Physics › Section T · Special relativity › Topic T.1
Einstein's postulates
In 1905 Albert Einstein rebuilt our ideas of space and time from two short statements. Everything strange in special relativity, from slowed clocks to mass as energy, follows from them by careful reasoning.
A speed everyone agrees on
Throw a ball forwards from a moving truck and someone on the pavement sees it travel faster than you threw it, because the truck's velocity adds on. The topic on relative velocity built that rule, and it works superbly for trucks, boats and aircraft. Now replace the ball with a flash of light. Experiments show that every observer measures the flash travelling at the same speed, \(c\), however fast the truck goes, with
That fact cannot fit the old rule, and resolving the clash led Einstein to special relativity, which rests on two postulates.
Reference frames and inertial frames
Every measurement of position, time or velocity is made relative to a reference frame: a set of axes and clocks attached to some object. An inertial frame is one in which Newton's first law holds, so an object with no net force on it stays at rest or moves at constant velocity. Inertial frames neither accelerate nor rotate, and any two of them move at constant velocity relative to each other. A smoothly cruising aircraft is very nearly inertial; one taking off is not, because objects inside seem pushed back by a fictitious force. The ground is close enough to inertial for most purposes.
The first postulate
Einstein's first postulate is the principle of relativity: the laws of physics are the same in every inertial frame. No experiment done entirely inside a closed laboratory, whether mechanical, electrical or optical, can tell whether it is at rest or moving at constant velocity. In a windowless train gliding along a straight, smooth track, a dropped key falls straight down and a pendulum swings exactly as on the platform. So there is no absolute rest and no preferred frame. Galileo and Newton had applied this to mechanics; Einstein insisted that it holds for electricity, magnetism and light as well.
Light and the search for the ether
In the 1860s James Clerk Maxwell's equations of electricity and magnetism predicted electromagnetic waves travelling at the measured speed of light, so light was identified as an electromagnetic wave. Every wave then known needed a medium, as sound needs air, so physicists assumed light travels through an invisible medium filling space, the luminiferous ether. Earth orbits the Sun, so it should be moving through the ether, and light should travel at slightly different speeds in different directions relative to us. Measuring that difference would reveal Earth's motion through the ether.
The Michelson-Morley experiment
In 1887 Albert Michelson and Edward Morley looked for this effect with an interferometer, which splits a light beam in two, sends the halves along perpendicular arms and recombines them. Any difference in travel time shifts the interference fringes. Rotating the apparatus should have moved the fringes by about 0.4 of a fringe. They saw less than about 0.02 fringe, consistent with no shift at all. This null result found no sign of Earth's motion through an ether, and later, more precise versions agree: light travels at the same speed in every direction, whatever Earth's motion.
Worked example: how small was the effect?
Why was such a delicate instrument needed? Find Earth's orbital speed as a fraction of \(c\), assuming a circular orbit of radius \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m and a period of 365.25 days. 1. Period: \(T = 3.156 \times 10^7\) s. 2. Orbital speed:
3. Fraction of \(c\):
4. The predicted timing difference depends on \((v/c)^2\), about \(1 \times 10^{-8}\), so only an interference method could detect it. Check: 30 km/s is fast by everyday standards, yet about one ten-thousandth of \(c\).
The second postulate
Einstein's second postulate states that light in a vacuum travels at the same speed \(c\) in every inertial frame, independent of the motion of its source or of the observer. He reached it mainly by trusting Maxwell's equations, which by the first postulate must hold in every inertial frame and so give the same speed of light in all of them. Light needs no medium. The value is now exactly 299,792,458 m/s, because the metre is defined from it; this course uses 3.00 × 10⁸ m/s. The postulate forces observers in relative motion to disagree about times and lengths, as the next topics show.
Worked example: a beam from a fast ship
A spaceship moves directly towards Earth at \(0.600c\) and fires a laser pulse forwards, then a second pulse backwards. Compare the old rule with the second postulate. 1. Take the direction towards Earth as positive. 2. Simple addition, forward pulse: \(c + 0.600c = 1.600c\), or \(4.80 \times 10^8\) m/s. 3. Simple addition, backward pulse: \(-c + 0.600c = -0.400c\), a speed of \(1.20 \times 10^8\) m/s. 4. Second postulate: both pulses travel at \(3.00 \times 10^8\) m/s relative to Earth, one towards it and one away. Measurements on fast-moving sources confirm this. Check: the crew also measure both pulses at \(c\), so all inertial observers agree.
Light in matter and the speed limit
The postulate is about light in a vacuum. Matter slows light: in a material of refractive index \(n\) it travels at \(v = c/n\), as the optics topics showed. In water, with \(n = 1.33\),
so light takes about 4.43 ns to cross 1.00 m of water instead of 3.33 ns in vacuum. The vacuum speed is unchanged, so the postulate stands. Relativity also makes \(c\) a speed limit: no object with mass can be accelerated to it, as a later topic shows.
Where relativity matters
Special relativity is built on inertial frames, though it can still describe accelerating objects as seen from one; Einstein's general relativity of 1915 extends it to accelerated frames and gravity. At everyday speeds special relativity and Newtonian mechanics agree to many decimal places, and the differences become noticeable only above about 1% of \(c\), or \(3 \times 10^6\) m/s. That is why Newton's laws still put satellites in orbit. Even so, particle accelerators, cosmic-ray particles and the clocks on navigation satellites all behave as relativity predicts. Newtonian physics is a superb low-speed approximation to relativity.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, adding the source's speed to the speed of light: light from a fast ship still travels at \(c\) for every observer. Second, saying the speed of light can never change: it is lower in matter, and only the vacuum speed is universal. Third, overstating Michelson-Morley: it found no ether drift and is consistent with the second postulate, but Einstein based the postulate mainly on electromagnetic theory. Fourth, calling an accelerating or rotating frame inertial. Fifth, reading the first postulate as "everything is relative": the laws of physics, and \(c\), are what all inertial observers agree on.
Key takeaways
An inertial frame is one where Newton's first law holds; it neither accelerates nor rotates. First postulate: the laws of physics are the same in all inertial frames, so uniform motion cannot be detected from inside and there is no absolute rest. Second postulate: light in a vacuum travels at c = 3.00 × 10⁸ m/s in every inertial frame, whatever the motion of source or observer. The 1887 Michelson-Morley experiment found no motion through an ether, consistent with this. Light is slower in matter, v = c/n. Relativity matters above about 1% of c.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A set of axes and clocks from which positions, times and velocities are measured
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these is the best example of an inertial reference frame?
Question 2 of 5
A spaceship approaching Earth at 0.500c fires a laser pulse backwards, away from Earth. At what speed do Earth observers measure the pulse travelling?
Question 3 of 5
What did the Michelson-Morley experiment of 1887 find?
Question 4 of 5
Using c = 3.00 × 10⁸ m/s, what is the speed of light in glass of refractive index 1.50?
Question 5 of 5
You are in a sealed, windowless cabin moving at constant velocity. What does the first postulate say about finding your speed?
