Physics › Section J · Thermodynamics › Topic J.5

Heat pumps and refrigerators

Heat never flows from cold to hot by itself, yet your refrigerator does exactly that all day. Run a heat engine backwards and it becomes a heat pump or a refrigerator, moving heat uphill in exchange for work, often delivering several joules of heating for every joule you pay for.

Moving heat uphill

The Clausius form of the second law says heat flows spontaneously only from hot to cold. It does not say heat can never go the other way, only that it will not do so on its own. Supply work and you can push heat from a cold place to a warm one. That is what refrigerators, freezers, air conditioners and heat pumps do. Each is a heat engine run backwards: instead of taking in heat at a high temperature and producing work, it takes in work and uses it to carry heat from a low temperature to a high one.

The energy flows

A refrigerator or heat pump takes in heat \(Q_c\) from the cold reservoir and work \(W\), usually from an electric motor, and delivers heat \(Q_h\) to the hot reservoir. As in the heat-engine topic, all three are positive amounts, and the arrows have simply reversed. The device works in a cycle, so \(\Delta U = 0\) for its working fluid, and energy conservation gives

Q_h = Q_c + W

The heat delivered to the warm side is always more than the work put in, because it includes the heat collected from the cold side as well.

How a heat pump works

A heat pump circulates a working fluid, a refrigerant, through four parts. In the outdoor coils, the evaporator, the fluid is colder than the outside air, so it absorbs heat \(Q_c\) even on a frosty day and boils into a gas. An electric compressor does work \(W\) on the gas, raising its pressure and temperature. In the indoor coils, the condenser, the hot gas releases heat \(Q_h\) to the room and condenses to a liquid. Finally an expansion valve lets the pressure drop, which cools the liquid before it returns outdoors. Reverse the flow and the same unit cools the house in summer.

Coefficient of performance

What matters for a heat pump is the heat delivered per joule of work you pay for, called its coefficient of performance:

\mathit{COP}_{hp} = \frac{Q_h}{W}

Because \(Q_h = Q_c + W\), this is always greater than 1. For a reversible machine it is also the reciprocal of the efficiency the same machine would have as an engine, \(\mathit{COP}_{hp} = 1/\mathit{Eff}\). Using the Carnot efficiency, an ideal heat pump has

\mathit{COP}_{hp} = \frac{T_h}{T_h - T_c}

with temperatures in kelvin. The smaller the temperature gap, the larger the COP, so heat pumps work best in mild climates.

Worked example: the best possible heat pump

To heat a house, a heat pump's indoor coils run at 50 °C and its outdoor coils at −10 °C, so that heat can flow into the fluid outside and out of it inside. What is the highest COP possible? 1. Kelvin: \(T_h = 323.15\) K and \(T_c = 263.15\) K, a gap of 60.0 K. 2. Ideal COP: \(323.15 \div 60.0 = 5.39\). 3. Meaning: an ideal pump would deliver 5.39 J of heat for each joule of electrical work, collecting 4.39 J from the cold outdoor air. 4. Check: the COP is above 1, as it must be. Real heat pumps fall below the ideal, commonly reaching about 2 to 4.

Worked example: the heating bill

A house needs heat at an average of 9.00 kW for 10.0 hours, and electricity costs $0.15 per kWh. Compare an electric resistance heater with a heat pump of COP 3.00. 1. Heat needed: \(9.00 \times 10.0 = 90.0\) kWh. 2. Resistance heater: every joule of electricity becomes one joule of heat, so it uses 90.0 kWh, costing \(90.0 \times \$0.15 = \$13.50\). 3. Heat pump: \(W = Q_h/\mathit{COP} = 90.0 \div 3.00 = 30.0\) kWh, costing \(\$4.50\). 4. Check: the other 60.0 kWh came free from the outdoor air, and \(30.0 + 60.0 = 90.0\) kWh, so energy is conserved.

Refrigerators and air conditioners

A refrigerator or air conditioner is the same machine, but its job is to remove heat from the cold side, so its coefficient of performance uses \(Q_c\):

\mathit{COP}_{ref} = \frac{Q_c}{W}

For an ideal, reversible refrigerator, \(\mathit{COP}_{ref} = T_c/(T_h - T_c)\). Since \(Q_h = Q_c + W\), a machine running between the same temperatures always has \(\mathit{COP}_{hp} = \mathit{COP}_{ref} + 1\). Real air conditioners typically reach COPs of about 3 to 4, well below the ideal. In the US, air conditioners are also rated by an energy efficiency ratio, EER, in British thermal units per hour per watt; because 1 W is 3.412 Btu/h, EER = 3.412 × COP.

Worked example: a kitchen refrigerator

Over an afternoon a refrigerator removes \(3.60 \times 10^5\) J of heat from the food inside while using \(1.20 \times 10^5\) J of electrical energy. Its coils run at −5 °C inside and 35 °C at the back. 1. Actual COP: \(3.60 \times 10^5 \div 1.20 \times 10^5 = 3.00\). 2. Heat released at the back:

Q_h = 3.60 \times 10^5 + 1.20 \times 10^5 = 4.80 \times 10^5\ \text{J}

3. Ideal COP: \(268.15 \div 40.0 = 6.70\). 4. Check: the actual value is below the ideal, as it must be. Note that the kitchen gains more heat than the food loses, so leaving the door open warms the room.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, mixing up the two COPs: a heat pump's useful output is \(Q_h\), but a refrigerator's is \(Q_c\). Second, using Celsius in the ideal formulas; a gap of 60 °C is 60 K, but \(T_h\) and \(T_c\) themselves must be in kelvin. Third, thinking a COP above 1 breaks energy conservation; the extra heat is collected from the cold side, not created. Fourth, calling COP an efficiency; efficiencies are below 1, while a heat pump's COP is above 1. Fifth, expecting an open refrigerator to cool a closed room.

Key takeaways

Heat pumps, refrigerators and air conditioners are heat engines run backwards: work W moves heat Q_c from a cold place and delivers Q_h = Q_c + W to a warm one. A heat pump's COP is Q_h/W, always above 1, and at best T_h/(T_h − T_c). A refrigerator's COP is Q_c/W, at best T_c/(T_h − T_c), and COP_hp = COP_ref + 1 between the same temperatures. All temperatures are in kelvin. Smaller temperature gaps give larger COPs. A heat pump with COP 3 uses a third of the electricity of a resistance heater.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Heat pump

A heat engine run backwards to deliver heat to a warm space

Work moves heat from cold to hot.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A heat pump delivers 12.0 kJ of heat to a house for 4.00 kJ of electrical work. What is its COP, and how much heat does it take from outdoors?

Question 2 of 5

What is the highest possible COP of a heat pump working between 0 °C outdoors and 35 °C indoors?

Question 3 of 5

A refrigerator with a COP of 4.00 removes 2000 J of heat from its interior. How much work does it use, and how much heat does it release into the kitchen?

Question 4 of 5

A refrigerator runs with its door open in a sealed, insulated kitchen. What happens to the kitchen's temperature over time?

Question 5 of 5

Run as an air conditioner, a machine has a COP of 3.50. Run between the same temperatures as a heat pump, what is its COP?

← Previous topicNext topic →