Physics › Section J · Thermodynamics › Topic J.4

Carnot's perfect heat engine

No engine can be perfect, but how close can it get? In 1824 a young French engineer found the answer, and it depends on just two numbers: how hot the heat source is, and how cold the surroundings that take the waste heat are.

How good can an engine be?

The second law says every heat engine must reject some heat, so its efficiency is below 100%. That leaves an obvious question: what is the highest efficiency possible? Sadi Carnot (1796-1832), a French engineer studying the steam engines of the Industrial Revolution, answered it in 1824. He imagined an ideal engine, now called the Carnot engine, running on a cycle built entirely from reversible processes. His result is a limit that no engine, however clever, can beat, and it gives a third way of stating the second law.

Why reversible processes win

Every irreversible effect in an engine wastes some of the opportunity to do work. Friction in bearings turns work back into heat that leaks away. Turbulence in the gas does the same. Heat that flows across a large temperature difference, say from a 1500 °C flame straight into 300 °C steam, could have driven a small engine of its own on the way, and that chance is lost. Each of these adds to the heat rejected, \(Q_c\), and lowers the efficiency. An engine that used only reversible processes would avoid all such losses, so it would be the best possible.

The Carnot cycle

The Carnot cycle has four reversible steps, two isothermal and two adiabatic. A to B: the gas expands isothermally at the hot temperature \(T_h\), taking in heat \(Q_h\) from the hot reservoir. B to C: it keeps expanding adiabatically, doing work and cooling to the cold temperature \(T_c\). C to D: it is compressed isothermally at \(T_c\), rejecting heat \(Q_c\) to the cold reservoir. D to A: it is compressed adiabatically, warming back to \(T_h\). Heat is exchanged only when the gas is at the same temperature as the reservoir, so no heat flows across a temperature difference. The net work is the area inside the loop.

The Carnot efficiency

For a Carnot engine, the heats exchanged are in the same ratio as the reservoir temperatures, measured in kelvin: \(Q_c/Q_h = T_c/T_h\). Putting this into \(\mathit{Eff} = 1 - Q_c/Q_h\) gives

\mathit{Eff}_C = 1 - \frac{T_c}{T_h}

Carnot's conclusion is the second law in a third form: no engine working between two given temperatures can be more efficient than a Carnot engine, and every reversible engine between those temperatures has exactly this efficiency. Real engines, which always contain some irreversibility, fall below it.

What the formula tells you

Efficiency would reach 100% only if \(T_c = 0\) K, and absolute zero cannot be reached, so even a perfect engine wastes heat. The ratio \(T_c/T_h\) should be as small as possible: make the hot reservoir hotter and the cold one colder. In practice the cold reservoir is the local air, a river or the sea, at around 280 to 310 K, so engineers push \(T_h\) as high as their materials allow. One catch: truly reversible steps must run infinitely slowly, so a real Carnot engine would deliver almost no power. The formula is a ceiling to measure against, not a design to copy.

Worked example: a steam power station

A power station makes steam at 540 °C and condenses it at 35 °C. What is the highest efficiency it could have? 1. Convert to kelvin: \(T_h = 540 + 273.15 = 813.15\) K and \(T_c = 35 + 273.15 = 308.15\) K. 2. Carnot efficiency:

\mathit{Eff}_C = 1 - \frac{308.15}{813.15} = 0.621

or 62.1%. 3. Compare: if the station actually runs at 40%, it achieves \(0.40 \div 0.621\), about 64% of the ideal. 4. Check: \(T_c/T_h\) is about 0.38, well below 1, so a fairly high limit is sensible.

Worked example: heat and work in a Carnot engine

A Carnot engine works between 500 K and 300 K and takes in 1800 J of heat per cycle. Find the work it does and the heat it rejects. 1. Efficiency: \(1 - 300/500 = 0.400\). 2. Work: \(W = \mathit{Eff} \times Q_h = 0.400 \times 1800 = 720\) J. 3. Heat rejected: \(Q_c = Q_h - W = 1800 - 720 = 1080\) J. 4. Check with the Carnot ratio: \(Q_c/Q_h = 1080/1800 = 0.600\), and \(T_c/T_h = 300/500 = 0.600\). They agree, as they must for a reversible engine.

Worked example: testing an inventor's claim

An inventor claims an engine that runs between 450 K and 300 K with an efficiency of 40%. Should you invest? 1. The best possible efficiency between these temperatures is \(1 - 300/450 = 0.333\), or 33.3%. 2. The claim of 40% exceeds the Carnot limit. 3. Conclusion: the engine cannot work as described, whatever its design, because it would break the second law. 4. Note that the claim does not break the first law, since 40% is below 100%. Energy conservation alone would never catch this error: you need the second law.

Small temperature differences

The Carnot limit explains why some heat sources are hard to use. A geothermal well delivering water at 150 °C, with a cold reservoir at 30 °C, gives \(1 - 303.15/423.15 = 0.284\), so at most 28.4%. Ocean thermal energy uses warm surface water at 25 °C and cold deep water at 5 °C, giving at most \(1 - 278.15/298.15 = 0.067\), under 7%, before any real losses. By contrast, a gas turbine burning fuel at well over 1000 °C has a far higher ceiling. A large temperature difference between the reservoirs is what makes heat valuable for doing work.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, using Celsius temperatures: \(1 - 35/540\) gives 93.5%, which is badly wrong; always convert to kelvin. Second, swapping the temperatures, which gives the fraction wasted, \(T_c/T_h\), instead of the efficiency. Third, treating the Carnot efficiency as what real engines achieve; it is an upper limit. Fourth, thinking a claim is fine because it is below 100%; compare it with the Carnot limit for its temperatures. Fifth, using the temperature of the fuel or the room rather than of the reservoirs the engine exchanges heat with.

Key takeaways

A Carnot engine uses only reversible processes: two isothermal and two adiabatic steps. For it, Q_c/Q_h = T_c/T_h, so its efficiency is Eff_C = 1 − T_c/T_h, with temperatures in kelvin. No engine between the same two temperatures can do better, and every reversible engine does exactly as well; this is a third form of the second law. 100% would need T_c = 0 K, which is unattainable. Higher T_h and lower T_c raise the limit, and small temperature differences give small limits. Real engines fall below the Carnot value because of irreversible losses.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sadi Carnot

French engineer who found the maximum engine efficiency in 1824

1796-1832.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What is the maximum possible efficiency of an engine working between reservoirs at 227 °C and 27 °C?

Question 2 of 5

A Carnot engine works between 600 K and 400 K and takes in 900 J of heat per cycle. How much work does it do per cycle?

Question 3 of 5

An inventor claims an engine running between 400 K and 300 K with an efficiency of 30%. What should you conclude?

Question 4 of 5

Which change would raise the maximum possible efficiency of a heat engine?

Question 5 of 5

Which processes make up a Carnot cycle?

← Previous topicNext topic →