turns quality back into a count." 4. Check: it is declarative, narrow, arguable, and it names its reason. The topic Consequentialism and utilitarianism explains Mill's view.
Building the case
With a thesis in hand, return to the readings and gather support: passages to quote or paraphrase, arguments to reconstruct, examples and thought experiments. Think like a detective rather than a prosecutor. A prosecutor wants a conviction; a detective wants the truth, and will change the suspect if the evidence points elsewhere. If your evidence does not fit your thesis, revise the thesis. Where published sources run out, you can argue for yourself with counterexamples, thought experiments and intuitions, but do not let the whole paper rest on a single intuition that a reader might simply not share.
Using sources honestly
Represent every view as its holder would recognise it. Read in context and with charity, so that you never attack a straw man or bend a quotation to fit your needs. Quote sparingly, keep quotations short, and always explain what a quoted passage means and why it matters; a quotation cannot make your point for you. Cite every source you draw on, in the citation style your instructor names. Presenting someone else's words or ideas as your own is plagiarism, and many institutions treat submitting AI-generated text, where your course does not allow it, as plagiarism or a similar breach of academic integrity.
Facing the strongest objection
Philosophy papers spend more time on objections than most argumentative writing. Raising one shows you have tested your own position, and answering it removes a line of attack before a critic can use it. Choose the strongest objection you can find, not the easiest. Then reply in one of three ways: show that the objection rests on a mistake, show that it misses your actual claim, or concede part of it and narrow your thesis so that it survives. A conceded point honestly handled usually makes a paper more convincing, not less.
Worked example: an objection and reply
Model paragraph: "A defender of Mill might object that the majority vote is only a tiebreaker, used when competent judges disagree, so in most cases quality is still decided by preference. But this concedes my point. Whenever judges do disagree, the ranking is fixed by counting heads, so the test cannot by itself establish a difference in quality." Analysis: 1. The paragraph states the objection fairly, in terms Mill's defenders would accept. 2. "But" signals the reply. 3. The reply shows the objection does not remove the problem; it limits where it arises. 4. The final sentence ties the reply back to the thesis. 5. A stronger draft might add how often competent judges plausibly disagree.
Organising the paper
The structure is familiar from other writing. The introduction gives just enough context for the problem, avoiding sweeping openings about all of human history, and ends with your thesis, perhaps with a sentence previewing the steps of the argument. The body takes those steps in order, usually one main point per paragraph: explain the view, present your argument, raise an objection, reply. Signposts such as "first", "this suggests" and "one might object" keep the reader oriented. The conclusion briefly restates the thesis and how you supported it, and introduces no new arguments or evidence.
Clarity and revision
Philosophy rewards plain, precise prose. Define key terms when you introduce them and keep using them in the same sense, because switching between words such as "knowledge" and "belief" can change your argument without your noticing. Prefer short sentences to grand ones. Write a draft early enough to revise it. One useful check is a reverse outline: write one line summarising each paragraph, then see whether the lines form an argument that leads to your thesis. If a paragraph's line does not fit, cut or move that paragraph.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, writing a summary of the readings with no thesis of your own. Second, choosing a thesis so broad that a short paper can only gesture at it. Third, stating a description or a question in place of an arguable claim. Fourth, answering a weak objection while ignoring the strongest one. Fifth, letting quotations stand without explanation. Sixth, misrepresenting a source to make it easier to attack. Seventh, adding new evidence or arguments in the conclusion.
Key takeaways
A philosophy paper defends a specific, arguable claim with reasons. A good thesis is a declarative sentence, narrow, modest and beyond mere description. Useful routes are to compare, criticise, strengthen, apply or draw out an implication. Gather evidence like a detective and revise the thesis if the evidence requires it. Represent sources charitably, quote sparingly with explanation, and cite everything in the style your instructor sets. Answer the strongest objection, by refuting it, showing it misses or narrowing your claim. Introduce with context and the thesis, argue one step per paragraph, conclude without new material, and revise for clarity.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A defence of a specific claim with reasons
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these is a thesis suitable for a short philosophy paper?
Question 2 of 5
While researching, you find that the evidence does not support your thesis. What should you do?
Question 3 of 5
Which objection should a philosophy paper address?
Question 4 of 5
What belongs in the conclusion of a philosophy paper?
Question 5 of 5
A reply to an objection concedes part of it and then narrows the thesis so that it survives. How should this be judged?
