Psychology › Section H · Memory › Topic H.3
Problems with memory
Memory fails in predictable ways: it loses information, blocks it, and sometimes fills gaps with things that never happened. Knowing those patterns matters for everyday life and, as wrongful convictions show, for justice.
Seven ways memory lets us down
Daniel Schacter (2001) grouped everyday memory failures into seven "sins". Three are forgetting: transience (memories fade with time), absent-mindedness (lapses of attention, such as forgetting where you put your keys) and blocking (information is stored but will not come, as in the tip-of-the-tongue feeling). Three are distortion: misattribution (confusing where a memory came from), suggestibility (memories altered by leading questions or later information) and bias (memories reshaped by present beliefs, as in hindsight). The seventh, persistence, is the opposite failure: unwanted memories, often distressing, that keep returning.
Amnesia: two directions of loss
Amnesia is a serious loss of memory caused by brain injury, disease or, more rarely, psychological trauma. Anterograde amnesia is the inability to form new long-term memories after the damage, as in patient H.M. from the previous topic; people with it can often still learn new skills. Retrograde amnesia is the loss of memories formed before the damage. After a head injury it usually covers a limited stretch, often the minutes to days just before it, and recent memories are more vulnerable than old ones. Losing one's whole identity after a blow to the head, as in films, is very rare.
The forgetting curve
Hermann Ebbinghaus learned lists of nonsense syllables, then measured how much time relearning saved after delays from 20 minutes to a month. Savings dropped to about 58% after 20 minutes and about 34% after a day, then fell only slowly, to about 21% after a month. Forgetting is fast at first and then levels off. Well-learned material lasts far longer. Harry Bahrick (1984) tested people who had studied Spanish at school up to 50 years earlier: their knowledge declined over the first few years, then stayed roughly stable for decades, especially among those who had learned it well.
Never stored, or stored but stuck
Much apparent forgetting is encoding failure: the information never entered long-term memory. Raymond Nickerson and Marilyn Adams (1979) asked Americans to pick the correct drawing of a penny from several versions; most could not, having encoded only enough to tell coins apart. Unused traces may also fade, called decay. Blocking is different: the information is stored but temporarily cannot be retrieved. In the tip-of-the-tongue state, people often know a word's first letter or number of syllables, which shows partial access. Absent-mindedness, such as walking into a room and forgetting why, is usually a lapse of attention.
Interference and retrieval cues
Memories also compete. In proactive interference, old learning disrupts new: you keep writing last year's date in January. In retroactive interference, new learning disrupts old: after learning a friend's new phone number, you can no longer recall the old one. Retrieval also depends on cues. Duncan Godden and Alan Baddeley (1975) had divers learn word lists either underwater or on land; recall was better when tested in the same setting, called context-dependent memory. Recall can likewise improve when your mood or body state matches the one at learning, called state-dependent memory. Many "forgotten" memories are simply missing the right cue.
Reconstruction and the misinformation effect
Remembering is not replaying. Recall rebuilds an event from stored pieces, general knowledge and expectations, and the rebuilt version can be stored again with changes. Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer (1974) showed students films of car crashes, then asked how fast the cars were going when they "smashed" or, for others, "hit" or "contacted" each other. The word "smashed" produced the highest speed estimates. A week later, about a third of the "smashed" group reported seeing broken glass, about twice the rate of the "hit" group, though the film showed none. Misleading information after an event can alter the memory itself: the misinformation effect.
False memories and the recovered memory debate
Whole events can be implanted. In the "lost in the mall" study (Loftus and Pickrell, 1995), relatives' stories, three true and one false, led about a quarter of participants to remember being lost in a shopping centre as a child, an event that never happened. In word-list studies, people who hear bed, rest, tired, dream and similar words often confidently "remember" hearing sleep. This research fed the 1990s debate over Freud's idea of repression and abuse memories recovered in therapy. A 1996 American Psychological Association working group concluded that most survivors of childhood abuse remember all or part of it, that a long-forgotten memory can return, and that suggestive techniques such as hypnosis or guided imagery can create convincing false memories. Without other evidence, the two can be hard to tell apart.
