Physics › Section T · Special relativity › Topic T.2

Simultaneity and time dilation

If every observer measures the same speed of light, they cannot all agree about time. Observers in relative motion disagree about which distant events happen together, and each finds the other's clocks running slow.

Does time depend on the observer?

Everyday experience says a time interval is the same for everyone: a race lasts 10.2 s whoever holds the stopwatch. The previous topic's second postulate breaks that assumption. Times are measured with clocks and signals, and the fastest signal, light, has the same speed \(c\) for every inertial observer. Follow that through carefully and two surprises appear. First, two events that are simultaneous for one observer need not be simultaneous for another. Second, a clock moving relative to you runs slow by your measurement. Both effects are real, measured and used in technology every day.

Simultaneity is relative

A train moves along a platform. Lightning strikes both ends of the train, leaving marks on the track. A platform observer standing midway between the marks receives both flashes together, and since both travelled equal distances at \(c\), she concludes the strikes were simultaneous. A passenger sits at the middle of the train. She moves towards the front flash and away from the rear one, so the front flash reaches her first. In her frame she is midway between the ends and both flashes travel at \(c\), so she concludes the front strike happened first. Both are right in their own frames: simultaneity of events at different places depends on the frame.

A light clock

Picture a clock made of two mirrors a distance \(D\) apart, with a light pulse bouncing between them; each round trip is one tick. Put it in a spaceship, mirrors across the direction of motion. For the astronaut beside it, the pulse goes straight across and back, so one tick lasts

\Delta t_0 = \frac{2D}{c}

An observer on Earth watches the ship pass at speed \(v\). While the pulse is in flight the mirrors move sideways, so the pulse follows a longer zigzag path. Light still travels at \(c\) in the Earth frame, by the second postulate, so the longer path must take a longer time, \(\Delta t\).

Deriving time dilation

In the Earth frame, each half of a tick takes \(\Delta t/2\). In that time light travels \(c\Delta t/2\) along a diagonal, the mirrors move \(v\Delta t/2\) sideways, and the gap across is still \(D\). By Pythagoras,

\left(\frac{c\Delta t}{2}\right)^2 = D^2 + \left(\frac{v\Delta t}{2}\right)^2

Replace \(D\) by \(c\Delta t_0/2\), multiply through by 4 and solve for \(\Delta t\):

\Delta t = \gamma \Delta t_0, \qquad \gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2}}

The Lorentz factor \(\gamma\) is never less than 1, so the Earth observer measures the longer time. Every clock in the ship, including the astronaut's heartbeat, must slow by the same factor, or she could detect her motion and break the first postulate.

Proper time and the factor γ

The proper time \(\Delta t_0\) between two events is the interval measured in the frame where both events happen at the same place, so a single clock is present at both. The astronaut's clock measures proper time for her own ticks. Any other inertial observer measures a longer, dilated interval. The factor grows slowly at first, then rapidly: \(\gamma = 1.005\) at \(0.100c\), 1.155 at \(0.500c\), 1.250 at \(0.600c\), 1.667 at \(0.800c\), 2.294 at \(0.900c\) and 7.09 at \(0.990c\). As \(v\) approaches \(c\), \(\gamma\) grows without limit, another sign that \(c\) cannot be reached.

Worked example: a fast courier ship

A ship passes Earth at \(0.800c\). Its pilot naps for 30.0 min by her own watch. How long is the nap by Earth's clocks? 1. The nap starts and ends at the pilot's seat, so 30.0 min is the proper time \(\Delta t_0\). 2. Lorentz factor:

\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1 - 0.800^2}} = \frac{1}{0.600} = 1.667

3. Earth's time:

\Delta t = \gamma \Delta t_0 = 1.667 \times 30.0\ \mathrm{min} = 50.0\ \mathrm{min}

4. Check: the Earth observer, for whom the nap starts and ends at different places, measures the longer time, as dilation requires.

Worked example: cosmic-ray muons

Cosmic rays striking the upper atmosphere create muons, unstable particles with a mean lifetime of 2.20 µs at rest. Take a muon moving at \(0.995c\). 1. Without dilation it would travel on average

0.995 \times (3.00 \times 10^8)(2.20 \times 10^{-6}) = 657\ \mathrm{m}

far too short to reach the ground from about 15 km. 2. With dilation: \(\gamma = 10.0\), so in Earth's frame its mean lifetime is \(10.0 \times 2.20 = 22.0\) µs. 3. Mean distance:

0.995 \times (3.00 \times 10^8)(22.0 \times 10^{-6}) = 6.57\ \mathrm{km}

4. Check: many muons do reach sea level, and counts at mountain tops and at sea level match the dilated lifetime, not the rest lifetime.

The twin paradox

One twin flies at \(0.800c\) to a star 4.00 light-years away by Earth's measure, turns round and returns; ignore the brief turnaround. By Earth's clocks the trip takes \(2 \times 4.00/0.800 = 10.0\) years; the traveller's clock records the proper time, \(10.0/1.667 = 6.00\) years. She comes home four years younger than her twin. Yet from her ship, Earth's clocks seem slow, so why is she the younger one? The situations are not symmetric. Her twin stays in one inertial frame, while she turns round, switching frames and feeling the acceleration. Special relativity, applied in Earth's frame, gives the answer without contradiction.

Clocks on planes and satellites

In 1971 Joseph Hafele and Richard Keating flew atomic clocks round the world on airliners, and the clocks' gains and losses matched relativity, including a gravitational effect. GPS satellites orbit at about 3.9 km/s, so special relativity makes their clocks lose about 7 µs per day. Being higher in Earth's gravity, they gain about 45 µs per day by general relativity. The net is a gain of about 38 µs per day, and the clocks are adjusted for it. Uncorrected, position errors would build up by roughly 10 km a day, since light travels about 11 km in 38 µs.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, putting the dilated time in the wrong place: \(\Delta t_0\) is always the shorter, single-clock interval, and \(\Delta t = \gamma\Delta t_0\) is longer. Second, dividing by \(\gamma\) instead of multiplying when finding the observed time. Third, forgetting the square root in \(\gamma\): at \(0.800c\) it is 1.667, not 2.778. Fourth, thinking the astronaut feels time slowing: by her own clocks everything is normal. Fifth, assuming simultaneity is absolute, or that the twin paradox needs general relativity: the turnaround breaks the symmetry. Sixth, giving the GPS correction the wrong sign: the satellite clocks run fast overall.

Key takeaways

Events simultaneous at different places in one frame need not be simultaneous in another. Proper time Δt₀ is measured by one clock present at both events. Any other inertial observer measures the longer time Δt = γΔt₀, with γ = 1/√(1 − v²/c²) ≥ 1. Moving clocks of every kind run slow. Muons with a 2.20 µs rest lifetime reach the ground because their lifetime is dilated. The travelling twin ages less because she changes frames. GPS clocks lose about 7 µs/day from motion and gain about 45 µs/day from gravity, a net gain of about 38 µs/day.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Relativity of simultaneity

Events simultaneous in one frame may not be in another

Applies to events at different places.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What is the Lorentz factor γ for a speed of 0.800c?

Question 2 of 5

A muon moving at 0.980c has a mean lifetime of 2.20 µs in its own rest frame. What is its mean lifetime measured in the laboratory?

Question 3 of 5

An astronaut in a fast ship times her own pulse. Who measures the proper time between two of her heartbeats?

Question 4 of 5

Lightning strikes both ends of a moving train at the same time according to a platform observer midway between the marks. What does a passenger at the middle of the train conclude?

Question 5 of 5

Combining special and general relativity, how do GPS satellite clocks compare with clocks on the ground?

← Previous topicNext topic →