Psychology › Section L · Social psychology › Topic L.2

Self-presentation and social roles

You act differently in a job interview, at a family meal and in a group chat, and that is normal. Roles, norms and scripts tell us how to perform in each setting, and one famous study claimed they can even turn people cruel.

Life as a series of performances

In 1959 the sociologist Erving Goffman described everyday life as a kind of theatre. In front-stage settings, such as a job interview or a classroom, people perform for an audience and manage how they come across. Back stage, among close friends or alone, they relax the performance. Self-presentation is this effort to control the impression we make on others. It is not the same as being fake: everyone adjusts how they speak, dress and act to suit the setting. This topic looks at the forces that guide those performances, roles, norms and scripts, and at a famous study of roles.

Impression management and self-monitoring

Impression management uses many tactics: ingratiation (flattering or agreeing, to be liked), self-promotion (highlighting abilities, to seem competent), and choosing clothes, posts or photos that fit the image we want. People differ in how much they do this. Mark Snyder (1974) called the trait self-monitoring. High self-monitors watch the situation closely and adjust their behaviour to fit it, so they may act quite differently at a party and at a funeral. Low self-monitors behave more consistently across settings, guided mainly by their own attitudes and feelings. Neither style is simply better; each has costs and benefits.

Social roles

A social role is the set of behaviours expected of someone in a particular position within a group, such as student, parent, team captain, nurse or customer. Each person holds several roles at once, and the expectations are shared within a culture, so most people know how a teacher or a goalkeeper is meant to act. Roles guide behaviour so strongly that the same person can seem playful at a family meal and serious at work. When two roles make incompatible demands, as when a working student's shift clashes with an exam, the result is role conflict.

Social norms

Social norms are a group's shared expectations about how its members should think and behave. Robert Cialdini distinguishes descriptive norms, what most people actually do, from injunctive norms, what people approve or disapprove of. Descriptive norms are powerful nudges. In a hotel study by Noah Goldstein, Cialdini and Vladas Griskevicius (2008), cards telling guests that most previous guests had reused their towels led to more reuse than cards appealing to protect the environment. Norms differ between families, schools, workplaces, online communities and countries, and we often notice them only when someone breaks one.

Scripts

A script is our knowledge of the expected sequence of events in a familiar setting (Roger Schank and Robert Abelson, 1977). A restaurant script runs roughly: wait to be seated, read the menu, order, eat, ask for the bill, pay and leave. Scripts free our attention and tell us what to do next without thinking. They also vary across cultures: in the United States diners are expected to add a tip of roughly 15 to 20%, while in Japan tipping is uncommon and can cause confusion. Entering a setting with no script, such as a first visit to an unfamiliar religious service, often feels awkward until we watch what others do.

The Stanford prison experiment: the classic account

In August 1971, Philip Zimbardo and colleagues turned a basement corridor of Stanford University's psychology building into a mock prison. About two dozen male college students, screened for psychological and medical problems and paid $15 a day, were randomly assigned to be guards or prisoners. Prisoners were 'arrested' at home by local police and given numbers and smocks; guards wore uniforms and mirrored sunglasses, and Zimbardo acted as prison superintendent. Within days some guards were humiliating prisoners, and several prisoners showed acute distress. The study, planned for two weeks, was stopped after six days, after the graduate student Christina Maslach objected to what she saw.

The Stanford prison experiment: what the critiques found

For decades the study was taught as proof that roles alone can make ordinary people cruel. Critiques have since undercut that claim, especially in 2018, when Thibault Le Texier published archival research and the journalist Ben Blum published interviews and recordings. Guards had been briefed to make prisoners feel powerless, and a member of the research team pressed a reluctant guard to be tougher. Only some guards became abusive, and one prisoner later said he had faked his famous breakdown. The newspaper advertisement, which mentioned prison life, may have attracted more aggressive volunteers (Carnahan and McFarland, 2007), and the BBC Prison Study (Reicher and Haslam, 2006) did not find guards drifting into tyranny.

Worked example: reading a new situation

Leila starts a part-time job at a café. Identify the social forces guiding her first shift. 1. Role: as a barista she is expected to greet customers, work quickly and stay polite, even when tired. 2. Injunctive norm: the manager says phones stay in lockers during shifts. 3. Descriptive norm: she notices colleagues wiping tables whenever they pass, so she starts doing it too. 4. Script: each order follows a sequence, greet, take the order, take payment, call the name. 5. Self-presentation: she smiles more than usual and mentions her past job, managing the impression she makes. 6. Check: none of these depends on her personality; each comes with the setting.

Worked example: weighing the prison study as evidence

Ask what the Stanford prison study can and cannot show. 1. Claim: assigned roles, by themselves, lead ordinary people to abuse power. 2. Strength: random assignment means guards and prisoners did not differ systematically at the start. 3. Weakness: there was no comparison group, and the guards' briefing signalled what was expected, so demand characteristics (behaving as participants think researchers want) may explain the results. 4. Weakness: the lead researcher also ran the prison, so he was not a neutral observer. 5. Replication: the BBC study, with a different design, found different results. 6. Verdict: the study shows how settings and leaders can encourage abuse, but it cannot isolate roles as the cause. It was later cited to explain the abuse of detainees at Abu Ghraib in Iraq in 2003 and 2004, where official inquiries also blamed failures of leadership.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, equating self-presentation with lying: adjusting to a setting is normal. Second, confusing roles (expected behaviour for a position), norms (a group's expectations for its members) and scripts (expected sequences of events). Third, citing the Stanford prison study as a well-controlled experiment proving that roles alone cause cruelty: it lacked a control group, the guards were steered, and a later study found different results. Fourth, saying that all the guards became brutal: only some did. Fifth, assuming norms are universal: customs for tipping, greeting and queuing vary between cultures.

Key takeaways

Goffman described self-presentation as a performance, with a front stage and a back stage. Impression management includes ingratiation and self-promotion, and high self-monitors adjust to situations more than low self-monitors (Snyder, 1974). A social role is the behaviour expected in a position, and roles can conflict. Social norms are shared expectations, either descriptive (what people do) or injunctive (what people approve). Scripts are expected sequences of events and vary by culture. Zimbardo's 1971 Stanford prison study was stopped after six days, but critiques, especially those of 2018, showed that guards were steered and some participants played up, and the BBC Prison Study found otherwise. It is now taught as a flawed demonstration.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Self-presentation

Efforts to control the impression we make on others

Adjusting to a setting, not necessarily lying.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Jordan is quiet and formal at a dinner with his manager, then loud and joking at a football match an hour later, tailoring his behaviour to each crowd. In Snyder's terms, Jordan is:

Question 2 of 5

Hotel cards saying that most guests reuse their towels increased reuse more than cards about protecting the environment. What did the more effective cards use?

Question 3 of 5

Knowing that at a cinema you buy a ticket, find your seat, sit through the trailers and then watch the film is an example of:

Question 4 of 5

Which finding from later critiques most weakens the claim that roles alone made the Stanford guards cruel?

Question 5 of 5

A student nurse is asked by a close friend to share details about a patient. The clash between being a loyal friend and a professional is best described as:

← Previous topicNext topic →