Eyewitness memory and line-ups
Eyewitness testimony is persuasive to juries, yet the Innocence Project reported that mistaken eyewitness identification played a part in about 69% of the 375 US wrongful convictions it counted as overturned by DNA evidence from 1989 to 2020. Errors rise with high stress, weapon focus (attention drawn to a weapon rather than a face), poor viewing, identifying someone of a different ethnic group (the cross-race effect) and suggestive procedures. Recommended reforms: double-blind line-ups, run by someone who does not know which person is the suspect; warning witnesses that the culprit may not be present; and recording confidence immediately, before feedback can inflate it.
Worked example: naming the memory failure
Classify each case with Schacter's sins. 1. Lena is sure her brother told her a joke she actually read online: right content, wrong source, so misattribution. 2. After a match, Raj insists he always knew his team would lose, though he predicted a win: present knowledge reshaped the memory, so bias (hindsight). 3. A witness asked "Did you see the knife?" later recalls a knife that was never there: suggestibility, from a leading question. 4. You can picture an actor's face but cannot produce his name: blocking. 5. A frightening crash keeps replaying in someone's mind for weeks: persistence. 6. Check: forgetting sins lose information, distortion sins change it.
Worked example: auditing a line-up
A witness glimpsed a robber holding a gun for a few seconds. She is shown six photos by a detective who knows which is the suspect, the only one in a red jacket like the robber's. She hesitates, picks him, and hears "Good, that's our guy". 1. Viewing: a brief glimpse with a weapon present means weapon focus and weak encoding. 2. Procedure: a non-blind administrator can cue the witness without meaning to. 3. Fairness: the jacket makes the suspect stand out. 4. Feedback: praise inflates confidence, so her certainty at trial will mean little. 5. Fix: double-blind, matched photos, a "may not be present" warning, and confidence recorded at once.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating memory as a recording: recall is reconstruction, so detail can be added without any intent to lie. Second, equating confidence with accuracy: confidence grows with retelling and feedback, though a confidence statement taken at the first, fair test carries some information. Third, mixing up the interference directions: proactive means old disrupts new; retroactive means new disrupts old. Fourth, mixing up the amnesias: anterograde blocks new memories, retrograde erases old ones. Fifth, assuming that what you cannot recall was never stored: blocking and missing cues are common.
Key takeaways
Schacter's seven sins: transience, absent-mindedness and blocking (forgetting); misattribution, suggestibility and bias (distortion); and persistence. Anterograde amnesia prevents new memories; retrograde amnesia removes earlier ones. Ebbinghaus's curve shows fast early forgetting that levels off; Bahrick found school Spanish lasting decades. Forgetting comes from encoding failure, blocking, interference (proactive and retroactive) and missing cues. Memory is reconstructive: the misinformation effect (Loftus and Palmer, 1974) and "lost in the mall" study show memories can be altered or implanted. Eyewitness errors contributed to about 69% of DNA exonerations studied by the Innocence Project; double-blind, fair line-ups and immediate confidence records reduce them.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Transience, absent-mindedness, blocking, misattribution, suggestibility, bias, persistence
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
After moving house, Priya keeps giving people her old address when asked for her new one. This is an example of:
Question 2 of 5
After a stroke, a man remembers his childhood and his career clearly but cannot remember anything that happened since he entered hospital. His problem is best described as:
Question 3 of 5
In Loftus and Palmer's (1974) study, what happened to people asked how fast the cars were going when they "smashed" into each other?
Question 4 of 5
You can picture a famous singer's face, know her name starts with A, and still cannot say it. In Schacter's terms, this is:
Question 5 of 5
Which change to line-up procedure most directly prevents the officer from cueing the witness?
