Sociology › Section G · Deviance, crime, and social control › Topic G.1
Deviance and social control
Every group has rules, and every group has members who break them. Sociologists ask who decides what counts as rule-breaking, how groups push people back into line, and why some deviance turns out to be useful.
Deviance in everyday life
Sociologists define deviance as a violation of social norms: a mild breach of a folkway (an everyday custom), a serious breach of mores (norms with strong moral weight), or a breach of a written law. Talking loudly in a library, cheating on an exam and armed robbery are all deviant. First, deviant does not mean bad: it means departing from what a group expects, and some deviance, such as civil disobedience, is admired later. Second, deviance lies less in the act than in the reaction to it. Howard Becker argued in Outsiders (1963) that deviant behaviour is behaviour that people have successfully labelled as deviant.
Setting, audience and actor
Whether an act counts as deviant depends on where it happens, who is watching and who does it. Shouting is expected in a football stadium, draws stares in a hospital ward, and can bring a contempt-of-court penalty if aimed at a judge. The actor matters too: a toddler who grabs food from a stranger's plate is excused, while an adult is not. Because the judgement comes from the audience, sociologists treat deviance as a social definition rather than a fixed property of behaviour.
Deviance changes over time
As norms shift, so do definitions of deviance. Visible tattoos, divorce and women wearing trousers to school were widely frowned on in the mid-twentieth-century United States and are ordinary now; smoking moved the other way. Cannabis was sold openly until states began restricting it in the 1910s, and the federal Marihuana Tax Act of 1937 effectively outlawed it; historians argue that hostility towards Mexican immigrants helped drive those early laws. Since 2012 many states have legalised recreational use, though federal law still forbids it. Same-sex intimacy was a crime in many states until the Supreme Court struck down the remaining laws in Lawrence v. Texas (2003).
Deviance and crime
Crime is the narrower idea: behaviour that violates a formal law and can be punished by the state. Picture two overlapping circles. Some acts are deviant but legal, such as arriving at a formal wedding in a swimsuit. Some are illegal but barely seen as deviant, such as driving a few miles per hour over the limit. Burglary sits in both circles. Laws and norms can fall out of step: for decades sports betting was illegal almost everywhere in the United States, even though many people saw a small wager as harmless, until the Supreme Court's decision in Murphy v. NCAA (2018) let states legalise it.
Social control and sanctions
Social control is the set of ways a group regulates behaviour and enforces norms. Its goal is social order, the predictable patterns people rely on, such as drivers stopping at red lights. Most control is internal: socialisation teaches norms so thoroughly that many drivers wait at a red light at 3 a.m. with no one around. When that fails, sanctions step in. Positive sanctions reward conformity and negative sanctions punish violations. Formal sanctions are applied by an organisation under stated rules; informal sanctions arise in everyday interaction. That gives four types: a compliment (informal positive), an eye roll (informal negative), a scholarship (formal positive) and a fine (formal negative).
Worked example: classifying sanctions
Classify each response. 1. A teacher smiles when a student hands in work early: it rewards conformity and comes from everyday interaction, so it is positive and informal. 2. A city health department fines a restaurant for breaking hygiene rules: an official body applying written rules, so negative and formal. 3. Classmates stop sitting with a student who spread lies about them: negative and informal. 4. A company names a worker employee of the month at its annual ceremony: positive and formal. 5. Check: reward or penalty? Organisation or everyday reaction? Formal does not mean severe; being shunned can hurt more than a parking fine.
Stigma
In Stigma (1963), Erving Goffman described a stigma as an attribute that deeply discredits a person in others' eyes, so that one trait overshadows everything else about them. He identified three broad sources: visible bodily differences, supposed flaws of character (such as a prison record or an addiction) and membership of a devalued group, such as a race or religion. Goffman distinguished the discredited, whose stigma is already known, from the discreditable, whose stigma is hidden. The discreditable must manage information, often by passing, keeping the trait concealed; people whose trait is known may practise covering, playing it down.
Medicalisation
Medicalisation is the process by which behaviour once seen as sin, weakness or crime is redefined as an illness. Peter Conrad and Joseph Schneider (1980) called it a move from badness to sickness. Chronic heavy drinking came to be treated as the disease of alcoholism, and restless, inattentive children may now be diagnosed with ADHD. Supporters say a medical label reduces blame and opens the way to treatment. Critics reply that it extends the power of doctors and drug companies and can turn social problems, such as poverty, into individual disorders. It can also reverse: the American Psychiatric Association stopped classing homosexuality as a mental disorder in 1973.
Durkheim: deviance is normal
Émile Durkheim, in The Rules of Sociological Method (1895), claimed that crime is normal. Every known society has it, and even a community of near-saints would treat small lapses as offences, because groups always draw lines somewhere. He argued that deviance has functions. Punishing it reminds everyone where the moral boundaries lie. Shared outrage pulls a community together. And deviance can open the way to change: Rosa Parks in Montgomery in 1955, and the Black students who staged lunch-counter sit-ins from 1960, broke local rules, and their defiance helped shift the nation's norms.
Worked example: paint on a wall
Trace how one action is judged. 1. An artist sprays a design on a shop shutter at night without permission. The owner sees damage and the law calls it vandalism, so it is deviant and criminal. 2. The city later pays the same artist to paint a mural: a formal positive sanction. 3. During a protest, someone paints a slogan on a government building. Officials call it a crime; supporters call it political speech, so the label is contested. 4. Decades later, some once-illegal street art is preserved by cities or sold at auction. 5. Conclusion: whether painting a wall is deviant depends on permission, setting, who is judging and when.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating deviant with bad: deviance means breaking a norm, and some deviance is later admired. Second, treating deviance and crime as identical: much deviance is legal, and some crime is widely tolerated. Third, assuming formal sanctions are always harsher: formal describes who applies a sanction, not how much it hurts. Fourth, thinking social control means only the police: most control is internal or informal. Fifth, assuming medicalisation is simply good or simply bad: it can reduce blame while expanding professional control.
Key takeaways
Deviance is a violation of norms, and whether an act counts depends on setting, audience, actor and era. Crime is deviance that breaks a formal law. Social control maintains social order, mostly through internalised norms, backed by sanctions that are positive or negative and formal or informal. Goffman's stigma is a deeply discrediting attribute, managed differently by the discredited and the discreditable. Medicalisation redefines badness as sickness, with mixed effects. Durkheim held that deviance is normal and functional: it marks boundaries, unites groups and can drive change.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A violation of social norms, from folkways to formal laws
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best matches the sociological view of deviance?
Question 2 of 5
A city council presents a resident with an official plaque for twenty years of volunteering. What kind of sanction is this?
Question 3 of 5
A man with a prison record keeps it hidden from his new coworkers. In Goffman's terms, he is:
Question 4 of 5
Which of these is an example of medicalisation?
Question 5 of 5
According to Durkheim, which is a function of deviance?
