Psychology › Section L · Social psychology › Topic L.1

What is social psychology? Attributions

Why did that driver cut you off, and why did you fail that test? Social psychology begins with the explanations people give for behaviour, and those everyday explanations turn out to be biased in predictable ways.

Social psychology and the power of the situation

Social psychology studies how the actual, imagined or implied presence of other people shapes what we think, feel and do. Its topics run from the individual level, such as attitudes, the self and social cognition (how we think about ourselves and others), to the level of pairs and groups: conformity, prejudice, aggression, helping, attraction and group decisions. One idea links them all: situations are often more powerful than we expect. This section starts with a quiet version of that idea: the explanations we give for each other's actions.

Dispositions, situations and attributions

An attribution is an explanation of why a behaviour happened. Fritz Heider (1958) argued that people act as naive scientists, sorting causes into two kinds. A dispositional, or internal, attribution points to the person: their traits, abilities or attitudes. A situational, or external, attribution points to the circumstances: the task, other people, luck or pressure. A classmate who says little in a seminar might be shy (dispositional) or new to a group whose members all know each other (situational). Historically, social psychologists stressed situations and personality psychologists stressed dispositions. Today most researchers study how the two interact.

The fundamental attribution error

When we explain other people's behaviour, we tend to overrate their dispositions and underrate their situations. Lee Ross (1977) named this the fundamental attribution error; it is also called correspondence bias. In a classic study by Edward Jones and Victor Harris (1967), students read essays that praised or attacked Fidel Castro. Even when told that each writer had been assigned their side, readers still judged that the writers believed what they had written. A related shortcut is the halo effect: one positive impression, such as good looks or warmth, colours judgements of unrelated qualities such as honesty or intelligence.

The quizmaster study

Lee Ross, Teresa Amabile and Julia Steinmetz (1977) randomly assigned students to be quizmasters or contestants. Quizmasters wrote hard questions from their own areas of knowledge, an obvious built-in advantage, and contestants struggled to answer them. Afterwards, contestants rated the quizmasters as more knowledgeable than themselves, and in a follow-up, observers who watched the quiz did the same. Everyone knew the roles were random, yet they read the outcome as a fact about the people. The quizmasters, who knew how they had chosen their questions, did not rate themselves as superior.

Culture shapes the error

The fundamental attribution error is strongest in individualist cultures, which stress personal independence and achievement, such as the United States, Canada and much of western Europe. People raised in more collectivist cultures, which stress relationships and group harmony, as in much of East Asia, Latin America and Africa, more often weigh the situation as well. Michael Morris and Kaiping Peng (1994) compared newspaper coverage of two mass killings in 1991: an English-language American paper dwelt more on the killers' personalities, while a Chinese-language paper said more about their circumstances and relationships.

Actor-observer bias

The actor-observer bias is the tendency to explain our own behaviour by situations but other people's by their dispositions (Edward Jones and Richard Nisbett, 1971). If you snap at a friend, you know you slept badly; when a friend snaps at you, you may decide they are irritable. One reason is information: actors know their own history, moods and pressures, while observers see only the act. Another is viewpoint: the actor looks out at the situation, while the observer looks at the actor. However, a meta-analysis by Bertram Malle (2006) of more than 170 studies found the average effect close to zero, appearing only under particular conditions.

Self-serving bias

The self-serving bias is the tendency to credit our successes to ourselves and blame our failures on circumstances: 'I passed because I'm good at this' but 'I failed because the questions were unfair'. Bernard Weiner (1979) described attributions on three dimensions: locus (internal or external), stability (lasting or temporary) and controllability (within our control or not). Fans tend to explain a team's wins as internal, stable and controllable (talent, hard work, good tactics) and its losses as external, unstable and uncontrollable (poor refereeing, bad weather). The bias protects self-esteem; it appears across cultures but tends to be smaller in East Asian samples.

The just-world hypothesis

Melvin Lerner proposed that many people need to believe the world is fair: that people get what they deserve and deserve what they get. Belief in a just world makes life feel predictable and controllable, but it has a cost, which is victim blaming. In experiments by Lerner and Carolyn Simmons (1966), observers who watched a woman apparently receive electric shocks, and could do nothing to stop them, rated her less favourably than observers who could help. Just-world thinking can turn poverty, illness or assault into the victim's fault, a dispositional explanation that ignores job markets, health systems and the actions of perpetrators.

Worked example: sorting attributions

A new team member, Sam, misses two deadlines. 1. The manager says, 'Sam just isn't organised.' This explains someone else's behaviour by a trait and ignores the situation: a likely fundamental attribution error. 2. Sam says, 'Two other projects landed on my desk that week.' A situational explanation of one's own behaviour fits the actor-observer pattern. 3. Next month Sam's report wins praise and Sam says, 'I'm a strong writer.' Taking internal credit for success, after blaming circumstances for failure, is the self-serving bias. 4. Check: each explanation might be partly true. The bias lies in reaching for one kind of cause automatically, before looking at the evidence.

Worked example: three ways to explain a failed test

Priya fails her driving test and considers three explanations. Classify each on Weiner's dimensions. 1. 'The examiner was in a bad mood': external, unstable (a different examiner next time) and uncontrollable. 2. 'I'm just hopeless at driving': internal, stable and, as she frames it, uncontrollable. 3. 'I didn't practise reversing enough': internal, unstable and controllable. 4. Compare: the first protects her self-esteem but gives her nothing to work on, and the second may lead her to give up. Only the third points to a specific fix. 5. Check: the labels describe how she frames the cause, not whether it is true.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking social psychology says personality is irrelevant: modern work studies how person and situation interact. Second, confusing the fundamental attribution error, which concerns explaining other people, with the self-serving bias, which concerns explaining our own successes and failures. Third, treating the actor-observer bias as a universal rule: its average effect is small and depends on conditions. Fourth, assuming every culture shows the fundamental attribution error equally strongly. Fifth, mistaking a situational explanation for an excuse: explaining why something happened is not the same as approving of it.

Key takeaways

Social psychology stresses the power of the situation. Attributions explain behaviour by dispositions (internal) or situations (external) (Heider, 1958). The fundamental attribution error overrates dispositions when we explain others, as the essay and quizmaster studies showed, and it is stronger in individualist cultures. The halo effect lets one good impression colour unrelated judgements. The actor-observer bias explains our own acts by situations, though its average effect is small. The self-serving bias takes credit for success and blames failure on circumstances; Weiner's dimensions are locus, stability and controllability. Belief in a just world can lead to victim blaming.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Social psychology

The study of how other people shape our thoughts, feelings and behaviour

Its central theme is the power of the situation.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A reader is told that a student was assigned to argue for a policy in a debate, yet still concludes that the student personally supports it. Which bias does this show?

Question 2 of 5

In the quizmaster study, why did contestants rate the quizmasters as more knowledgeable than themselves?

Question 3 of 5

After a poor exam result, a student says, 'I didn't revise enough.' How does this attribution score on Weiner's three dimensions?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement best describes the current evidence on the actor-observer bias?

Question 5 of 5

Hearing that a neighbour's house was burgled, someone says she must have left a door unlocked. Which idea best explains this reaction?

← Previous topicNext topic →