Sociology › Section H · Media and technology › Topic H.4

Theoretical perspectives on media and technology

Are media and technology engines of progress, tools of the powerful, or mirrors in which we build our identities? Each sociological perspective gives a different answer, and together they explain far more than any one alone.

One subject, several lenses

Media and technology range from a match to a nuclear power station, and from a bus advertisement to a global video platform. No single theory explains all of it, so sociologists apply the perspectives introduced in Theoretical perspectives in sociology. Functionalists ask what media and technology do to keep society running. Conflict theorists ask who controls them and who benefits. Feminist theorists examine how they portray and position women and men. Symbolic interactionists ask what they mean to people and how they shape shared views of reality.

Functionalism: commerce and entertainment

Functionalists start by listing the functions media perform. One is commercial: advertising pays for much of what we watch and read, and it lets firms reach precisely the audiences they want, using detailed data on viewers and users. Advertising appears on screens, buses, sports grounds and in schools, although US rules introduced in 2014 restricted the sale of junk food and sugary drinks in schools. A second, manifest function is entertainment. Asked why they stream a series or play an online game, most people simply say they enjoy it, and the vast amount of time spent on screens shows how central that function is.

Socialisation, latent functions and dysfunctions

Media also socialise us throughout life, teaching what is desirable, how to speak and dress, and how to react to events. They provide shared moments of national significance, such as the September 11 attacks in 2001, that people remember watching together. How strong this influence is compared with family, peers and schools remains debated. Technology changes lives in intended ways, such as video calls with distant relatives, and in latent ways: some studies link heavy screen use to less physical activity. Paul Lazarsfeld and Robert Merton (1948) described a narcotising dysfunction: people flooded with information may mistake knowing about an issue for doing something about it.

Conflict theory: who controls the gates?

Conflict theorists focus on unequal access, as in the digital divide, and on control. Gatekeeping, as Pamela Shoemaker and Tim Vos (2009) define it, is the process by which countless possible messages are cut down and shaped into the few that reach the public. Those who control the gates, owners, editors and executives, decide what audiences see. Hegemonic media are media through which one dominant group's worldview comes to seem normal and natural to everyone. New media weakened traditional gatekeepers, because anyone can publish. Critics add that platform algorithms, designed by a few large companies, have become powerful new gatekeepers.

Money, media and politics

Conflict theorists also stress that wealthy interests can buy far more election airtime and online reach than others. In Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (2010), the Supreme Court ruled that corporations and unions may spend unlimited sums on independent political advertising, including ads that openly support or oppose candidates, as long as they do not coordinate with campaigns. A lower-court ruling the same year cleared the way for super PACs, which can raise and spend unlimited money. Super PACs must disclose their donors, but funds routed through some nonprofit groups need not be, which critics call dark money. Supporters of the ruling see such spending as protected free speech.

Surveillance and social control

In the late eighteenth century Jeremy Bentham designed the panopticon, a prison in which a guard in a central tower could watch every cell while prisoners could never tell whether they were being watched. Michel Foucault, in Discipline and Punish (1975), argued that modern societies work in a similar way: people who might be observed at any time come to police themselves. George Orwell's novel Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949) imagined an all-seeing state. Today security cameras, phone location data and facial-recognition software make such monitoring practical, and Shoshana Zuboff (2019) popularised the term surveillance capitalism for companies' collection of personal data to predict and shape behaviour for profit.

Worked example: facial recognition in a city

A city installs facial-recognition cameras in its transport system. 1. Functionalist reading: the system may help find missing people and deter crime, contributing to order. 2. Conflict reading: the city and its contractor gain power over residents, and studies by the US National Institute of Standards and Technology have found higher error rates for some demographic groups in many algorithms, so wrongful stops may fall unequally. 3. Foucault's insight: commuters who know they might be identified may change how they dress, meet or protest, even if no one is watching. 4. Interactionist angle: for some the cameras symbolise safety, for others oppression. 5. Conclusion: the same technology can serve order and control at once.

Feminist perspectives

Feminist theorists note that women in advertising, television and games are often shown within narrow limits: young, thin, conventionally attractive and frequently light-skinned. They argue such images reinforce stereotypes; in one experiment, Jesse Fox and Jeremy Bailenson (2009) found that exposure to stereotyped female avatars increased acceptance of negative attitudes towards women. Women remain under-represented in computing and engineering careers. In 1990 Ms. magazine relaunched without advertising to escape advertisers' pressure. Cyberfeminism is the use and promotion of feminism online. New media offer women platforms and control over their own image, as many influencers show, but also expose them to harassment.

Symbolic interactionism

Interactionists see technology itself as a symbol. The phone, car or laptop someone owns can signal wealth and status, or a lack of it. Neo-Luddites regard technology as embodying the cold, alienating side of modern life, while technophiles treat it as the promise of a better future. Media also help in the social construction of reality, the process, described by Peter Berger and Thomas Luckmann (1966), by which people create shared understandings of the world. Characters on screen can become a reference group, against which viewers judge their own lives, and some viewers form parasocial relationships, one-sided feelings of closeness to celebrities or streamers.

Worked example: one smartphone, four lenses

Analyse a teenager's new smartphone. 1. Functionalist: it keeps her in touch with family, helps with homework and entertains her, all manifest functions; a latent effect may be less sleep. 2. Conflict: the manufacturer and app companies profit from her attention and data, and classmates who cannot afford a phone fall behind. 3. Feminist: the beauty filters and influencer content she sees may narrow her sense of how a girl should look, yet she can also post her own content. 4. Interactionist: the phone signals status among peers, and the lives she follows online become a reference group. 5. Check: each lens asks a different question, and together they show benefits and costs.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming functionalists think media have only good effects: narcotising dysfunction is a functionalist idea. Second, thinking new media ended gatekeeping: algorithms and platform rules are new gates. Third, misreading Citizens United: it allowed unlimited independent spending, including ads that openly back candidates, though not coordination with campaigns. Fourth, confusing the panopticon with simple observation: its point is that people discipline themselves when they might be watched. Fifth, treating a reference group as people you know personally: it can be anyone you compare yourself with, including people on screen.

Key takeaways

Functionalists highlight commercial, entertainment and socialising functions, latent effects and the narcotising dysfunction (Lazarsfeld and Merton). Conflict theorists study the digital divide, gatekeeping, hegemonic media, money in political media after Citizens United, and surveillance, drawing on Bentham's panopticon, Foucault and Zuboff's surveillance capitalism. Feminist theorists examine narrow portrayals of women, the gender gap in technology and cyberfeminism. Interactionists see technology as a status symbol and media as builders of shared reality and reference groups. Most sociologists combine the lenses.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Commercial function

Media let advertisers reach targeted audiences and fund content

A functionalist view.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

After weeks of news and posts about a famine, many people feel well informed and share links, but few donate or act. Which concept fits?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement about Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (2010) is accurate?

Question 3 of 5

Employees who know their keystrokes might be monitored at any moment start working harder even when no one checks. This best illustrates:

Question 4 of 5

A conflict theorist studying a video platform would most likely ask:

Question 5 of 5

A student judges her own appearance and lifestyle against influencers she follows but has never met. For her, the influencers act as a:

← Previous topicNext topic →