Psychology › Section H · Memory › Topic H.2
Brain areas involved in memory
A memory is not filed in one drawer of the brain. Different regions handle different kinds of memory, and the changes that store them happen at synapses. This topic follows the search for the memory trace, from lesioned rats to patient H.M. to mice whose memories can be switched on with light.
The search for the engram
Where is a memory kept? Karl Lashley spent decades looking for the engram, the physical trace of a memory. He trained rats to run mazes, then removed different parts of their cerebral cortex. No single cut erased the maze. Instead, the rats' performance worsened with the amount of cortex removed rather than its location. Lashley summed this up as mass action and equipotentiality, the idea that one part of a cortical area can take over the work of a damaged part. His lesson was that memories are distributed, not stored in one spot.
Memory at the synapse
Later researchers found the trace in the connections between neurons. Eric Kandel used the large neurons of the sea slug Aplysia to show that learning strengthens specific synapses, sharing the 2000 Nobel Prize. In 1973 Timothy Bliss and Terje Lømo described long-term potentiation (LTP): after rapid repeated stimulation, synapses in the hippocampus respond more strongly for hours or longer. LTP depends on the neurotransmitter glutamate and is widely thought to be one basis of learning. In 2012 Susumu Tonegawa's laboratory tagged the hippocampal cells active during a fear experience in mice; reactivating just those cells with light made the mice freeze.
The hippocampus: forming explicit memories
The hippocampus, a curved structure deep in each temporal lobe, is essential for forming new explicit memories, episodic and semantic. It binds the parts of an experience, held in different cortical areas, into one memory and helps consolidate it. Over months to years, much of that memory comes to depend on the cortex itself (systems consolidation), so old memories often survive hippocampal damage. The hippocampus is also central to spatial memory: John O'Keefe found place cells there that fire when an animal is in one particular location, sharing the 2014 Nobel Prize.
Patient H.M.
Henry Molaison, known in research as H.M. until his death in 2008, had severe epilepsy. In 1953 the surgeon William Scoville removed most of both hippocampi, with nearby tissue including much of the amygdala. The seizures eased, but H.M. could no longer form new explicit memories: he never learned the names of staff he saw for years. He kept many older memories, though he lost some from the years just before the operation. Brenda Milner found that he improved at mirror drawing over three days while denying he had ever done it. Forming explicit memories and learning skills, she showed, use different systems.
The amygdala: emotional memory
The amygdala, an almond-shaped cluster next to the hippocampus, is central to fear and to remembering emotional events. In fear conditioning, an animal learns that a tone predicts a mild shock; damage to the amygdala prevents this fear memory from forming. The amygdala also strengthens other memories of arousing events: stress hormones such as adrenaline act through it to boost consolidation, as James McGaugh showed. In one experiment, people who heard an emotional story remembered its emotional middle section unusually well, but people given propranolol, a drug that blocks adrenaline's effects, lost that advantage (Cahill and colleagues, 1994).
Cerebellum and basal ganglia: implicit memory
The cerebellum is needed for timed motor learning and classically conditioned reflexes. Richard Thompson trained rabbits to blink at a tone that predicted a puff of air to the eye; damage to a small part of the cerebellum abolished the learned blink, while the ordinary reflex to the puff remained. The basal ganglia, deep below the cortex, support habits and procedural skills. People with Parkinson's disease, which damages basal ganglia circuits, can struggle to learn a new habit-like task while still remembering the training session, the reverse of the pattern seen in amnesia.
The prefrontal cortex: working with memories
The prefrontal cortex, at the front of the frontal lobes, manages memories more than it stores them. It is active when information is held in working memory, and monkeys with prefrontal damage struggle on tasks that require keeping a location in mind for a few seconds. It also guides strategic encoding and retrieval: brain scans show stronger left prefrontal activity when people judge a word's meaning rather than its spelling, matching the depth-of-processing results from the previous topic. Damage here tends to cause disorganised recall and confusion about where a memory came from.
Flashbulb memories: vivid but not exact
Roger Brown and James Kulik (1977) coined the term flashbulb memory for the vivid memory of how you heard shocking news. Emotion makes such memories feel sharp, but accuracy is another matter. Ulric Neisser and Nicole Harsch asked students the day after the 1986 Challenger shuttle disaster how they had heard the news, then asked again about two and a half years later; many later accounts differed sharply from the first, yet the students were confident. After the 11 September 2001 attacks, Jennifer Talarico and David Rubin found that flashbulb memories lost consistency about as fast as everyday memories, while belief in their accuracy stayed high.
Worked example: locating the damage
Patient A cannot remember a nurse she met an hour ago, but over a week she gets faster at a new puzzle she insists she has never seen. Patient B remembers every visit in detail, but after many trials he never learns to blink at a tone that predicts an air puff. 1. Patient A has lost new explicit memory while keeping skill learning: the hippocampal pattern, as in H.M. 2. Patient B keeps explicit memory but loses a conditioned reflex: the cerebellar pattern. 3. Together they form a double dissociation: the two kinds of memory use separate systems. 4. Check: behaviour only suggests a site; brain imaging is needed to confirm where the damage lies.
Worked example: testing a flashbulb claim
Claim: "My memory of that day is perfect." Design a test like Talarico and Rubin's. 1. Within a day, record each person's account of hearing the news and of an ordinary event from the same days. 2. Ask again weeks or months later and count details that changed. 3. Rate how vivid and how certain each memory feels. 4. Typical result: both memories change at similar rates, but only the flashbulb memory keeps its high confidence. 5. Conclusion: emotion boosts the feeling of remembering more than its accuracy. 6. Check: the core fact of the event survives; the details drift.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying memories are stored in the hippocampus: it forms and consolidates explicit memories, but long-term storage is spread across the cortex. Second, thinking H.M. lost all memory: he lost the ability to form new explicit memories and some memories from just before surgery, but kept older memories and could still learn skills. Third, giving one region one job: the amygdala colours many kinds of memory, not only fear. Fourth, treating a flashbulb memory's vividness as proof of accuracy. Fifth, reading Lashley as proof that no region specialises: traces are distributed, yet the hippocampus and cerebellum still have distinct jobs.
Key takeaways
Lashley found no single engram: rats' maze memory declined with the amount of cortex removed, so memories are distributed. The trace lies in synaptic change (Kandel's Aplysia; long-term potentiation, 1973), and reactivating tagged hippocampal cells in mice recalled a fear memory. The hippocampus forms and consolidates explicit memories and supports spatial memory. H.M. had most of both hippocampi removed in 1953 and could form no new explicit memories, yet learned mirror drawing. The amygdala handles fear and strengthens emotional memories through stress hormones. The cerebellum supports conditioned reflexes, the basal ganglia habits, and the prefrontal cortex working memory and strategic retrieval. Flashbulb memories feel certain but drift like ordinary ones.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The physical trace of a memory in the brain
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these could H.M. still do after his 1953 surgery?
Question 2 of 5
What did Karl Lashley find when he removed parts of trained rats' cortex?
Question 3 of 5
Rabbits learn to blink at a tone that predicts a puff of air. Damage to which structure abolishes this learned blink while the normal reflex remains?
Question 4 of 5
Studies of flashbulb memories after the 2001 attacks found that, over the following months, these memories:
Question 5 of 5
People given propranolol, which blocks adrenaline's effects, listen to an emotional story. Compared with a placebo group, they most likely:
