Sociology › Section G · Deviance, crime, and social control › Topic G.2
Theoretical perspectives on deviance and crime
Why do people break rules, and why are some rule-breakers punished far more than others? Sociology's three main perspectives each offer theories of deviance, and each points to different causes and different remedies.
Durkheim and the functionalist starting point
Theories of deviance fall under the three paradigms: functionalism, conflict theory and symbolic interactionism. Functionalists ask what deviance does for society. Durkheim, as Deviance and social control showed, held that deviance is normal and that punishing it reaffirms shared values. In The Division of Labour in Society (1893) he linked law to the collective conscience, a society's shared beliefs and morals: an act is criminal because the community condemns it. He also used the term anomie for a state in which norms are weak or unclear, an idea Robert Merton later reworked.
Merton's strain theory
In his 1938 article "Social Structure and Anomie", Robert Merton argued that American culture urges everyone to pursue financial success but does not give everyone equal access to legitimate means of reaching it, such as good schools and well-paid jobs. The gap between goals and means creates strain. Merton described five ways people adapt. Conformity accepts both the goals and the approved means. Innovation accepts the goal but uses illegitimate means, such as fraud or theft. Ritualism gives up the goal but follows the rules rigidly. Retreatism rejects both goals and means and withdraws. Rebellion rejects both and tries to replace them with new ones.
Worked example: Merton's five adaptations
Classify each person. 1. A nurse studies at night for a promotion and saves steadily: goal and means both accepted, so conformity. 2. A sales manager inflates figures to win bonuses: the goal of wealth is kept but the means are illegitimate, so innovation. 3. A clerk who long ago stopped hoping for promotion still follows every procedure to the letter: goal dropped, means kept, so ritualism. 4. A man drops out of work and society altogether: both rejected, so retreatism. 5. Activists who reject consumer success and build a commune with its own rules: rejection plus replacement is rebellion. Check: for each case, ask whether the goal is kept and whether the means are approved.
Social disorganisation and collective efficacy
Chicago School sociologists, notably Clifford Shaw and Henry McKay, mapped juvenile delinquency across their city from the 1920s to the 1940s. Rates stayed high in the same inner districts for decades, even as one immigrant group after another moved through. They concluded that the cause lay in the neighbourhood, not in any group: poverty, rapid population turnover and weak local institutions undermine informal social control. Later, Robert Sampson and colleagues (1997) added the idea of collective efficacy, the mix of trust among neighbours and their willingness to step in for the common good, and found it linked to lower violence even in poor areas.
Conflict theory: power and the law
Conflict theorists ask who makes the rules and whom they protect. Building on Marx, they argue that laws and their enforcement tend to reflect the interests of the powerful. C. Wright Mills described a power elite of corporate, political and military leaders in The Power Elite (1956). Edwin Sutherland coined the term white-collar crime in 1939 for offences committed by respectable, high-status people in the course of their work, such as fraud and embezzlement. Conflict theorists stress that such crimes often cause large losses yet draw lighter punishment than street crime.
Unequal penalties: crack and powder cocaine
Conflict theorists often cite the federal Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1986. It set the same mandatory minimum sentence for 5 grams of crack cocaine as for 500 grams of powder cocaine, a 100-to-1 ratio, even though the two are forms of the same drug. The US Sentencing Commission later reported that most federal crack defendants were Black, while most powder defendants were Hispanic or White. Critics argue the law punished the less powerful far more harshly. Others note that some Black political leaders, alarmed by crack's toll, supported the law, so its origins were not simply about class power. The Fair Sentencing Act of 2010 cut the ratio to 18 to 1.
