Sociology › Section C · Culture › Topic C.3

Pop culture, subcultures, countercultures, and change

No culture is one solid block. Inside every society there are elite tastes and mass entertainment, groups with styles of their own and groups in open revolt, and the whole mix keeps shifting as new ideas and objects arrive and spread.

Variety inside one culture

Earlier topics treated a culture as one shared way of life. That is a useful starting point, but any large society contains many variations. A retired orchestra player and a teenage gamer in the same city share a language, laws and many values, yet their tastes, slang and weekends differ sharply. Sociologists sort this variety in two ways: by class-linked tastes, such as high and popular culture, and by groups that stand apart from the mainstream or against it. They also ask how it all changes.

High, low and popular culture

High culture describes the tastes and activities associated with a society's elite: opera, ballet, classical concerts, fine art. Popular culture, or pop culture, is the culture of the mainstream: films, chart music, sport, video games and social media trends, spread mainly by commercial media. Some writers also speak of low culture, tastes linked with the poorest groups, though many sociologists see the label as a snobbish judgement. The boundaries move. Shakespeare's plays drew crowds of ordinary Londoners, including standing spectators who paid a penny, yet today they are taught as high culture. Jazz made a similar journey in the 20th century.

Bourdieu's cultural capital

The French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (1930-2002) argued that tastes are not just personal preferences: they help mark and reproduce class. He called the knowledge, skills and tastes that bring social advantage cultural capital, and described three forms. Embodied capital lives in the person: an accent, manners, ease with art or wine. Objectified capital lies in possessions, such as books, paintings or instruments. Institutionalised capital takes the form of credentials, such as a degree from a prestigious university. Bourdieu argued that children from wealthier homes absorb embodied capital early, and schools may reward it as if it were natural talent.

Subcultures

A subculture is a group within a society whose members share the wider culture but also a distinctive set of values, norms, styles or interests. Ethnic communities that keep their heritage languages and foods, skateboarders, cosplayers, competitive gamers, surfers and motorcycle clubs are all examples. Subcultures can be based on ethnicity, religion, region, age, occupation or hobby. Members usually work, vote and shop like everyone else; the subculture adds a layer of identity and belonging. Many develop their own slang, dress or rituals, which mainstream fashion and advertising often borrow.

Countercultures

A counterculture goes further: its members reject some of the dominant culture's central values and norms and try to live by alternatives. The best-known US example is the counterculture of the 1960s, whose young members opposed the Vietnam War, rejected consumerism and conventional careers, and in some cases set up communes. Countercultures range from peaceful to dangerous; violent extremist groups that reject the law are countercultures too. Some fade, some are suppressed, and some see parts of their outlook absorbed: historians often trace later mainstream environmentalism partly to the 1960s. The line between subculture and counterculture is a matter of degree.

Worked example: hip hop's journey

Trace hip hop with the terms so far. 1. Origin: in the 1970s, African American, Caribbean and Latino young people in the Bronx, New York, created hip hop through DJing, rapping, breakdancing and graffiti. It was a subculture, sharing American culture while building its own styles. 2. Countercultural edges: some lyrics challenged police treatment and poverty, rejecting mainstream accounts of life in poor neighbourhoods. 3. Spread: recordings and later the internet carried it abroad, where artists rapped in French, Korean and many other languages. 4. Mainstream: it became one of the best-selling music genres, and breaking was an Olympic sport at Paris 2024. 5. Check: the same practice moved from subculture towards popular culture as it spread.

Innovation and diffusion

Cultures change in two main ways. Innovation brings something new, in one of two kinds. A discovery makes known something that already existed: in 1928 Alexander Fleming noticed a mould's existing power to kill bacteria, leading to penicillin. An invention combines existing things in a new way: the printing press developed by Johannes Gutenberg in the mid-15th century joined a screw press, ink and movable metal type. Diffusion is the spread of cultural items from one group or society to another, as coffee spread from Ethiopia and Yemen across the Ottoman world and into Europe by the 17th century. Everett Rogers, in Diffusion of Innovations (1962), described how adoption spreads from innovators and early adopters to the majority and, last, to laggards.

Cultural lag

Different parts of culture change at different speeds. The American sociologist William F. Ogburn, in Social Change (1922), used the term cultural lag for the delay between a change in material culture and the adjustment of nonmaterial culture, such as laws, norms and values. His own example was factory machinery: industrial accidents multiplied for decades before laws requiring compensation for injured workers caught up. Today, laws about online privacy trail the spread of smartphones and data collection, and rules on artificial intelligence are still being written while the tools spread. A lag is not permanent; it is the period during which old rules fit new conditions badly.

Globalisation and culture

Globalisation, the growing connection of the world's economies and societies through trade, travel, migration and media, speeds up diffusion. Critics worry about homogenisation, a single global culture dominated by Western brands. Yet cultural flows run in many directions: Korean pop music, Nigerian films and Japanese anime have global audiences. Global products are also adapted locally, a process the sociologist Roland Robertson popularised as glocalisation: McDonald's restaurants in India, for example, do not serve beef. Societies also differ in how they handle diversity at home. Canada adopted an official policy of multiculturalism in 1971, recognising and supporting many cultures rather than expecting full assimilation.

Worked example: phones in the classroom

Apply the change concepts to smartphones in schools. 1. Innovation: the smartphone is an invention, combining a telephone, a camera, a computer and internet access. 2. Diffusion: following Rogers's pattern, a few students owned one first, then most, until a student without one stood out. 3. Cultural lag: for years schools had no settled rules; teachers improvised while the devices were already in every pocket. 4. New norms: schools and governments in several countries have since restricted phones during lessons, an example of nonmaterial culture catching up. 5. Check: material change came first, and norms followed it slowly.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating high culture as better culture: sociologists describe tastes linked to class, they do not rank them. Second, confusing subcultures with countercultures: a subculture adds to the wider culture, a counterculture rejects key parts of it. Third, swapping discovery and invention: a discovery reveals what already existed, an invention combines existing things in a new way. Fourth, thinking cultural lag means a culture is backward: it describes the gap between material and nonmaterial change, which every society experiences. Fifth, assuming globalisation simply makes every culture identical.

Key takeaways

High culture is linked with elites, popular culture with the mainstream, and the boundary shifts over time. Bourdieu's cultural capital, embodied, objectified and institutionalised, links taste to class. Subcultures share the wider culture with distinctive styles; countercultures reject key parts of it. Cultures change through innovation, either discovery or invention, and through diffusion, which Rogers (1962) traced from innovators to laggards. Ogburn's cultural lag (1922) is the delay before norms and laws catch up with material change. Globalisation spreads culture in many directions, with local adaptation.

Flashcards

Flashcard

High culture

Tastes and activities associated with a society's elite

Opera, ballet, fine art.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A group of competitive cyclists has its own slang, clothing and weekend rituals, but its members hold ordinary jobs and share mainstream values. This group is best described as a:

Question 2 of 5

For years after smartphones spread, many schools had no clear rules about them. Ogburn would call this:

Question 3 of 5

Which of these is an invention rather than a discovery?

Question 4 of 5

In Bourdieu's terms, a degree from a prestigious university is an example of:

Question 5 of 5

Sushi restaurants opening in towns across the United States illustrate:

← Previous topicNext topic →