Psychology › Section P · Therapy and treatment › Topic P.3

Individual, group, and family treatment

The previous topic asked which kind of therapy a person receives; this one asks who is in the room. Therapy can involve one client, a group of strangers, a couple or a whole family, and each format brings its own strengths and limits. The topic is for learning only, not advice.

The intake and the treatment plan

Whatever the format, treatment usually begins with an intake, the therapist's first meeting with a new client. The therapist gathers information about the presenting problem (the difficulty that brought the person in), their history, support network and practical matters such as fees or insurance, and explains what therapy will involve. Together they agree on goals, which become a treatment plan with specific, measurable objectives, a way of tracking progress and an estimate of how long treatment may take. The plan also guides the choice of modality: individual, group, couples or family therapy, or a combination.

Confidentiality and its limits

Confidentiality means a therapist may not share what a client says with anyone else unless the law requires or permits it. Clients are told about the limits at the start. In the United States these typically include suspected abuse or neglect of a child or vulnerable adult, which therapists are legally required to report, and a serious risk that the client will harm themselves or someone else. The 1976 California case Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California established that therapists can have a duty to protect an identifiable person their client has seriously threatened; states now handle this duty in different ways. Confidentiality matters because people rarely speak openly without trust.

Individual therapy

In individual therapy, one client meets one clinician, typically for sessions of about 45 to 60 minutes, often weekly or every other week, in person or increasingly by video. The privacy of the format lets clients explore sensitive material at their own pace and lets the therapist tailor every technique to one person's needs and goals. Treatment may last a handful of sessions for a focused problem or a year or more for long-standing difficulties. Its drawbacks are cost and therapist time: one clinician can see only a limited number of people, which is one reason other formats exist.

Group therapy: how it helps

In group therapy, one or two clinicians meet with several clients, often about five to ten, who share a similar problem, such as social anxiety, grief or recovery from trauma. The psychiatrist Irvin Yalom described therapeutic factors that groups offer and individual therapy cannot. Universality is the relief of discovering that others share your problem, which reduces shame and isolation. Groups also instil hope as members watch others improve, give people a chance to help each other, and let them practise new ways of relating in a safe setting. Group therapy is cheaper per person, and for many problems research finds it about as effective as individual therapy.

Group therapy: formats and limits

Groups vary. Closed groups keep the same members for a fixed number of sessions; open groups let people join and leave. Structured groups follow a plan of activities, while unstructured groups let members decide what to work on. Psychoeducational groups emphasise teaching, such as a group explaining a parent's illness to children. Self-help and support groups, such as Alcoholics Anonymous, founded in 1935, are led by peers rather than professionals. Groups have limits too. Some people find it hard to speak in front of strangers, members may clash, and confidentiality is harder to guarantee because other members, unlike the therapist, are not professionally bound by it.

Worked example: choosing a modality

Consider which format might suit each situation, as a clinician would after an intake. 1. A 15-year-old feels he is the only person his age whose parents are divorcing. A group of teenagers in the same situation offers universality, so group therapy fits well. 2. A woman wants to explore a private trauma she has never told anyone. She needs privacy and a pace set for her alone, so individual therapy fits. 3. Two partners argue constantly about money and chores. The problem lies in their interaction, so couples therapy fits. 4. A family's arguments escalate whenever the youngest child misbehaves. The pattern involves everyone, so family therapy fits. Check: in each case the format follows where the problem lives, and many people combine formats.

Couples therapy

Couples therapy works with two people in an intimate relationship, whether dating, living together or married, who want to resolve difficulties. Many approaches draw on cognitive-behavioural principles: partners learn to listen, express feelings without blame and argue constructively, and they examine how their beliefs and behaviour affect each other. Emotionally focused therapy, developed by Sue Johnson and Leslie Greenberg, instead centres on attachment needs and the emotional cycles partners get stuck in. Research by John Gottman on how couples handle conflict has also shaped practice. Therapy does not always keep couples together: sometimes partners conclude that separating is the healthier choice, and helping them reach that decision clearly can also be a good outcome.

Family therapy and the systems view

Family therapy treats one or more families together. Its central idea is the systems approach: a family is an organised system in which each member influences and is influenced by the others, so one person's problem may be maintained by the family's patterns. The member whose symptoms prompted treatment is sometimes called the identified patient. In structural family therapy, associated with Salvador Minuchin, the therapist examines the family's boundaries, alliances and rules, such as who makes decisions and whether parents act as a team. Strategic family therapy, associated with Jay Haley and Cloé Madanes, is briefer and more directive, with the therapist designing specific tasks to change problem patterns.

Worked example: a systems analysis

Sixteen-year-old Ana has started skipping school, and her parents bring her to therapy as the problem. 1. Identify the identified patient: Ana. 2. Look at the system: the therapist notices that the parents argue constantly but stop and unite whenever Ana gets into trouble. 3. Find the pattern: Ana's misbehaviour, without her intending it, briefly ends the parents' conflict, which helps keep it going. 4. Structural move: the therapist helps the parents work as a team on rules and address their own disagreements directly. 5. Expected effect: once the parents' conflict no longer needs Ana's trouble to pause it, her school attendance is more likely to improve. Check: treating Ana alone would have left the maintaining pattern untouched.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming confidentiality is absolute: suspected child abuse and serious risk of harm are standard exceptions. Second, thinking group therapy is second-rate: for many problems it is about as effective, and it offers universality that individual therapy cannot. Third, confusing therapy groups with self-help groups: the latter are peer-led. Fourth, assuming couples therapy has failed if a couple separates. Fifth, seeing family therapy as fixing one troubled member: the systems view treats the whole family's patterns. Sixth, mixing up structural therapy (boundaries and rules) with strategic therapy (brief, directive tasks).

Key takeaways

Treatment begins with an intake and a treatment plan with measurable goals. Confidentiality is essential but has legal limits, including reporting suspected abuse and, since Tarasoff (1976), a possible duty to protect people who are seriously threatened. Individual therapy offers privacy and tailoring. Group therapy offers universality, hope and peer support at lower cost, with formats from closed to open and psychoeducational, though confidentiality is harder to ensure. Couples therapy addresses relationship patterns. Family therapy uses a systems approach, through structural or strategic methods. This topic is for learning only: talk to a qualified professional about which format might suit you, and in a US crisis, call or text 988.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Intake

The therapist's first meeting with a new client

Gathers the presenting problem and sets goals.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which situation is a standard limit of confidentiality in US therapy?

Question 2 of 5

A teenager in a group for young people with diabetes says, "I thought I was the only one who felt like this." Which therapeutic factor is she experiencing?

Question 3 of 5

Why is confidentiality harder to guarantee in group therapy than in individual therapy?

Question 4 of 5

In family therapy, what does the systems approach assume?

Question 5 of 5

A therapist examines who makes the rules in a family and whether the parents act as a team. This is most typical of:

← Previous topicNext topic →