Psychology › Section K · Personality › Topic K.2

Freud and the psychodynamic perspective

Sigmund Freud built the first grand theory of personality: a mind divided against itself, shaped by hidden urges and early childhood. His ideas changed Western culture, but most of his specific claims have not survived scientific testing, so this topic teaches both what he said and how well it holds up.

A doctor and the talking cure

Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) was a Viennese physician trained in neurology, not a psychologist. His colleague Josef Breuer treated a young woman known as Anna O. (Bertha Pappenheim) in the early 1880s for paralysis, headaches and other symptoms then labelled hysteria. Talking about her experiences seemed to ease them, and she called it the "talking cure." Freud and Breuer described the case in Studies on Hysteria (1895). Historians later found she was not cured as reported: she spent time in a sanatorium afterwards and recovered only years later. Freud's theory grew from cases like this.

Levels of awareness

Freud divided mental life into three levels. The conscious holds what you are aware of now. The preconscious holds material you can bring to mind when you try, such as a friend's birthday. The unconscious, the largest part in his view, holds wishes, memories and feelings that cannot be reached directly yet still steer behaviour. He argued that the mind keeps unacceptable urges out of awareness through repression. Hidden material could leak out in dreams, in free association (saying whatever comes to mind) and in slips of the tongue, now called Freudian slips. An iceberg, mostly below the waterline, is the image often used to illustrate it.

Id, ego and superego

In 1923 Freud described personality as three interacting systems. The id, present from birth and entirely unconscious, holds basic drives such as hunger, sex and aggression; it follows the pleasure principle, demanding satisfaction now. The superego develops as a child absorbs the rules of parents and society; it acts as a conscience, rewarding with pride and punishing with guilt. The ego is the rational self, working at both conscious and unconscious levels; it follows the reality principle, finding ways to satisfy the id that reality and the superego will accept. For Freud, a healthy personality had a strong ego that could balance the other two.

Defence mechanisms

When the ego cannot settle a conflict, Freud said, it feels anxiety and protects itself with unconscious defence mechanisms that distort reality. His daughter Anna Freud set them out systematically in 1936. Repression pushes threatening thoughts out of awareness. Denial refuses to accept a painful fact. Projection sees one's own unacceptable feelings in someone else. Displacement redirects a feeling onto a safer target. Reaction formation shows the opposite of a hidden feeling. Regression retreats to behaviour typical of a younger age. Rationalisation offers a respectable excuse for an action. Sublimation channels an unacceptable urge into a valued activity. Freud thought everyone uses them, and overuse causes trouble.

Worked example: naming the defence

Classify each case using Freud's terms. A: Omar is left off the football team and insists he never wanted to play because training would hurt his grades. B: Jess is told off by her manager, says nothing, then shouts at her flatmate about the dishes. C: Theo resents his new stepfather but is unusually, gushingly polite to him. 1. Find the uncomfortable feeling: disappointment, anger, resentment. 2. Ask where it went. In A it is hidden behind a sensible-sounding excuse: rationalisation. In B it lands on a safer target: displacement. In C it is turned into its opposite: reaction formation. 3. Check: each counts as a defence only if the person is unaware of it, as Freud's definition requires.

The psychosexual stages

Freud claimed personality is largely set in the first five or six years, as the id's pleasure-seeking focuses on a different body zone at each stage. Oral (birth to about 1): pleasure from sucking and feeding; the conflict is weaning. Anal (about 1 to 3): the conflict is toilet training. Phallic (about 3 to 6): focus on the genitals. Latency (about 6 to puberty): sexual urges lie dormant while children focus on school and friends. Genital (puberty onwards): mature sexual interest. A child whose needs were over-indulged or frustrated at a stage could become fixated there; harsh toilet training, he said, produced a stubborn, overly tidy "anal-retentive" adult.

The phallic stage and its critics

Freud's most controversial claim concerned the phallic stage. He argued that a boy desires his mother, sees his father as a rival and fears punishment; this Oedipus complex, named after the Greek tragedy, resolves when the boy identifies with his father. For girls he proposed "penis envy." The parallel term Electra complex was coined by Carl Jung, and Freud rejected it. Critics, including the psychoanalyst Karen Horney, argued that these ideas reflected the male-centred culture of Freud's Vienna, not a universal stage of childhood. Research has not found good evidence for either complex.

The evidence problem

Freud's theory is weak as science for several reasons. Its central ideas are hard to falsify: as the research topic showed, no observation could prove the id does not exist. It can explain any result after the event, which means it predicts little in advance. Its evidence was Freud's own reading of a few mostly wealthy Viennese patients, not controlled studies. Specific claims have fared badly when tested: there is no reliable link between toilet training and adult personality, and research suggests traumatic experiences are more often remembered too vividly than repressed. Most psychologists today regard the details of the theory as unsupported.

Worked example: testing a Freudian claim

Take the claim that a strict upbringing during toilet training makes an adult obsessively neat. 1. Ask what it predicts: adults with harsh toilet training should be neater than others. 2. Ask what happens if they turn out messy. Freud's theory allows that too, as an anal-expulsive reaction, so both outcomes can be read as support. 3. A fair test needs records of how children were actually trained, made at the time, and independent measures of adult tidiness. Such studies have not found the predicted link. 4. Verdict: a theory that explains every outcome cannot be shown wrong, and where it can be tested it has not held up.

What has survived

Some broad ideas associated with Freud do have modern support, in changed form. A great deal of mental processing happens outside awareness, as research on priming and implicit memory shows, although this is not the seething, repressed unconscious Freud described. A 1998 review of social-psychology research found reasonable evidence for some defence-like processes, such as reaction formation and denial, and little for others, such as sublimation. And talking with a trained listener as a treatment shaped later therapy. Freud matters as a pioneer, not as a source of tested facts.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating Freud's claims as established facts: most of the specific theory lacks empirical support. Second, confusing the superego (conscience) with the ego (the realistic mediator). Third, mixing up projection, which puts your feeling into someone else, with displacement, which aims your feeling at a safer target. Fourth, calling latency a full stage: Freud saw it as a quiet period. Fifth, crediting Freud with the Electra complex; Jung coined the term. Sixth, assuming every slip of the tongue reveals a hidden wish: speech research shows most slips come from tiredness, distraction or similar-sounding words.

Key takeaways

Freud built his theory from clinical cases such as Anna O. He described conscious, preconscious and unconscious levels, with repression keeping urges hidden. The id (pleasure principle), superego (conscience) and ego (reality principle) conflict, and the ego uses unconscious defence mechanisms such as repression, projection, displacement and reaction formation. He proposed oral, anal, phallic, latency and genital stages, with fixation and the Oedipus complex. The theory is hard to falsify and rests on biased case evidence; most specific claims are unsupported, while unconscious processing and some defence-like processes survive in revised form.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Anna O.

Bertha Pappenheim, Breuer's patient whose case launched the talking cure

Studies on Hysteria, 1895; not cured as reported.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

After her coach criticises her in training, Lena goes home and snaps at her younger brother over nothing. In Freud's terms, which defence mechanism is this?

Question 2 of 5

In Freud's model, which part of personality operates on the reality principle?

Question 3 of 5

What is the main scientific criticism of Freud's theory of personality?

Question 4 of 5

According to Freud, in which period do sexual urges lie dormant while children focus on school and friendships?

Question 5 of 5

Which idea associated with Freud is broadly supported by modern research?

← Previous topicNext topic →