Labelling theory
Symbolic interactionists study how deviance is defined in interaction. Labelling theory, associated with Howard Becker, stresses whether others label a person deviant. Edwin Lemert distinguished primary deviance, rule-breaking that does not change how people see themselves or how others treat them, from secondary deviance, which follows when a person accepts a deviant label and begins to act it out. A label can become a master status, the trait that defines someone above all others, such as "ex-convict". William Chambliss's study "The Saints and the Roughnecks" (1973) found that middle-class boys who misbehaved were excused while working-class boys were labelled troublemakers, and the labels shaped their later lives.
Techniques of neutralisation
Gresham Sykes and David Matza (1957) asked how young offenders who mostly shared conventional values could still break the law. Their answer was five justifications that neutralise guilt in advance. Denial of responsibility: "it wasn't my fault". Denial of injury: "nobody really got hurt". Denial of the victim: "they had it coming". Condemnation of the condemners: "the people judging me are hypocrites". Appeal to higher loyalties: "I did it for my friends or family". These excuses let people see themselves as basically good while deviating, which helps explain why many resist a deviant label.
Learning deviance and social bonds
Edwin Sutherland's differential association theory, first set out in 1939, holds that deviance is learned through interaction in close groups, like any other behaviour. People learn techniques, motives and attitudes, and a person turns to crime when the definitions favourable to breaking the law that they encounter outweigh those against it. Travis Hirschi's control theory, in Causes of Delinquency (1969), flips the question: why do most people conform? His answer is social bonds: attachment to others, commitment to conventional goals, involvement in conventional activities and belief in the rules. Weak bonds leave people freer to deviate. Textbooks classify control theory differently; it draws on Durkheim's ideas about social ties.
Worked example: one case, several theories
A 19-year-old joins friends in stealing catalytic converters from parked cars. 1. Strain: he wants money and status but sees no route to them through his low-paid job, so he innovates. 2. Differential association: his friends taught him the technique and treat the thefts as clever, not shameful. 3. Control theory: he has left school, rarely sees his family and has no commitments he fears losing. 4. Neutralisation: he tells himself insurance will pay, a denial of injury. 5. Labelling: if he is arrested and branded a thief, secondary deviance may follow. 6. Conflict: his theft may be punished more harshly than a firm's large-scale wage theft. 7. Each theory implies a different remedy: jobs, new peers, stronger bonds or fairer enforcement.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up Merton's adaptations: innovation keeps the goal but swaps the means, ritualism keeps the means but drops the goal. Second, thinking labelling theory says labels cause all deviance: primary deviance comes first, and labels shape what follows. Third, confusing denial of injury (no real harm) with denial of the victim (the victim deserved it). Fourth, treating social disorganisation as a claim about particular ethnic groups: Shaw and McKay's point was that the neighbourhood, not the group, mattered. Fifth, assuming one theory is correct: each explains some cases better than others.
Key takeaways
Functionalists see deviance as normal: Durkheim linked law to the collective conscience, Merton traced deviance to strain between goals and means, and Shaw and McKay tied crime to disorganised neighbourhoods, refined by Sampson's collective efficacy. Conflict theorists (Marx, Mills) show how power shapes law and enforcement, as with white-collar crime and the 1986 crack ratio. Interactionists study labelling (Becker, Lemert, Chambliss), neutralisation (Sykes and Matza) and learning (Sutherland); Hirschi's control theory stresses social bonds.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Deviance arises from a gap between cultural goals and legitimate means
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A clerk stopped hoping for promotion years ago but still follows every office procedure exactly. Which of Merton's adaptations is this?
Question 2 of 5
After repeated suspensions and being called a troublemaker, a student starts to see himself that way and acts accordingly. Lemert would call this:
Question 3 of 5
An employee who takes laptops from work says, "It's a huge company with insurance. Nobody actually loses anything." Which technique of neutralisation is this?
Question 4 of 5
Shaw and McKay found that delinquency stayed high in the same Chicago districts for decades as different immigrant groups moved through. What did they conclude?
Question 5 of 5
A sociologist asks whose interests were served by a law that punished crack far more harshly than powder cocaine. Which perspective is this question typical of?
