Sociology › Section U · Social movements and change › Topic U.1
Collective behavior
A crowd surges towards a stage, a rumour races through a school, a dance challenge spreads across the world in a week. Sociologists ask why people sometimes act together outside the usual rules, and whether crowds are as irrational as they look.
What counts as collective behaviour
Collective behaviour is relatively spontaneous, unstructured activity in which a number of people take part voluntarily, outside the routines set by institutions. A lecture follows established rules; a buying frenzy for a new toy or a rumour sweeping a town does not. Collective behaviour is usually short-lived, and its norms are vague or form on the spot. It matters because it can be the first stirrings of something larger: an angry crowd can become a protest, and a protest can grow into an organised social movement, the subject of the topic "Social movements".
Crowds, masses and publics
Sociologists distinguish three forms. A crowd is a fairly large number of people gathered in one place, close enough to influence one another. A mass is a large number of people who share an interest but are scattered, such as the millions following the same streaming series or playing the same online game. A public is a dispersed, unorganised group of people who share ideas about an issue, such as everyone who holds an opinion on a proposed new motorway. In short: a mass shares interests, a public shares ideas, and only a crowd shares physical space.
Four types of crowd
Herbert Blumer proposed a widely used typology of crowds. A casual crowd is people sharing a space while barely interacting, such as shoppers pausing to watch a street performer. A conventional crowd gathers for a scheduled event and follows its norms, such as an audience at a concert or a congregation at worship. An expressive crowd gathers mainly to release emotion, as at a victory parade or a vigil after a tragedy. An acting crowd is focused on a goal and takes action to reach it, such as protesters marching on a city hall or, at the extreme, a rioting mob. A crowd can shift between types as events unfold.
Rumours, fads and panics
Not all collective behaviour involves people in one place. A rumour is unverified information passed from person to person, and it spreads fastest when a situation is uncertain and important to people; social media has made rumours travel further and faster. A fad is a short-lived enthusiasm, such as a viral dance or a craze for a toy, while a fashion changes more slowly and lasts longer. A moral panic, a term from Stanley Cohen's Folk Devils and Moral Panics (1972), is an exaggerated public fear that a group threatens society's values, often amplified by the media. A flash mob is a planned gathering staged to look spontaneous.
Early views: contagion and convergence
Early theorists saw crowds as irrational. In The Crowd (1895) the French writer Gustave Le Bon argued that anonymity in a crowd lets a collective mind take over, so that emotion spreads like a contagion and individuals lose their judgement. This is called contagion theory. Convergence theory, associated with the psychologist Floyd Allport, reversed the direction: crowds do not change people, but like-minded people converge in the same place, so a crowd reflects what its members already wanted. Research on real crowds has undermined Le Bon's picture. Most crowd members stay in small groups of friends or family, keep their own judgement and act for understandable reasons.
Emergent norm theory
Ralph Turner and Lewis Killian developed emergent norm theory from the 1950s. They argued that people in a crowd are neither mindless nor all alike. When a situation is new or confusing, people interact, often in small clusters, and work out new norms for how to behave; those norms then guide the crowd. Disaster research supports this: studies of evacuations and emergencies, building on work by Enrico Quarantelli, find that true panic is rare and that people usually help one another. Critics say the theory does not fully explain how one norm wins out and spreads.
Value-added theory
Neil Smelser's Theory of Collective Behavior (1962), a functionalist account, proposed six determinants, each adding to the likelihood of collective behaviour. Structural conduciveness: the social setting makes it possible, for example people can gather and communicate. Structural strain: a gap between expectations and reality creates tension. A generalised belief: people identify the problem and its cause. A precipitating factor: a dramatic event sparks action. Mobilisation for action: people are drawn in and leaders direct them. Finally, the operation of social control: police, officials or the media can prevent, redirect or end the episode, or intensify it if handled badly. Critics argue the model is easier to apply after the fact than to predict.
The assembling perspective
Clark McPhail, in The Myth of the Madding Crowd (1991), argued that the very idea of a uniform, irrational crowd was a myth. He preferred the term gathering and treated people in them as rational individuals coordinating their actions. He studied what people actually do together: arriving in companion clusters, facing the same way, chanting, singing or moving in step. He also studied the life cycle of a gathering, from assembling to dispersing. Critics note that this close focus on observable actions can neglect the wider cultural and political context that gives a gathering its meaning.
Worked example: applying value-added theory
In a fictional town, a factory closes without warning, and 900 workers learn of it from a sign on the gate. Apply Smelser. 1. Conduciveness: workers share a car park and a social media group, so they can gather and communicate. 2. Strain: they expected notice and severance pay, and got neither. 3. Generalised belief: workers come to blame the owners for moving production abroad. 4. Precipitating factor: a video shows managers removing machinery at night. 5. Mobilisation: a union steward calls a rally at the gate, and hundreds come. 6. Social control: police keep the gate road open; a calm response lets the rally end peacefully, while a heavy-handed one might escalate it.
Worked example: a crowd in a blackout
During a citywide power cut, a concert crowd of 20,000 is plunged into darkness. Analyse it. 1. Type of crowd: before the cut it was a conventional crowd, gathered for a scheduled event. 2. New situation: the usual norms no longer fit, which is when emergent norm theory predicts new norms will form. 3. Observed norm: people switch on phone torches, link arms and shuffle towards the exits, while staff and volunteers direct them. 4. Compare with contagion theory: it predicts blind panic, but small groups of friends coordinate calmly, as McPhail would expect. 5. Conclude: the evidence supports emergent norm and assembling views over Le Bon's.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up a mass and a public: a mass shares interests, a public shares ideas, and neither need be in one place. Second, assuming crowds are naturally irrational: research finds most crowd members stay rational and in small groups. Third, treating the last of Smelser's determinants as something that always ends an episode: social control can also inflame it. Fourth, calling every gathering a social movement: collective behaviour is short-lived and loosely organised. Fifth, confusing a fad, which is brief, with a fashion, which changes more slowly.
Key takeaways
Collective behaviour is relatively spontaneous, noninstitutionalised group activity. Its forms include crowds, masses and publics; Blumer's crowd types are casual, conventional, expressive and acting. Rumours, fads, fashions and moral panics (Cohen, 1972) spread without physical gathering. Le Bon's contagion theory saw crowds as irrational; convergence theory says like-minded people gather; emergent norm theory (Turner and Killian) says crowds create norms; Smelser's value-added theory (1962) lists six determinants; McPhail's assembling perspective (1991) studies rational gatherings.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Relatively spontaneous, unstructured group activity outside institutional routines
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Millions of people around the country watch the same streaming series but never meet. In sociological terms they form a:
Question 2 of 5
Mourners gather in a town square to light candles after a tragedy. Which type of crowd is this?
Question 3 of 5
Which theory holds that, in an unfamiliar situation, people in a crowd develop new norms that then guide their behaviour?
Question 4 of 5
In Smelser's value-added theory, a video of managers removing machinery at night that sparks a rally is an example of:
Question 5 of 5
What does research on emergencies, such as evacuations, generally find about crowd behaviour?
