Psychology › Section L · Social psychology › Topic L.3
Attitudes and persuasion
Attitudes change in two directions: other people persuade us from outside, and our own actions pull our beliefs into line from inside. This topic covers both, from the one-dollar experiment to the two routes every advertiser relies on.
What an attitude is
An attitude is an evaluation of a person, object, group or idea, usually favourable or unfavourable. It has three components, the ABC of attitudes. The affective component is feeling ('Recycling makes me feel responsible'). The behavioural component is the tendency to act ('I sort my rubbish every week'). The cognitive component is belief ('Recycling saves resources'). The three usually line up, but not always: someone can believe exercise is good for them, feel bored by it and still skip the gym.
When attitudes predict behaviour
In the early 1930s Richard LaPiere toured the United States with a young Chinese couple, at a time of widespread prejudice against Chinese people. They were refused service only once at about 250 hotels and restaurants. Yet when LaPiere later wrote to the same businesses, more than 90% of those that replied said they would not serve Chinese guests. Later research found that attitudes predict behaviour best when the attitude is specific to the behaviour, strong and easily brought to mind, and when outside pressures are weak.
Cognitive dissonance
Leon Festinger (1957) proposed that holding two inconsistent cognitions (beliefs, attitudes or knowledge of our own behaviour) creates an unpleasant tension he called cognitive dissonance. Dissonance is strongest when the inconsistency threatens our view of ourselves as sensible and good. Because it feels bad, we are motivated to reduce it. A smoker who knows smoking causes cancer can change the behaviour (quit), change a belief ('the risks are exaggerated'), add a new cognition ('it keeps my weight down') or trivialise the conflict ('everyone dies of something'). Changing the behaviour is often the hardest, so people frequently change their attitudes instead.
The one-dollar experiment
Leon Festinger and James Carlsmith (1959) gave students an hour of dull tasks, such as turning pegs on a board. Each was then paid either $1 or $20 to tell the next participant that the tasks had been enjoyable. Later, those paid $1 rated the tasks as more enjoyable than those paid $20 or those who told no lie. The explanation is insufficient justification. Twenty dollars was a good reason to tell a small lie, so there was little dissonance. One dollar was not, so the only comfortable way to explain the lie was to decide the task had not been so bad after all.
Effort, choices and dissonance
Dissonance also explains justification of effort: we value what we have suffered for. Elliot Aronson and Judson Mills (1959) had students undergo no initiation, a mild one or an embarrassing one to join a discussion group, then listen to a deliberately dull discussion. Those with the harsh initiation rated the group more favourably. After hard choices, people also rate the chosen option higher and the rejected one lower (Jack Brehm, 1956). Daryl Bem's self-perception theory (1967) offers an alternative: when attitudes are weak, we may simply infer them from our own behaviour.
Persuasion: source, message and audience
Persuasion is changing someone's attitudes through communication. After the Second World War, Carl Hovland's group at Yale studied it systematically. Source: communicators who seem expert and trustworthy persuade more, and attractive or likeable speakers help too, which is why adverts use celebrities. Message: a two-sided message that admits and answers counterarguments tends to work better on audiences who already disagree or know the topic well. Timing matters too: if two opposing speeches come back to back and the decision comes later, the first tends to win; if there is a gap between them and the decision follows at once, the second tends to win. Audience: attitudes appear most open to change in late adolescence and early adulthood.
The elaboration likelihood model
Richard Petty and John Cacioppo's elaboration likelihood model (1986) says persuasion follows one of two routes, depending on how much the audience thinks about the message. On the central route, people who are motivated (the topic matters to them) and able (they have time, knowledge and no distractions) weigh the arguments, so only strong arguments work. On the peripheral route, people who are unmotivated or unable respond to cues such as a speaker's fame, attractiveness, background music or the sheer number of arguments. Central-route change lasts longer, resists counterarguments and predicts behaviour better; peripheral-route change is quicker but fragile.
Foot in the door and door in the face
In the foot-in-the-door technique, agreeing to a small request makes people more likely to agree to a larger one later. Jonathan Freedman and Scott Fraser (1966) found that about three quarters of homeowners who had agreed to a small safe-driving request later accepted a large, ugly 'Drive Carefully' sign in their front gardens, compared with fewer than one in five of those asked directly. The effect fits a desire to stay consistent with what we have already done. The door-in-the-face technique reverses the order: after refusing an outrageous request, people more readily accept a moderate one, which feels like a concession.
Worked example: dissonance after a purchase
Marcus spends $1,200 on a laptop. A week later a friend shows him a cheaper model with better reviews. 1. Identify the cognitions: 'I make smart choices' and 'I paid more for a worse laptop'. They clash, so he feels dissonance. 2. Option one, change behaviour: return the laptop, if the shop allows it. 3. Option two, change a belief: 'reviews don't matter; mine has a better keyboard'. 4. Option three, add a cognition: 'my brand's after-sales service is excellent'. 5. Predict: if returning it is impossible, dissonance theory expects him to rate his laptop more highly than before. 6. Check: the purchase was freely chosen and costly, both conditions that strengthen dissonance.
Worked example: which route is this campaign using?
Two campaigns promote the same electric car. 1. Campaign A shows the car gliding past a sunset while a famous singer smiles from the driver's seat, with no figures. These are peripheral cues, aimed at viewers who will not think hard. 2. Campaign B is a comparison table of range, charging time and running costs, sent to people who have booked a test drive. That is a central-route message for motivated, able readers. 3. Predict: Campaign A may lift liking quickly; Campaign B's converts should hold their view longer and resist a rival's counterclaims. 4. Check: Campaign B fails if its arguments are weak, because careful readers notice.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming attitudes always predict behaviour: they predict best when specific, strong and free of outside pressure. Second, reversing the one-dollar result: the smaller payment produced the greater attitude change. Third, treating the peripheral route as stupidity: everyone uses it when they lack the time or motivation to think. Fourth, thinking central-route persuasion always works: weak arguments fail on the central route. Fifth, mixing up the two compliance techniques: foot in the door starts small, door in the face starts big.
Key takeaways
An attitude is an evaluation with affective, behavioural and cognitive components, and it predicts behaviour best when specific, strong and free of outside pressure. Cognitive dissonance (Festinger, 1957) is the tension of inconsistent cognitions, reduced by changing behaviour, changing beliefs or adding cognitions. Insufficient justification ($1 versus $20) and justification of effort both produce attitude change. The Yale approach studies source, message and audience. The elaboration likelihood model separates the central route (strong arguments, lasting change) from the peripheral route (cues, fragile change). Foot in the door starts with a small request; door in the face starts with a large one.
Flashcards
Flashcard
An evaluation of a person, object, group or idea
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In Festinger and Carlsmith's experiment, why did people paid $1 later rate the dull task as more enjoyable than people paid $20?
Question 2 of 5
A voter with plenty of time and a strong personal stake reads a detailed policy comparison and changes her view. According to the elaboration likelihood model, the change is likely to be:
Question 3 of 5
The statement 'I feel anxious whenever I am near dogs' expresses which component of an attitude?
Question 4 of 5
A charity asks you to sign a short petition, then a week later asks you to volunteer for a whole day. Which technique is it using?
Question 5 of 5
What did LaPiere's travels with a Chinese couple in the early 1930s suggest?
