Psychology › Section P · Therapy and treatment › Topic P.1

Mental health treatment past and present

How a society treats people with psychological disorders reflects what it believes causes them. This topic traces care from supernatural explanations and locked asylums to today's community services, and explains how people enter treatment now. It is for learning, not for diagnosing yourself or anyone else.

How many people need and receive care?

Psychological disorders are common. US federal surveys in the early 2020s estimated that more than one in five adults had a diagnosable mental illness in a given year, and that only about half of them received any treatment. Children whose difficulties disrupt others, as with ADHD, are more likely to be treated than children whose anxiety goes unnoticed. Treatment itself has changed enormously, and the story begins when the main explanations were supernatural.

Supernatural explanations

In many ancient and medieval societies, strange behaviour was blamed on spirits, demons, witchcraft or angry gods, so treatment aimed at the supposed spirit: prayer, rituals and exorcism. Skulls from as far back as the Stone Age show trephination, holes cut deliberately into the skull. Archaeologists debate its purpose, which may have included releasing spirits as well as treating head injuries, and healed bone shows that many people survived it. Not everyone held supernatural views. The Greek physician Hippocrates, around 400 BCE, argued that mental disturbances had natural causes in the body, an idea that resurfaced repeatedly over the following centuries.

Witch hunts and the first asylums

From about the late 1400s to the 1700s, witch trials in Europe and its colonies led to the execution of tens of thousands of people. An old textbook claim says most of the accused were mentally ill, but historians now reject it: accusations usually grew out of local conflict, fear and religious politics. Asylums to confine people with mental illness spread in the 1600s and 1700s; London's Bethlem Hospital, which had housed such patients since the Middle Ages, gave English the word bedlam. Their purpose was to remove people from society, not to treat them, and inmates were often chained, beaten and kept in filth.

Reformers: moral treatment and Dorothea Dix

From the late 1790s, first at the Bicêtre and then at the Salpêtrière hospital in Paris, the hospital superintendent Jean-Baptiste Pussin and the physician Philippe Pinel removed patients' chains and replaced brutality with conversation, activity and respect. In England, the Quaker William Tuke opened the York Retreat in 1796 on similar lines. This moral treatment movement found that many patients improved. In the United States, the teacher Dorothea Dix spent the 1840s and later decades documenting the abuse of poor people with mental illness in jails and almshouses. Her lobbying of state legislatures helped found or expand dozens of state psychiatric hospitals.

The state hospital era

The new state hospitals were meant to heal, but many became overcrowded warehouses as patient numbers rose far faster than funding. By the early 1900s, stays of years or decades were common, staff were few and treatments could be harsh: prolonged cold baths, restraints and, from the late 1930s, early forms of electroshock given without anaesthesia or muscle relaxants. Some large institutions did not close until the 1990s. Today's electroconvulsive therapy is a different procedure, given under general anaesthesia with careful monitoring, and is covered with other biomedical treatments in the next topic.

Deinstitutionalisation

Two developments emptied the old hospitals. First, the antipsychotic drug chlorpromazine reached US hospitals in the mid-1950s and reduced symptoms of psychosis, such as hallucinations and delusions, for many patients. Second, the Community Mental Health Act of 1963, signed by President John F. Kennedy, funded local mental health centres so people could be treated near home. This shift, called deinstitutionalisation, cut the state hospital population from a peak of over half a million in 1955 to a small fraction of that by the 1990s. Many people gained freedom, but the community services that were supposed to replace the hospitals were never adequately funded.

Worked example: tracing the consequences

Follow the cause-and-effect chain of deinstitutionalisation. 1. Cause: new drugs and civil rights concerns made long-term confinement seem unnecessary and unjust. 2. Policy: the 1963 act funded community centres, and states closed hospital beds, partly to save money. 3. Gap: many centres were underfunded, staff were not trained for severe illnesses such as schizophrenia, and housing, food and job support were missing. 4. Effect: many people with serious mental illness ended up homeless or in contact with police. 5. Long-term effect: today, jails and prisons hold far more people with serious mental illness than psychiatric hospitals do, a pattern sometimes called transinstitutionalisation. Check: the policy goal was sound; the failure lay in the missing community support.

Where and from whom people get treatment today

Most people with a disorder are never hospitalised. They are seen as outpatients in community mental health centres, private practices, clinics, schools, workplaces, primary care and, increasingly, by video. Psychiatric hospital stays are now short, usually days to a couple of weeks, and are mainly for people in acute danger. Providers include psychiatrists (medical doctors who can prescribe medication), clinical psychologists, clinical social workers, licensed counsellors and marriage and family therapists; licensing rules vary by state. In a mental health crisis in the US, anyone can call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, at any hour.

Voluntary and involuntary treatment

Voluntary treatment means a person chooses to seek help, perhaps prompted by a friend, family member or doctor. Involuntary treatment is treatment the person has not chosen. It includes therapy ordered by a court, for instance as a condition of probation or parole, and emergency psychiatric holds. Every US state has laws allowing short-term involuntary hospitalisation, generally only when a person is judged, through a legal process, to be a danger to themselves or others or unable to care for themselves. These laws try to balance two values that can conflict: protecting people in crisis and respecting their liberty and right to refuse treatment.

Worked example: classifying routes into care

Classify each route into treatment. 1. A student books counselling at her college because she has felt low for weeks. She chose to go, so this is voluntary treatment. 2. A man convicted of drink-driving must attend weekly substance-use counselling under his probation terms. A court required it, so this is involuntary treatment. 3. A woman's doctor suggests therapy for panic attacks, and she agrees. A referral does not make treatment involuntary; she made the choice. 4. A person in a psychiatric emergency is held in hospital for evaluation under state law. This is involuntary, and it is legally limited in length. Check: the test is always whether the person chose the treatment, not who first suggested it.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, believing trephination patients almost always died: healed skulls show many survived. Second, claiming accused witches were mostly mentally ill: historians reject this. Third, crediting Dorothea Dix with the first US asylums: public asylums existed before her, though she helped found or expand many. Fourth, treating deinstitutionalisation as simply good or bad: it freed many people but lacked the community support it needed. Fifth, assuming any referral makes treatment involuntary: the person's own choice is what counts. Sixth, thinking most treatment happens in hospitals: most is outpatient.

Key takeaways

Over one in five US adults has a mental illness in a given year, and only about half receive treatment. Supernatural explanations once led to exorcism, and witch trials killed tens of thousands, though not mainly people with mental illness. Asylums confined rather than treated until Pinel, Pussin and Tuke introduced moral treatment and Dix expanded US state hospitals. Antipsychotics and the 1963 Community Mental Health Act drove deinstitutionalisation, whose underfunded aftermath left many homeless or jailed. Care today is mostly outpatient, voluntary or involuntary. This topic is education only: anyone struggling should talk to a qualified professional, and in a crisis in the US, call or text 988.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Treatment gap

Only about half of US adults with a mental illness receive treatment

Early-2020s federal survey estimates.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What does archaeological evidence suggest about prehistoric trephination?

Question 2 of 5

Which pair of developments drove deinstitutionalisation in the United States?

Question 3 of 5

What was the main failure of deinstitutionalisation?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is an example of involuntary treatment?

Question 5 of 5

Who removed patients' chains at Paris hospitals around 1800 and introduced more humane care?

← Previous topicNext topic →