Psychology › Section K · Personality › Topic K.5

Humanistic approaches

Freud studied people in distress and the behaviourists studied rats and pigeons. In the middle of the 20th century, humanistic psychologists asked a different question: what does a healthy, growing person look like, and what helps someone become their best self?

The third force

By the 1950s, two approaches dominated psychology. Psychoanalysis saw people as driven by dark, unconscious forces; behaviourism saw them as shaped by rewards and punishments. Humanistic psychology, often called the "third force," pushed back against both. It did not claim the others were simply wrong. It argued that they left out what matters most about being human: conscious experience, free choice, the search for meaning and an inborn drive to grow. Humanists studied healthy people rather than patients, and they trusted people's own accounts of their experience. The two leading figures were Abraham Maslow and Carl Rogers, both met briefly in the history topic.

Maslow's hierarchy of needs

Abraham Maslow (1908-1970) proposed in 1943 that human needs form a hierarchy. At the base are physiological needs (food, water, sleep), then safety, then love and belonging, then esteem (respect from others and self-respect), and at the top self-actualisation. Maslow argued that lower needs usually press hardest and must be reasonably met before higher ones become the main motive. He distinguished deficiency needs, which push us to fill a gap such as hunger or loneliness, from growth needs, which pull us towards becoming more fully ourselves. The hierarchy also appears in the motivation topic; here the focus is on what it says about personality.

Self-actualisation

Self-actualisation is the fulfilment of a person's potential: becoming everything one is capable of becoming. Maslow studied people he judged to be self-actualised, drawn from historical figures and people he knew, and described traits he thought they shared. They accepted themselves and others, saw reality clearly, were spontaneous and creative, focused on problems beyond themselves, valued privacy and deep friendships, and sometimes reported peak experiences, moments of intense joy and wonder. Maslow believed few people fully reach this level. For him, many emotional and behavioural problems arise when needs lower in the hierarchy go unmet and block growth.

Rogers: the self-concept

Carl Rogers (1902-1987) placed the self-concept, a person's organised set of thoughts and feelings about who they are, at the centre of personality. Ask "Who am I?" and your answers sketch it. Rogers divided the self into the real self, the person you actually are, and the ideal self, the person you think you should be. When the two are close, a person experiences congruence: an accurate self-image, a sense of worth and openness to experience. When they are far apart, the result is incongruence, felt as anxiety and a nagging sense of falling short. Rogers believed every person has an actualising tendency, an inborn drive to grow, which incongruence blocks.

Conditions of worth and unconditional regard

Where does incongruence come from? Rogers pointed to conditions of worth: messages, often from parents, that a child is loved only when they behave in certain ways. A child who is praised only for top marks may build an ideal self around achievement and deny feelings that do not fit. The remedy is unconditional positive regard: accepting and valuing a person as they are, whatever they feel or do. This does not mean approving of every action. A parent can say "I love you, and what you did was wrong." Rogers held that people who feel accepted in this way can afford to see themselves honestly and change.

Worked example: real self and ideal self

Maya, 17, is studying three sciences because her family expects her to become a doctor, but she spends every free hour writing music and feels anxious and hollow. Analyse her situation in Rogers's terms. 1. Ideal self: a future doctor who excels at science. 2. Real self: someone whose energy and interest go into music. 3. The gap between them is incongruence, which fits her anxiety. 4. Possible source: conditions of worth, if she believes her family's approval depends on medicine. 5. A Rogerian response would offer acceptance, helping her see and value her real interests so she can choose freely, whichever path she then takes. This is analysis of a theory, not advice for a real person.

From theory to therapy

Rogers turned his theory into client-centred (later person-centred) therapy. The therapist does not interpret or direct; instead they provide three core conditions. Genuineness: being real and open rather than hiding behind a professional role. Unconditional positive regard: accepting the client without judgement. Empathy: understanding the client's experience from the inside and reflecting it back. Given these conditions, Rogers argued, a person's own actualising tendency does the healing. Research on therapy has broadly supported part of this: the quality of the relationship between client and therapist, including empathy, is consistently linked with better outcomes across many kinds of therapy.

Weighing the evidence

Humanistic ideas are appealing but have real scientific weaknesses. Concepts such as self-actualisation are vague and hard to measure, which makes them hard to test. Maslow's evidence came from a small group of people he chose himself, using his own judgement of who was self-actualised, so his conclusions partly reflect his values. Strict versions of the hierarchy have not held up: people often seek love, respect or meaning while basic needs remain unmet. Critics also argue the theory reflects an individualist Western view of the self. Even so, humanism helped inspire positive psychology, the scientific study of well-being and strengths.

Worked example: testing Maslow

Maslow's hierarchy predicts that people whose basic needs are unmet should gain little from social or esteem needs. How could this be tested? 1. Measure, in many countries, how far people's needs at each level are met, and how good their lives feel. 2. Check the predicted order. A 2011 study by Louis Tay and Ed Diener, using survey data from 123 countries, did this. 3. Read the findings: the needs Maslow listed were broadly universal and each was linked to well-being, but people gained from meeting social and respect needs even when basic needs were not fully met. 4. Verdict: Maslow identified real human needs, but the strict step-by-step order is not supported.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking unconditional positive regard means approving of everything; it means valuing the person, not every act. Second, swapping the real self (who you are) with the ideal self (who you think you should be). Third, reading Maslow's hierarchy as a rigid ladder that must be climbed one rung at a time; the evidence does not support a strict order. Fourth, assuming self-actualisation is a measured scientific fact; it is a loosely defined ideal. Fifth, forgetting that Maslow's sample was hand-picked by Maslow himself. Sixth, treating congruence as never feeling doubt: it means the self-image is accurate, not perfect.

Key takeaways

Humanistic psychology, the third force, emphasised conscious experience, free choice and growth in healthy people. Maslow's hierarchy runs from physiological and safety needs through love and esteem to self-actualisation, the fulfilment of potential; he separated deficiency needs from growth needs. Rogers centred personality on the self-concept: congruence between real and ideal self supports worth, while incongruence, often from conditions of worth, brings anxiety. Unconditional positive regard, genuineness and empathy are the core conditions of person-centred therapy. Humanistic concepts are hard to test, Maslow's sample was biased, and the strict order of the hierarchy is not supported.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Third force

Humanistic psychology, after psychoanalysis and behaviourism

Growth, choice, conscious experience.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

In Maslow's theory, what is self-actualisation?

Question 2 of 5

According to Carl Rogers, a person experiences congruence when:

Question 3 of 5

Which parent's message best shows Rogers's idea of unconditional positive regard?

Question 4 of 5

What is a major weakness of Maslow's evidence about self-actualised people?

Question 5 of 5

What did Tay and Diener's 2011 study of 123 countries find about Maslow's hierarchy?

← Previous topicNext topic →