Psychology › Section K · Personality › Topic K.3
The neo-Freudians: Adler, Erikson, Jung, and Horney
Several of Freud's own followers broke with him, keeping his belief in unconscious forces and early experience but rejecting his focus on sex. Their theories put relationships, culture and lifelong growth at the centre, and some of their ideas, such as extraversion and identity, are still in everyday use.
Keeping some of Freud, rejecting the rest
The neo-Freudians were psychoanalysts trained in Freud's ideas, some of them members of his own circle, who then built rival theories. They agreed with him that unconscious processes matter and that childhood shapes the adult. They disagreed that sexual and aggressive drives are the main engine of personality. Instead they emphasised social relationships, culture, conscious goals and the possibility of change across life. Four stand out: Adler, Erikson, Horney (say "HORN-eye") and Jung (say "Yoong"). Like Freud, they built their theories mainly from clinical observation of patients rather than from controlled studies, which limits how far their specific claims can be trusted.
Adler: inferiority and striving
Alfred Adler (1870-1937), an early member of Freud's circle in Vienna, was the first major figure to break away, in 1911. He founded individual psychology. Adler argued that every child feels small and weak beside adults, and that the main force in personality is the striving to overcome these feelings of inferiority. Healthy striving leads to competence. When the feelings become overwhelming, a person may develop an inferiority complex, a lasting sense of not measuring up. Adler also stressed social interest, a sense of belonging and of contributing to the common good, and named three life tasks everyone faces: work, friendship and love. He thought these goals are mostly conscious.
Adler and birth order
Adler's most popular idea is that birth order shapes personality. He suggested that firstborns, dethroned when a sibling arrives, become responsible high achievers; youngest children risk being pampered; and middle children, squeezed between them, become competitive or skilled at getting along. The idea is everywhere in magazines and pop psychology. It has been tested many times, often badly, because comparing people from different families mixes birth order with family size and social class. The best modern studies, which compare siblings within the same family or use very large samples, find almost no birth-order effect on personality traits.
Worked example: testing birth order
A website claims that firstborns are more conscientious than their younger siblings. 1. Spot the confound. Children from large families are more likely to be later-born, and family size is linked to income and education, so a simple comparison between families can mislead. 2. Choose a better design: compare siblings within the same family, or use samples big enough to control for family size. 3. Check the results. A 2015 study of over 20,000 adults in the United States, the United Kingdom and Germany found no meaningful birth-order differences in conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness or emotional stability, and only a very small edge for firstborns on measured intellect. 4. Verdict: the claim fails, despite its popularity.
Erikson: development across the lifespan
Erik Erikson (1902-1994) trained in psychoanalysis in Vienna, encouraged by Anna Freud, and moved to the United States in 1933 as Nazism spread. He rejected Freud's view that personality is set by about age 6. In his psychosocial theory, personality develops across the whole lifespan through eight stages, each built around a social conflict rather than a body zone: from trust versus mistrust in infancy, through identity versus role confusion in adolescence, to integrity versus despair in old age. Successfully resolving each conflict builds a lasting strength. The lifespan section of this course treats the eight stages in detail; his idea of the adolescent identity search remains widely used.
Jung: the collective unconscious
Carl Jung (1875-1961), a Swiss psychiatrist once seen as Freud's heir, broke with him around 1913 and founded analytical psychology. He did not accept that sex drives everything, and he added a second layer beneath Freud's personal unconscious: the collective unconscious, an inherited store of patterns shared by all humans. Its contents are archetypes, universal images and themes such as the hero, the wise elder, the trickster and the mother, which Jung saw recurring in myths, art and dreams. He also described the persona, the social mask we show the world, and the shadow, the parts of ourselves we prefer not to see.
Jung's types and their legacy
Jung's best-supported contribution is the distinction between introversion, an orientation towards one's inner world, and extraversion, an orientation towards people and outside activity. A version of this dimension appears in almost every modern trait model. Jung, however, thought in types, and the popular Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, built on his ideas, sorts people into 16 types. Research shows that most people score near the middle of each scale rather than in two clear camps, and many people receive a different type when they retake it. The collective unconscious has no clear evidence behind it: there is no known way for specific symbols to be inherited through genes.
Horney: culture, anxiety and coping
Karen Horney (1885-1952), among the earliest women psychoanalysts, moved from Germany to the United States in 1932. She rejected Freud's claim that girls envy male anatomy, arguing that any envy was of men's greater power and privilege in society, and she suggested men might envy women's ability to give birth. Differences between men's and women's personalities, she said, are largely cultural. Horney traced personality problems to basic anxiety, the insecurity of a child whose needs for warmth and safety are not met. Children cope by moving toward people (seeking approval), moving against people (seeking power) or moving away from people (seeking independence).
Worked example: Horney's three strategies
Three adults grew up in cold, unpredictable homes. Ana agrees to every request and panics at any sign of disapproval. Ben picks arguments, needs to win and belittles colleagues. Cara keeps everyone at arm's length and prefers work she can do alone. 1. Identify the shared root in Horney's terms: basic anxiety from unmet childhood needs. 2. Match each pattern. Ana seeks safety through affection: moving toward people. Ben seeks safety through dominance: moving against people. Cara seeks safety through distance: moving away from people. 3. Apply Horney's key point: all three strategies are normal in moderation. They become a problem only when used rigidly, whatever the situation.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking neo-Freudians rejected Freud entirely: they kept the unconscious and the importance of childhood. Second, confusing Jung's collective unconscious, shared by all humans, with Freud's personal unconscious of one individual's repressed material. Third, treating birth-order effects as established: large, well-designed studies find almost none. Fourth, ending Erikson's stages in childhood: they run to old age. Fifth, assuming Horney accepted penis envy: she reframed it as envy of social power. Sixth, trusting a Myers-Briggs type as a fixed label: retest results often change, and the categories split people who score almost the same.
Key takeaways
Neo-Freudians kept the unconscious and childhood but played down sex, stressing social and cultural forces. Adler's individual psychology centres on striving to overcome inferiority, social interest and the tasks of work, friendship and love; his birth-order theory is not supported by large studies. Erikson described eight psychosocial stages across the whole lifespan. Jung's analytical psychology added the collective unconscious, archetypes, the persona and introversion-extraversion; only the last is well supported. Horney linked envy to social privilege and described basic anxiety with three coping strategies: toward, against and away from people. Their theories rest mainly on clinical observation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Followers who revised Freud, stressing social and cultural forces
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
According to Alfred Adler, what is the main driving force behind personality?
Question 2 of 5
How did Erik Erikson's view of development differ most clearly from Freud's?
Question 3 of 5
What did Carl Jung mean by the collective unconscious?
Question 4 of 5
A child in a cold, unpredictable home copes by withdrawing, needing privacy and relying only on himself. Which of Karen Horney's strategies is this?
Question 5 of 5
What have large, well-designed studies found about Adler's birth-order theory?
