Psychology › Section K · Personality › Topic K.6
Biological approaches
Some babies startle at every noise while others sleep through anything, long before parents or culture could have shaped them. Biological approaches ask how much of personality is built in: through temperament, through genes and through our evolutionary history.
Nature in personality
Biological approaches hold that inherited predispositions and the workings of the body help explain why people differ. Three lines of evidence support this view. Temperament differences appear in the first weeks of life, before much learning can have happened. Studies of twins and adopted children show that genetic relatives resemble each other in personality more than unrelated people do. And evolutionary thinking offers reasons why such differences might exist at all. None of this means personality is fixed by biology. As the genetics topic showed, genes and environment work together, and the questions are always how much, and how.
Temperament: Thomas and Chess
Temperament is a person's characteristic emotional and behavioural style, visible from infancy: activity level, mood, how intensely they react and how easily they adapt. In the New York Longitudinal Study, begun in the 1950s, Alexander Thomas and Stella Chess followed children from infancy and grouped them into three types. Easy babies (about 40%) were cheerful, regular in eating and sleeping, and adapted quickly. Difficult babies (about 10%) were irregular, intense and slow to accept change. Slow-to-warm-up babies (about 15%) were wary of new things at first but adjusted over time. The remaining third or so did not fit neatly into any type.
Reactivity and self-regulation
Later researchers moved from types to dimensions. Mary Rothbart described two core aspects of temperament that carry into adult personality: reactivity, how quickly and strongly a person responds to new or challenging situations, and self-regulation, how well they can control that response. Jerome Kagan found that a minority of infants react strongly to unfamiliar sights and sounds; many of these behaviourally inhibited children were still shy and cautious years later, though a substantial number changed. Temperament is a starting point, not a destiny. How parents respond matters: a calm, patient response to a difficult baby tends to produce better outcomes than a harsh one.
Twin and adoption studies
How can genetic and environmental influences be separated? Twin studies compare identical twins, who share virtually all their genes, with fraternal twins, who share about half on average, like ordinary siblings. Both kinds usually grow up in the same home. If identical twins are more alike on a trait than fraternal twins, genes are likely to play a part. Adoption studies add another test: do adopted children resemble their biological parents, who passed on their genes, or their adoptive parents, who provided the home? Each design has weaknesses, for example identical twins may be treated more alike, so researchers look for agreement across methods.
The Minnesota twins reared apart
The strongest twin design studies identical twins separated early in life and raised in different homes, because any similarity between them cannot come from a shared upbringing. The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart, led by Thomas Bouchard from 1979 to 1999, assessed about 80 such pairs, plus fraternal twins raised apart and twins raised together. Its striking finding was that identical twins raised apart were about as similar in personality as identical twins raised together. Growing up in the same home added surprisingly little similarity. Later research has broadly confirmed the pattern: shared family environment explains little of adult personality, while experiences unique to each person explain a great deal.
Worked example: estimating heritability from twins
Heritability is the proportion of the variation in a trait, within a particular population, that is linked to genetic differences. A simple estimate doubles the gap between identical (MZ) and fraternal (DZ) twin correlations:
Suppose, in a hypothetical study of anxiousness, identical twins correlate at 0.46 and fraternal twins at 0.26. 1. Find the gap: 0.46 − 0.26 = 0.20. 2. Double it, because identical twins share about twice the genetic overlap of fraternal twins: 2 × 0.20 = 0.40. 3. Interpret: about 40% of the differences in anxiousness in this population are linked to genetic differences. 4. Check: this matches typical twin estimates for major traits, about 40% to 50%.
What heritability does not mean
Heritability is easy to misread. It describes differences within a population, not individuals: a heritability of 40% does not mean 40% of your shyness came from your genes. It depends on circumstances: if everyone grew up in very similar environments, the genetic share of the remaining differences would rise. It says nothing about whether a trait can change: height is highly heritable, yet average height has risen over generations as nutrition improved. And it does not mean the rest is due to parenting; most of the non-genetic variation comes from experiences unique to each person, plus measurement error. A heritable trait is influenced by genes, not determined by them.
Worked example: reading a gene headline
A headline reads: "Scientists find the gene for extraversion." Evaluate it. 1. Recall the twin evidence: extraversion is moderately heritable, so genes matter. 2. Ask what modern genome studies show. Studies scanning the DNA of hundreds of thousands of people find that personality traits are influenced by thousands of genetic variants, each with a tiny effect, and together the variants identified so far explain far less variation than twin studies suggest. 3. Add epigenetics: chemical marks, influenced by experience, can switch genes on or off without changing the DNA sequence. 4. Verdict: there is no single gene for extraversion, and the headline misleads.
Evolution and personality
Evolutionary psychologists such as David Buss ask why personality differences exist at all. One answer is that no single level of a trait is best everywhere. High extraversion may bring more social and mating opportunities but also more risks, such as accidents and conflict; caution protects but can mean missed chances. If the costs and benefits balance out across environments, natural selection can keep a range of levels in a population. Life-history theory asks how people divide limited time and energy between growth, mating and parenting. Costly signalling theory studies how people advertise their quality as partners or friends. These ideas are plausible but hard to test directly.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reading heritability as a statement about one person rather than about differences in a population. Second, assuming a heritable trait cannot change. Third, assuming the non-genetic part of personality must come from parenting; shared family environment explains surprisingly little. Fourth, believing in a single gene for a trait: personality is shaped by thousands of variants with tiny effects. Fifth, treating temperament as destiny: many inhibited infants become less shy, and parenting affects how temperament is expressed. Sixth, forgetting to double the twin-correlation gap when estimating heritability, or using the identical-twin correlation alone.
Key takeaways
Biological approaches link personality to inherited predispositions and physiology. Temperament appears in infancy: Thomas and Chess described easy, difficult and slow-to-warm-up babies, and Rothbart stressed reactivity and self-regulation. Twin and adoption studies separate genes from environment; the Minnesota study found identical twins raised apart about as alike as those raised together. Heritability, about 40% to 50% for major traits, describes population differences, can be estimated as 2(rMZ − rDZ), and does not mean fixed. Traits are polygenic, and epigenetic marks are one route by which experience affects genes. Evolutionary ideas explain why a range of trait levels may persist.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Personality explained by inherited predispositions and physiology
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In a new nursery, a toddler hangs back and watches for the first week, then gradually joins in happily. Which Thomas and Chess temperament fits best?
Question 2 of 5
What was the most striking finding of the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart?
Question 3 of 5
A study reports that the heritability of extraversion is about 40%. What does this mean?
Question 4 of 5
In a twin study, identical twins correlate at 0.50 on a trait and fraternal twins at 0.30. Using the simple estimate from this topic, what is the heritability?
Question 5 of 5
What do large studies scanning the DNA of hundreds of thousands of people show about personality?
