Sociology › Section T · Population, cities, and environment › Topic T.3
The environment and society
Polluted air, rising seas and toxic waste are physical problems, but who causes them, who suffers from them and who gets to decide what is done are social questions. Environmental sociology studies those questions.
Society and nature are linked
Environmental sociology studies the relationships between human societies and the natural environment. It treats the environment as something people both reshape and depend on: economies draw on forests, water and fossil fuels, and the resulting pollution and climate change feed back into health, jobs and migration. Sociologists ask why environmental harm is produced, how it is distributed and how groups mobilise to stop it. They do not judge the physical science themselves; they rely on natural scientists for that, and focus on the social causes, consequences and conflicts that surround it.
The tragedy of the commons
In 1968 the ecologist Garrett Hardin described the tragedy of the commons. Imagine a pasture open to all herders. Each gains the full profit of adding one more animal but shares the cost of overgrazing with everyone, so each keeps adding animals until the pasture is ruined. Hardin applied the logic to shared resources such as fisheries, clean air and the atmosphere. The political economist Elinor Ostrom, who won a Nobel Prize in economics in 2009, challenged his gloomy conclusion. In Governing the Commons (1990) she showed that many communities manage shared resources well for centuries, through local rules, monitoring and penalties, without either privatisation or central control.
Two theories of growth and harm
Sociologists disagree about whether economic growth must damage the environment. Allan Schnaiberg's treadmill of production theory (1980) argues that capitalist economies depend on constant growth: firms must expand to compete, governments need rising tax revenue, and workers need jobs, so resource use and pollution keep increasing. Ecological modernisation theory, developed by European scholars such as Arthur Mol and Gert Spaargaren, argues instead that cleaner technology, regulation and market pressure can decouple growth from harm, pointing to falling emissions in some wealthy countries. Critics of each reply that the treadmill underrates innovation, while modernisation overlooks pollution moved to poorer countries.
Climate change as a social problem
Burning coal, oil and gas has raised atmospheric carbon dioxide from about 280 parts per million before industrialisation to 423.9 in 2024, according to the World Meteorological Organization, which judged 2024 the warmest year on record, about 1.55 °C above the 1850 to 1900 average; long-term warming stands at roughly 1.3 to 1.4 °C. Causes and harms are unequal. Rich countries and rich people have produced most emissions, while poorer people, who emit least, are often most exposed to floods, heat and crop failure. The Paris Agreement of 2015 asks each country to set its own target; the United States withdrew with effect from January 2026.
Air, water and health
WHO estimates that about 99% of the world's people breathe air that exceeds its guideline limits, and that outdoor and household air pollution together cause millions of early deaths each year, most in low- and middle-income countries. Billions lack safe water, as the topic Global health showed. Wealthy countries are not immune. In 2014 the city of Flint, Michigan, a majority-Black city under state-appointed management, switched its water supply to the Flint River to save money without adequate corrosion control, and lead leached from old pipes into homes. Residents' complaints were dismissed for months, an example of how power shapes whose warnings count.
Waste and toxic sites
Rich societies produce vast amounts of waste. The US Environmental Protection Agency estimated that Americans generated about 292 million tons of municipal solid waste in 2018, roughly 4.9 pounds per person per day, of which about a third was recycled or composted. Much electronic waste is shipped to poorer countries, where it is often broken apart by hand. Toxic waste can poison whole communities. In 1978 residents of Love Canal, a neighbourhood in Niagara Falls, New York, discovered that their homes and school sat on buried chemical waste. The scandal led Congress to create the Superfund programme in 1980 to clean up hazardous sites.
Environmental racism and justice
Environmental racism is the disproportionate exposure of racial and ethnic minorities to pollution and hazards, and their exclusion from decisions about them. In 1982 residents of Warren County, North Carolina, a mainly Black county, protested a landfill for soil contaminated with toxic chemicals called PCBs, and more than 500 people were arrested. A 1987 report for the United Church of Christ found that race was the strongest predictor of where hazardous waste facilities were located. The sociologist Robert Bullard's Dumping in Dixie (1990) documented the pattern across the South. The environmental justice movement demands equal protection and a voice in siting decisions.
Native nations and the land
Native nations have faced particular environmental harms, often on land they were pushed onto. From the 1940s, uranium mining for nuclear weapons and power left more than 500 abandoned mines on the Navajo Nation, and many miners and families were exposed to radiation. In 2016 the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe led protests against the Dakota Access Pipeline, which crosses beneath a reservoir near its reservation, arguing that a spill could poison its water and that sacred sites had been damaged. Thousands of supporters joined. The pipeline was completed in 2017, and legal disputes over it continued for years.
Worked example: a fishery collapses
Trace a tragedy of the commons. 1. The resource: for centuries cod off Newfoundland supported fishing communities. 2. The incentive: after the 1950s, large trawlers from many countries could each profit by catching more, while the cost of depletion was shared. 3. The effect: catches peaked and then fell; scientists' warnings went largely unheeded. 4. The collapse: in 1992 Canada imposed a moratorium on northern cod fishing, and about 30,000 people lost work. 5. The lesson, following Ostrom: shared resources need enforceable rules that the users help design and monitor. Stocks have recovered only slowly, showing that some damage is hard to reverse.
Worked example: who benefits when it gets cleaner?
A low-income neighbourhood sits beside a highway and a chemical plant. 1. Exposure: environmental justice research finds higher asthma rates in such areas. 2. Explanation: land was cheap, residents had little political power, and earlier zoning placed industry there, as conflict theory predicts. 3. Change: the plant closes and the city builds a riverside park. 4. Consequence: the cleaner area attracts wealthier buyers, rents rise and many original residents leave, a process researchers call green gentrification. 5. Conclusion: an environmental improvement can still be unjust if the people who bore the pollution do not stay to enjoy the benefits.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming Hardin had the last word: Ostrom showed many communities manage commons successfully. Second, treating the treadmill and ecological modernisation as settled facts; they are competing theories with supporting evidence. Third, thinking environmental harm falls evenly: it tracks race, class and nationality. Fourth, mixing up a single record year, 1.55 °C in 2024, with long-term warming of about 1.3 to 1.4 °C. Fifth, assuming environmental clean-up always helps the most exposed: green gentrification can displace them.
Key takeaways
Environmental sociology studies how societies shape and depend on nature. Hardin's tragedy of the commons warns that shared resources are overused; Ostrom showed that local rules can prevent it. The treadmill of production links growth to harm; ecological modernisation argues they can be decoupled. Climate change, air and water pollution and waste fall hardest on the poor. Environmental racism, from Warren County in 1982 to Flint in 2014 and Standing Rock in 2016, sparked the environmental justice movement.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The study of relationships between societies and the natural environment
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Each boat owner in a shared fishery profits from catching more fish, while the cost of depletion falls on everyone, so the stock collapses. What concept is this?
Question 2 of 5
What did Elinor Ostrom's research show about shared resources?
Question 3 of 5
A scholar argues that cleaner technology and regulation have let some rich countries grow while cutting emissions. Which theory is this?
Question 4 of 5
A 1987 report for the United Church of Christ studied hazardous waste sites in the US. What did it find?
Question 5 of 5
A city cleans up a polluted riverfront, rents rise and many long-time low-income residents move away. What does this illustrate?
