Psychology › Section I · Lifespan development › Topic I.4
Death and dying
Every life story ends, and how people die and grieve is shaped by medicine, law, culture and personal belief. This topic covers how death is defined, how hospice and palliative care changed dying, what the research says about the famous five stages, and how people plan ahead.
A changing view of death
Cultures differ widely in how openly they face death and how they mourn: through funerals, cremation, set periods of mourning, or rituals that keep the dead part of family life. In the mid-20th-century United States, most people died in hospitals or other institutions, and doctors often did not tell patients they were dying. Since the 1960s that has changed. Patients now usually expect to be told their diagnosis, many choose to die at home, and psychology studies dying and grief as part of lifespan development. This topic is general education, not medical or legal advice.
Defining death
Ventilators, which can keep a heart beating after the brain has stopped working, made death harder to define. In the United States, the Uniform Determination of Death Act (1981), whose standard every state now accepts in some form, recognises two definitions: the irreversible stopping of circulation and breathing, or the irreversible loss of all functions of the entire brain, including the brainstem. Brain death is not the same as a coma or a vegetative state, in which the brainstem still works and the person may breathe unaided. Doctors confirm brain death with strict clinical tests set out in national guidelines.
The hospice movement
Cicely Saunders, a British nurse, social worker and doctor, founded St Christopher's Hospice in London in 1967, the first modern hospice. In 1974 Florence Wald, a nursing professor at Yale, helped found the first US hospice in Connecticut. Hospice care aims at comfort and dignity rather than cure: careful control of pain and other symptoms, emotional and spiritual support, and help for the family, including after the death. Most hospice care in the United States is given at home. To qualify under Medicare, doctors must certify that the patient is likely to live six months or less if the illness runs its usual course.
Palliative care and the evidence
Palliative care is the wider idea: relief of symptoms and stress for anyone with a serious illness, at any stage, alongside treatment aimed at cure. Hospice is palliative care for the final months, when curative treatment has stopped. Families of hospice patients often report better symptom control and more satisfaction with care. In a well-known trial, Jennifer Temel and colleagues (2010) gave people newly diagnosed with advanced lung cancer early palliative care alongside standard treatment; they reported better quality of life and fewer depressive symptoms, and on average lived somewhat longer, despite choosing less aggressive care at the end of life.
Kübler-Ross's five stages
Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, a Swiss-American psychiatrist, interviewed many terminally ill patients and in 1969 published On Death and Dying. She described five reactions to learning one is dying. Denial: "This can't be happening." Anger: "Why me?" Bargaining: trying to postpone death, often through promises. Depression: sorrow at what will be lost. Acceptance: a calmer readiness. Her book changed medical culture by insisting that dying people be listened to. The stages were later applied to grief after any loss. Kübler-Ross herself said that people do not necessarily pass through every stage or follow this order.
What the research says about the stages
As a fixed sequence that everyone passes through, the five stages are not supported by research. The best-known test, the Yale Bereavement Study (Maciejewski and colleagues, 2007), surveyed about 230 people over two years after a loved one's death from natural causes. Disbelief, yearning, anger and depression did each peak at roughly the times the model suggests, but acceptance was the strongest response from the first month onward, and yearning, not depression, was the main negative feeling. The feelings overlapped instead of taking turns. Researchers now treat the stages as common reactions, not a timetable.
How people actually grieve
George Bonanno's studies of bereaved adults found several paths. Resilience, a fairly stable level of functioning with brief periods of distress, was the most common, often shown by around half of participants. Others showed recovery over months, and a minority intense grief that lasted. The dual process model (Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut, 1999) describes healthy grieving as moving back and forth between facing the loss and attending to daily life, with breaks from grief being normal. Many people keep continuing bonds with the dead, through memories or rituals, which can be healthy. Faith and social support help many cope, and when grief stays intense and disabling, professional support can help.
Planning ahead: advance directives
Advance directives let people state their wishes for medical care in case they cannot speak for themselves. A living will records which treatments a person would or would not want, such as mechanical ventilation or tube feeding near the end of life. A health care proxy, also called a durable power of attorney for health care, names a person to make medical decisions on the patient's behalf. A do-not-resuscitate (DNR) order is a medical order, signed by a doctor (or, in some states, another authorised clinician) in line with the patient's or proxy's wishes, telling staff not to attempt CPR if the heart or breathing stops. Rules differ by state, and choices reflect religion, culture and family.
Worked example: "She's stuck in denial"
Two months after her husband died, Rosa keeps working, laughs with friends, and cries some evenings. A relative says she is "stuck in denial" and "needs to reach the anger stage". 1. Assumption: grief follows fixed stages in order, which research does not support. 2. Evidence: Rosa grieves at times and functions well at others, fitting the dual process model and the common resilient pattern. 3. Missing stage: no one is required to feel anger. 4. Conclusion: her grief looks typical, and the advice could make her feel she is grieving wrongly. 5. Check: if grief became intense and disabling for a long time, a professional, not a stage chart, should assess it.
Worked example: matching the documents
Mr Okafor, 78, has advanced heart failure. He wants no breathing machine at the end, wants his daughter to decide if he cannot, and does not want CPR. 1. "No breathing machine" is a treatment preference written in advance: a living will. 2. "My daughter decides" names a decision-maker: a health care proxy. 3. "No CPR" needs a DNR order, which his doctor signs after discussing it with him. 4. Care: if he chooses comfort-focused care and his doctor expects him to live six months or less, hospice could support him at home. 5. Check: each tool does a different job, and state forms differ, so families usually complete them with a doctor or lawyer.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating Kübler-Ross's stages as a fixed sequence that everyone must complete; even she rejected that reading. Second, thinking a lack of visible distress means grief is unhealthy or delayed: resilience is common. Third, confusing hospice, for the final months, with palliative care, which can begin at diagnosis alongside cure-focused treatment. Fourth, assuming a living will and a DNR order are the same document. Fifth, confusing brain death with a coma or vegetative state. Sixth, assuming one culture's way of mourning is the right way.
Key takeaways
Views of death vary across cultures and have moved since the 1960s towards openness and dying at home. US law defines death as irreversible loss of circulation and breathing or of all brain function (1981). Cicely Saunders founded the first modern hospice (1967), Florence Wald the first US one (1974); hospice offers comfort-focused care, while palliative care can start at diagnosis. Kübler-Ross (1969) described denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance, but research does not support them as fixed stages. Resilience is a common response to loss, and grief moves between loss and daily life. Living wills, health care proxies and DNR orders do different jobs.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Death = irreversible loss of circulation and breathing, or of all brain function
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best reflects current research on Kübler-Ross's five stages?
Question 2 of 5
What is the main aim of hospice care?
Question 3 of 5
A woman wants her son to make medical decisions for her if she cannot. Which document does this?
Question 4 of 5
How does palliative care differ from hospice care?
Question 5 of 5
According to Stroebe and Schut's dual process model, healthy grieving involves:
