Sociology › Section H · Media and technology › Topic H.3

Global implications of media and technology

A video posted in Seoul can be watched in São Paulo within seconds, yet billions of people are still offline. This topic asks what happens when media and technology cross borders: who gains, who controls the flow, and who is left out.

A flatter world?

Technology has long driven globalisation, from shipping routes to undersea cables. In The World Is Flat (2005), the journalist Thomas Friedman argued that personal computers, cheap high-speed internet and new software had levelled the global playing field. A firm in Ohio could hire a call centre in Bangalore, India, as easily as one down the road, and workers anywhere could compete for the same jobs. Friedman warned that wealthy countries would have to prepare their workers for this competition. His argument was influential, but it came from economics and business journalism rather than sociology, and critics soon challenged it.

Critics: a spiky world

The urban theorist Richard Florida replied in 2005 that the world is spiky, not flat: innovation, wealth and talent still cluster in a few city regions, such as Silicon Valley, Tokyo or Shanghai, while large areas are left behind. Inequality within countries makes the same point. China's booming coastal cities stand far apart from its poorest rural provinces. Sociologists therefore separate two processes. Media globalisation is the worldwide spread and integration of media content and the cross-cultural exchange of ideas. Technological globalisation is the cross-border development and exchange of technology. Both can widen gaps as well as close them.

Media consolidation

Multinational corporations are major vehicles of media globalisation. Media consolidation is the concentration of ownership, as a shrinking number of companies comes to own a growing share of outlets, producing an oligopoly, a market dominated by a few firms. The journalist Ben Bagdikian argued in The Media Monopoly (1983) that about 50 corporations controlled most US media, and later editions put the number far lower. Critics say consolidated media answer to shareholders more than to the public, narrow the range of viewpoints and have little incentive to innovate. Defenders reply that the internet has added countless independent voices, though a handful of platforms now control much of the attention those voices compete for.

Global village or cultural imperialism?

In the 1960s Marshall McLuhan predicted that electronic media would turn the world into a global village, in which distant events feel close and shared. Critics see a less equal picture: access to the global conversation is weighted towards wealthier, English-speaking users, and media from powerful countries can crowd out local languages and traditions, a concern called cultural imperialism. Others note that cultural flows now run in many directions. South Korean pop music and drama, Indian films and Nigeria's prolific film industry, often called Nollywood, all reach huge international audiences, so globalisation also spreads non-Western culture.

Censorship and control

Global media also prompt governments to control what citizens see. China's system of internet controls, often called the Great Firewall, blocks services such as Google, Facebook and YouTube, so Chinese users rely on domestic platforms that are closely monitored. Users are required to register with their real names, and criticism of the government can be punished. After Myanmar's military seized power in February 2021 and detained the civilian leader Aung San Suu Kyi, it blocked Facebook, Twitter and other platforms to hinder protests. Many governments now order temporary internet shutdowns during unrest or elections. Openness also has costs: offshore websites let people evade national laws on gambling and other activities.

Worked example: was it a Twitter revolution?

During the 2011 uprisings across the Arab world, protesters in Cairo's Tahrir Square posted updates that the world followed live, and some commentators called it a Twitter revolution. Test the claim. 1. Evidence for a role: social media spread news, helped organise gatherings and drew foreign attention. 2. Evidence against a sole cause: only a minority of Egyptians used Twitter, and protests grew even after the government cut internet access in late January. 3. Deeper causes: unemployment, rising prices and long-standing anger at repression fuelled the protests. 4. Conclusion: media technology acted as an accelerant and amplifier, not the root cause, which is how many scholars now describe it.

Technological diffusion and global divides

Technological diffusion is the movement of technology from the countries that develop it to others. It has been rapid: the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) estimated that about 6 billion people, roughly three-quarters of the world, used the internet in 2025. But about 2.2 billion remained offline, nearly all in low- and middle-income countries. The ITU found 94% of people online in high-income countries against 23% in low-income countries, 85% in urban areas against 58% in rural ones, and 77% of men against 71% of women. The same patterns that create a digital divide inside the United States reappear within and between countries, so those who could gain most from technology are often the last to get it.

Worked example: reading the ITU figures

Use the ITU's 2025 estimates. 1. Income gap: 94% − 23% = 71 percentage points between high- and low-income countries. 2. Turn it round: in low-income countries about 77 of every 100 people are offline, compared with about 6 of every 100 in high-income countries. 3. Urban-rural gap: 85% − 58% = 27 points. 4. Gender gap: 77% − 71% = 6 points, smaller but still meaning millions more women than men offline worldwide. 5. Interpret: the largest gap is between countries by income, so a conflict theorist would stress global inequality, while a functionalist might note that the online share keeps rising each year.

Mobile phones and development

In much of sub-Saharan Africa, many people skipped landlines and went straight to mobile phones, a pattern called leapfrogging. Phones let farmers and traders check prices before travelling to market; a widely cited study of fishermen in Kerala, India, found that mobile phones reduced price swings and waste. Mobile money has had large effects: M-Pesa, launched in Kenya in 2007, lets users send and store money by text message without a bank account. Shared village phone schemes extended access further. Critics caution that many projects are run by companies seeking new markets, and that phones cannot replace roads, electricity and schools.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming technology spreads evenly once it exists: diffusion follows existing inequalities. Second, equating more outlets with more owners: consolidation means many outlets can share a few owners. Third, treating cultural flows as one-way: Korean, Indian and Nigerian media reach global audiences. Fourth, crediting social media alone with political revolutions: they amplify movements rooted in deeper grievances. Fifth, calling Friedman's thesis settled: critics argue the world remains spiky, with wealth concentrated in a few places.

Key takeaways

Technology drives globalisation; Friedman's flat-world thesis is countered by evidence that activity clusters in a spiky pattern. Media globalisation spreads content and ideas, while technological globalisation spreads tools. Media consolidation creates oligopolies, though the internet adds new voices. The global village has unequal entry, and cultural imperialism is balanced by flows from many regions. Governments such as China's and Myanmar's restrict online media. In 2025 about 6 billion people were online and 2.2 billion offline, with the widest gaps by country income. Mobile phones and mobile money show both the promise and the limits of diffusion.

Flashcards

Flashcard

The World Is Flat

Friedman's 2005 claim that technology levelled global economic competition

Bangalore call centres.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which observation best supports critics who say the world is spiky rather than flat?

Question 2 of 5

A country has hundreds of newspapers, TV channels and radio stations, but four companies own most of them. This illustrates:

Question 3 of 5

In 2025 the ITU estimated internet use at 94% in high-income countries and 23% in low-income countries. About how many of every 100 people in low-income countries were offline?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement best reflects how many scholars now judge the role of social media in the 2011 Arab uprisings?

Question 5 of 5

A farmer in Kenya receives payment for crops by text message without having a bank account. This is an example of:

← Previous topicNext topic →