Sociology › Section C · Culture › Topic C.2

Elements of culture

Every culture is built from the same kinds of parts: values and beliefs about what matters, norms about how to behave, sanctions that keep people in line, and the symbols and language that carry it all. Learn the parts and you can take any culture apart, including your own.

Taking a culture apart

What is culture? defined culture as a group's learned, shared way of life and split it into material and nonmaterial parts. This topic looks inside the nonmaterial side. Sociologists usually pick out five elements: values, beliefs, norms, symbols and language. Values say what is worth wanting, beliefs say what is true, norms say how to behave, and symbols and language let people share all of it and pass it on. A sixth piece, the system of rewards and penalties called sanctions, keeps the norms working.

Values and beliefs

In sociology a value is not a price but a shared standard of what is good, desirable or worth pursuing: education, freedom, family or loyalty, for example. Beliefs are specific statements people hold to be true, such as "a college degree leads to a better life". Values sit underneath beliefs: that belief rests on valuing education and achievement. Cultures weigh values differently. In a widely cited comparison of employees in dozens of countries (1980), the Dutch researcher Geert Hofstede placed the United States at the top for individualism, the priority of the individual over the group; many other cultures were more collectivist, putting the group's welfare first.

Ideal culture and real culture

Values describe how people think they should live, not always how they do live. Sociologists call the standards a society claims to hold its ideal culture, and the way people actually behave its real culture. Most students value honesty, yet cheating on assignments still happens; most people value good health, yet many skip exercise. The gap is not just hypocrisy: values compete with each other and with convenience. Studying the gap between ideal and real culture tells sociologists where a society's rules are under strain.

Norms: formal and informal

Norms are the rules and expectations that guide behaviour in a group. Formal norms are written down and enforced by an organisation: laws, school codes of conduct, workplace safety rules, the rules of a sport. They are the most clearly stated and usually the most strictly enforced. Informal norms are unwritten and learned by watching others: face the door in a lift, do not stand right next to the only other person at a bus stop, reply to a message within a reasonable time. Informal norms far outnumber formal ones, and newcomers struggle with them because nobody explains them.

Folkways, mores and taboos

William Graham Sumner, in Folkways (1906), sorted norms by their moral weight. Folkways are everyday customs with little moral force: eating salad with your fingers at a formal dinner draws a puzzled look, nothing more. Mores (pronounced MOR-ays) carry strong moral weight, and breaking them brings outrage: stealing from a friend, mistreating a child, betraying your country. Many mores are also written into law. Sociologists rank taboos, a word from Polynesian languages, above both as the strongest prohibitions of all, acts so offensive that most people find even the idea revolting, such as incest or cannibalism. The same act can be a folkway in one culture and a more in another.

Sanctions and social control

Norms work because people reward conformity and punish breaches. These responses are sanctions, and together they form social control, the ways a group encourages people to follow its norms. Sanctions vary on two dimensions. Positive sanctions reward: praise, a smile, a bonus, a medal. Negative sanctions punish: a frown, gossip, a fine, prison. Formal sanctions come from an organisation, such as a court, an employer or a school; informal sanctions come from ordinary people in everyday life. Most of the time people conform before any sanction arrives, because they have learned to expect it.

Worked example: the rules of a lunch queue

Students queue for lunch in a school canteen. Identify the elements. 1. Value: fairness, the idea that people should be served in the order they arrive. 2. Norm: wait your turn, an informal norm that nobody writes down but everyone knows. 3. Its weight: queue-jumping usually breaks a folkway, but pushing in ahead of someone with a disability might feel closer to a breach of mores. 4. Sanctions: a queue-jumper meets sighs, comments and glares, negative informal sanctions; if staff send them to the back, the sanction becomes formal. 5. Comparison: numbered tickets turn the informal norm into a formal system. 6. Check: every element links back to the value of fairness.

Worked example: a breaching experiment

The American sociologist Harold Garfinkel (1917-2011) studied the unspoken rules of everyday life in Studies in Ethnomethodology (1967). In one exercise, his students spent a short time at home behaving like polite lodgers: formal, distant, asking permission for everything. Analyse it. 1. The norm breached: family members act with easy familiarity. 2. The reaction: relatives were bewildered, then annoyed, and demanded to know what was wrong. 3. What it reveals: the norm was invisible until it was broken, yet everyone was following it. 4. The wider point: social order is not automatic; people keep producing it in each interaction. 5. A caution: deceiving people, even briefly, raises the issues covered in Ethical concerns in research.

Symbols and language

A symbol is anything carrying a meaning recognised by people who share a culture: a word, a gesture, a flag, a colour. Meanings are learned. White is worn by brides in many Western countries but has traditionally been the colour of mourning in parts of East Asia. Gestures vary too: a hand sign that means "OK" in the United States can be an insult elsewhere. Language is the most important symbol system: sounds, written signs or hand shapes combined to communicate. American Sign Language is a full language with its own grammar. Through language, culture is taught to each new generation.

Does language shape thought?

The linguist Edward Sapir and his student Benjamin Lee Whorf argued in the 1920s and 1930s that the language people speak shapes how they see the world; later writers named this the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, or linguistic relativity. A strong version, that language fixes thought so people cannot grasp ideas their language lacks, has been largely rejected: people translate and invent new words. A weaker version, that language nudges perception and memory, has some experimental support. Russian has separate basic words for light blue and dark blue, and in a 2007 study Russian speakers told two blues apart faster when they fell on opposite sides of that boundary; English speakers showed no such advantage.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing values with beliefs: a value is an ideal, such as education; a belief is a claim held to be true, such as "a degree pays off". Second, assuming ideal culture describes real behaviour. Third, mixing up formal and informal norms with mores and folkways: the first pair is about whether a rule is written down, the second about its moral weight. Fourth, thinking sanctions are only punishments: rewards count too. Fifth, taking the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis in its strong form: evidence supports influence, not a cage.

Key takeaways

Values are shared ideals of the good; beliefs are statements held to be true; ideal culture is what a society claims, real culture what people do. Norms guide behaviour: formal norms are written and enforced by organisations, informal norms are unwritten. By moral weight, norms run from folkways to mores (Sumner, 1906) to taboos. Sanctions, positive or negative and formal or informal, make up social control. Garfinkel's breaching experiments exposed hidden norms. Symbols and language carry culture, and the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis holds, in its supported weak form, that language influences perception.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Value

A shared standard of what is good, desirable or worth pursuing

Education, freedom, loyalty.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

"Getting a college degree leads to a better life." A sociologist would classify this statement as:

Question 2 of 5

Arriving at a job interview in pyjamas would most likely break a:

Question 3 of 5

A student rolls her eyes when a classmate talks loudly on the phone in the library. Her reaction is a:

Question 4 of 5

Which statement best reflects current research on the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis?

Question 5 of 5

In Garfinkel's breaching experiments, researchers deliberately broke small unwritten rules in order to:

← Previous topicNext topic →