Psychology › Section P · Therapy and treatment › Topic P.2

Types of treatment

Therapy can mean lying on a couch talking about dreams, practising a feared situation step by step, or taking a medication prescribed by a doctor. This topic surveys the main kinds of treatment and the evidence behind them, for learning only, never as advice for yourself or anyone else.

Two families of treatment

Treatments for psychological disorders fall into two broad families. Psychotherapy is a psychological treatment in which a trained professional uses conversation and structured techniques to help a person overcome problems or grow. Biomedical therapy uses medication or medical procedures that act directly on the brain and body. The two are often combined, and many therapists are eclectic, drawing techniques from several approaches to suit the person. The psychotherapies differ mainly in what they assume causes distress: hidden conflicts, learned behaviour, distorted thinking or blocked growth.

Psychoanalysis, psychodynamic therapy and play

Sigmund Freud's psychoanalysis, the first formal psychotherapy, dominated the early twentieth century. Freud traced problems to repressed childhood conflicts, so therapy aimed to bring them into awareness. Its techniques included free association (saying whatever comes to mind), dream analysis, interpreting resistance (blocking painful material) and analysing transference, in which the patient directs feelings about important people, such as a parent, onto the analyst. Classic analysis took years. Modern psychodynamic therapy keeps the focus on unconscious patterns but is shorter and face to face. With children, therapists often use play therapy, either nondirective (the child plays freely) or directive (the therapist guides the play).

Behaviour therapy and exposure

Behaviour therapy assumes problem behaviours are learned, so they can be changed by applying learning principles, without searching for hidden causes. Counterconditioning teaches a new response to an old trigger. In aversive conditioning, an unwanted behaviour is paired with something unpleasant, such as a bitter nail varnish for nail biting; its long-term effects are often limited. Exposure therapy treats fear by facing the feared object or situation safely until the fear fades. Mary Cover Jones reported the first case in 1924, gradually bringing a rabbit closer to a frightened boy while he ate. Joseph Wolpe later developed systematic desensitisation, and virtual reality now allows exposure to flying, heights or traumatic scenes.

Worked example: a fear hierarchy

Systematic desensitisation pairs relaxation with a graded list of feared situations, on the principle that a person cannot be deeply relaxed and anxious at once. Consider Noor, who is afraid of dogs. 1. Relaxation: she learns progressive muscle relaxation, tensing and releasing each muscle group. 2. Hierarchy: she ranks situations from least to most frightening, for example a photo of a puppy, a video of a dog barking, a dog behind a fence and finally stroking a calm dog. 3. Pairing: while relaxed, she imagines the lowest item until it causes no anxiety, then moves up one step. 4. Real life: she works through the items in person. Check: each step is attempted only once the one below causes no fear.

Operant techniques

Other behaviour therapies use operant conditioning: behaviours that are reinforced become more frequent, and behaviours that are not reinforced fade. In a token economy, people in a structured setting, such as a hospital ward or classroom, earn tokens for target behaviours and exchange them for privileges. Applied behaviour analysis uses reinforcement to teach specific skills step by step and is widely used with some autistic children, though some autistic adults have criticised parts of it. One limitation: behaviour learned for tokens may stop when the rewards do.

Cognitive therapy and CBT

Cognitive therapy, developed by the psychiatrist Aaron Beck in the 1960s, holds that the way we interpret events shapes how we feel. Therapists help clients spot automatic negative thoughts and cognitive distortions, such as overgeneralisation (one failure means I always fail), all-or-nothing thinking and jumping to conclusions, then test them against evidence. Albert Ellis's rational emotive behaviour therapy similarly challenges irrational beliefs. Cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) combines changing thoughts with changing behaviour through homework and practice, and focuses on present problems rather than childhood. Hundreds of studies support CBT for depression, anxiety disorders, PTSD, eating disorders and other conditions.

