Psychology › Section J · Emotion and motivation › Topic J.1
Motivation
Why does one student revise for hours while another cannot start? Motivation is the study of what gets behaviour going, points it at a goal and keeps it there, and psychologists have proposed several competing answers.
What gets behaviour going
Motivation is the set of needs and wants that start behaviour, direct it towards a goal and keep it going. Some motives are biological, such as hunger and thirst. Others are psychological, and here psychologists draw one central distinction. Intrinsic motivation comes from inside: you do something because the activity itself is satisfying, as when you read a novel for pleasure. Extrinsic motivation comes from outside: you act to gain a reward or avoid a penalty, as when you read the same novel because it is on the exam. Most real behaviour mixes the two, and the mix can shift over time.
Instincts and drives
Early theories looked for biological causes. William James (1842-1910) argued that human behaviour is driven by many instincts, which are unlearned, species-typical patterns of behaviour. The idea faded because rival theorists produced conflicting lists of instincts, and because so much human behaviour turned out to be learned. Naming a behaviour an instinct also explains nothing new. Drive-reduction theory took its place. When the body drifts from homeostasis, its balanced internal state, a physiological need arises and creates a drive, an unpleasant state that pushes us to act. Low blood sugar produces hunger, and eating reduces it. Behaviours that successfully reduce a drive tend to become habits.
Arousal and the Yerkes-Dodson law
Drive reduction cannot explain why a well-fed, rested person seeks out a roller coaster. Arousal theory adds that people try to keep arousal at an optimal level, seeking excitement when bored and calm when overstimulated. Performance follows the same pattern, rising from low to moderate arousal and falling again when arousal is very high. The Yerkes-Dodson law, named after a 1908 study of mice learning discriminations of differing difficulty, adds that the best level depends on the task. Simple, well-practised tasks are done best at relatively high arousal; difficult or unfamiliar tasks are done best at lower arousal. Modern researchers treat this as a useful general pattern rather than a precise law.
Worked example: the same nerves, two tasks
An athlete is highly keyed up before a meet. She must sprint 100 metres in the morning and sit a complicated chemistry test in the afternoon. Predict her performance. 1. Identify the arousal level: high. 2. Classify the first task: sprinting is simple and heavily practised, so its optimal arousal is relatively high. 3. Predict: her nerves are likely to help, or at least not hurt, the sprint. 4. Classify the second task: a complex test needs careful reasoning and working memory, so its optimal arousal is lower. 5. Predict: unless she calms down, high arousal is likely to hurt the test. 6. Check: the same arousal level gives opposite predictions, which is exactly the Yerkes-Dodson claim.
Self-efficacy and social motives
Albert Bandura argued that self-efficacy, your belief that you can carry out a particular task, is a powerful motivator. People with high self-efficacy for a task choose harder goals and keep going after setbacks; past success on similar tasks is a major source of that belief. Other researchers, including Henry Murray, David McClelland and Dan McAdams, studied social motives: the need for achievement drives people to master challenges, the need for affiliation draws them to friendly contact, and the need for intimacy draws them to deep, close relationships. Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary (1995) argued that the need to belong is a fundamental human motive, and loneliness is linked to poorer health.
Maslow's hierarchy of needs
Abraham Maslow (1943) proposed that needs form a hierarchy. From the bottom: physiological needs such as food and sleep; safety and security; love and belonging; esteem, meaning self-worth and recognition; and at the top self-actualisation, fulfilling your potential. In his view, lower needs must largely be met before higher ones take priority, and few people fully self-actualise. Late in life he described a further level, self-transcendence: serving purposes beyond yourself. The famous pyramid was drawn by later writers, not by Maslow. Critics point to people who pursue meaning while hungry or in danger, such as hunger strikers, and a 2011 survey across 123 countries found that the needs mattered everywhere but were not satisfied in a strict order.
When rewards backfire
Paying people for something they already enjoy can reduce how much they do it once the payments stop. This is the overjustification effect: an extrinsic reward gives people a new reason for the activity, and intrinsic interest falls. A large 1999 review of more than 100 experiments by Edward Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard Ryan found the effect mainly for tangible rewards, such as money or prizes, that were expected and depended on doing the task. Verbal praise that gives information about skill tended to raise intrinsic motivation, and unexpected rewards did little harm. Some researchers argued the effects were smaller than claimed, so the details are still debated.
Self-determination and goals
Self-determination theory, developed by Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, says people thrive and stay intrinsically motivated when three needs are met: autonomy (choice over what you do), competence (feeling capable) and relatedness (feeling connected to others). Classrooms that offer choice, respect and challenging but achievable work tend to foster intrinsic motivation; harsh public grading tends to undermine it. Specific, challenging goals with feedback usually beat vague goals such as "do your best". Implementation intentions, plans of the form "when X happens, I will do Y", help people follow through. Angela Duckworth's idea of grit, passion and perseverance for long-term goals, is popular, but a 2017 review found it overlaps heavily with conscientiousness.
Worked example: a hobby becomes a job
Theo builds levels for a video game in his spare time because he enjoys it. A studio starts paying him a fixed fee for each level, with deadlines and a manager who rejects levels without explanation. After a year the contract ends, and Theo rarely builds levels for fun any more. Analyse it. 1. Starting motive: intrinsic, since he built levels with no reward. 2. Change: an expected, tangible reward tied to the task, the condition most linked to overjustification. 3. Self-determination: deadlines and unexplained rejections cut his autonomy and gave no information about his competence. 4. Prediction: interest falls once the pay stops, as observed. 5. Better design: informative feedback on his skill and some choice over projects.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating intrinsic and extrinsic motivation as either-or: most behaviour mixes both. Second, believing every reward kills interest: the effect is mostly found for expected, tangible rewards, while informative praise often helps. Third, reading Yerkes-Dodson as "more arousal is always better" or "calm is always best": the best level depends on task difficulty. Fourth, treating Maslow's levels as a strict ladder; people often pursue several needs at once. Fifth, confusing self-efficacy, belief in your ability at a specific task, with self-esteem, your overall sense of worth.
Key takeaways
Motivation starts, directs and sustains behaviour, from inside (intrinsic) or outside (extrinsic). Instinct theory named behaviour without explaining it. Drive-reduction theory links needs, drives and homeostasis; arousal theory adds an optimal arousal level, lower for difficult tasks (Yerkes-Dodson). Self-efficacy and social motives, including the need to belong, also drive behaviour. Maslow's hierarchy runs from physiological needs to self-actualisation, but not in a strict order. Expected, tangible rewards can undermine intrinsic interest; autonomy, competence and relatedness sustain it.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Needs and wants that start, direct and sustain behaviour towards a goal
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A highly anxious pianist must play a simple scale she has practised for years and then sight-read a difficult new piece. According to the Yerkes-Dodson law, what is most likely?
Question 2 of 5
A child who loves solving puzzles is promised $1 for every puzzle finished. When the payments stop, she solves fewer puzzles than before. This illustrates:
Question 3 of 5
Which observation is the strongest criticism of treating Maslow's hierarchy as a strict ladder?
Question 4 of 5
Instinct theory lost favour among psychologists mainly because:
Question 5 of 5
According to self-determination theory, which classroom is most likely to foster intrinsic motivation?