Worked example: the ABC model

Ellis's ABC model separates an Activating event, a Belief about it, and the emotional and behavioural Consequences. Two friends, Tariq and Ben, each send a message to their group chat suggesting a film night, and nobody replies for a day. 1. A: the same unanswered message for both. 2. B for Tariq: "They don't want me around; nobody ever does." This overgeneralises from one silence. 3. C for Tariq: he feels hurt and stops suggesting plans. 4. B for Ben: "Everyone's busy this week; I'll ask again on Friday." 5. C for Ben: mild disappointment, then he tries again. Check: the event was identical, so the difference in consequences came from the beliefs, which is exactly what CBT targets.

Humanistic therapy

Humanistic therapies aim to help people understand and accept themselves and grow towards their potential. Unlike psychoanalysis, they focus on conscious thoughts and the present and future. Carl Rogers developed client-centred therapy, saying client rather than patient to avoid implying illness. It is nondirective: the therapist does not give advice or interpretations but helps the person clarify their own feelings. Rogers emphasised active listening (acknowledging, restating and clarifying what the client says) and three core conditions: genuineness, empathy and unconditional positive regard, an attitude of acceptance without judgement.

Does psychotherapy work?

Judging therapy needs controlled studies, because people often seek help at their worst and would tend to improve anyway (regression towards the mean), and expectations alone can help (a placebo effect). Meta-analyses, statistical summaries of many studies, show psychotherapy is clearly more effective than no treatment for many conditions. Well-established approaches, such as CBT and psychodynamic therapy, often show similar overall results, though some, such as exposure for phobias, have especially strong evidence for particular problems. A consistent predictor of success across approaches is the therapeutic alliance, the working bond of trust and shared goals between client and therapist. The American Psychological Association defines evidence-based practice as integrating the best available research with clinical expertise and the client's own characteristics, culture and preferences.

Biomedical treatments

Psychotropic medications are prescribed by medical doctors, including psychiatrists, and in a handful of US states by specially trained psychologists. They change the activity of neurotransmitters and can ease symptoms, but they do not cure disorders. Main classes include antidepressants such as SSRIs, which increase available serotonin; antipsychotics for schizophrenia, whose long-term use can cause side effects such as tardive dyskinesia (involuntary movements) or weight gain; mood stabilisers such as lithium for bipolar disorder; anti-anxiety drugs such as benzodiazepines, which can be habit-forming; and stimulants for ADHD. For severe depression that has not responded to other treatment, electroconvulsive therapy is given under anaesthesia, and transcranial magnetic stimulation, cleared by the FDA in 2008, uses magnetic pulses. All such decisions belong with a prescriber.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, picturing all therapy as Freud's couch: most modern therapy is face to face and much is brief. Second, confusing transference (feelings directed at the therapist) with resistance (blocking painful material). Third, thinking exposure means sudden flooding: systematic desensitisation is gradual and paired with relaxation. Fourth, calling client-centred therapy advice-giving: it is nondirective. Fifth, believing medication cures a disorder: it manages symptoms. Sixth, assuming one therapy is best for everyone: the alliance and a good fit matter greatly.

Key takeaways

Treatment is psychotherapy, biomedical therapy or both. Psychoanalysis uses free association, dream analysis, resistance and transference; modern psychodynamic therapy is briefer, and play therapy suits children. Behaviour therapy applies conditioning: exposure, systematic desensitisation, aversive conditioning and token economies. Beck's cognitive therapy and CBT change distorted thoughts and behaviour; Ellis's ABC model shows beliefs shaping consequences. Rogers's client-centred therapy offers genuineness, empathy and unconditional positive regard. Psychotherapy works, and the therapeutic alliance predicts success. Medications ease symptoms but do not cure. This topic is education only: talk to a qualified professional about any treatment, and in a US crisis, call or text 988.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Psychotherapy

Psychological treatment with a trained professional

Versus biomedical therapy.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

During psychoanalysis, a patient begins treating the analyst with the resentment she feels towards her father. Freud called this:

Question 2 of 5

In systematic desensitisation, why is relaxation paired with each step of the fear hierarchy?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement best describes client-centred therapy?

Question 4 of 5

Using the ABC model, what explains why two people react differently to the same unanswered message?

Question 5 of 5

Which is accurate about psychotropic medication?

← Previous topicNext topic →