Sociology › Section I · Social stratification › Topic I.3

Global stratification and inequality

A low-paid worker in Ohio and a low-paid worker in Bangladesh may both be near the bottom of their own societies, yet their lives are worlds apart. Global stratification asks how countries, and the people in them, are ranked across the whole planet.

Stratification across borders

The previous topics ranked people within one society. Global stratification is the unequal distribution of wealth, power, prestige and economic security among the world's countries. It has two dimensions. Between-country inequality compares nations with one another, for example average income in Norway against average income in Niger. Within-country inequality compares people inside each nation. A full picture of global inequality among individuals needs both, because a rich person in a poor country may be far better off than a poor person in a rich one. Sociologists ask how these rankings formed, how they are measured and how they shape the life chances of the people born into them.

How the gap opened

For most of history the gaps between the richest and poorest regions were modest by today's standards, because nearly everyone lived by farming. That changed after about 1800. Industrialisation, beginning in Britain and spreading to western Europe and North America, multiplied output in some places but not others, a split often called the Great Divergence, a phrase popularised by the historian Kenneth Pomeranz. Many scholars argue that colonial rule widened the gap by organising colonies to export raw materials and buy manufactured goods. By the twentieth century the world was sharply divided between industrialised and largely agricultural economies, and much of that division remains.

Measuring national income

Comparisons usually start with national income. Gross domestic product (GDP) is the market value of all final goods and services produced within a country's borders in a year. Gross national income (GNI) adds income that residents earn abroad and subtracts income paid to foreigners; the older name for a similar measure is gross national product (GNP). Totals mostly reflect size, so researchers divide by population to get GDP or GNI per capita, the average income per person. An average says nothing about how income is shared, so a country with a high average can still contain deep poverty.

Exchange rates and purchasing power

To compare countries, incomes must be put in one currency, usually US dollars. Using market exchange rates understates living standards in poorer countries, where many local goods and services, such as haircuts, rent and street food, are cheap. Purchasing power parity (PPP) corrects for this by converting with a rate that equalises the cost of a common basket of goods and services. A PPP dollar buys in each country what one dollar buys in the United States. Gaps between rich and poor countries are therefore smaller in PPP terms than at market rates, but they remain very large.

Worked example: market rates and PPP

A hypothetical country has GNI per capita of 300,000 pesos. The market exchange rate is 100 pesos per dollar, but a basket that costs $1 in the United States costs only 40 pesos there. 1. At the market rate: \(300{,}000 \div 100 = \$3{,}000\) per person. 2. At PPP: \(300{,}000 \div 40 = \$7{,}500\) per person. 3. Compare with a rich country on $60,000 per person: the ratio is 20 to 1 at market rates but 8 to 1 at PPP. 4. Interpret: local prices are lower, so each peso buys more than the exchange rate suggests. 5. Check: the PPP figure is larger whenever local prices are below US prices, which is typical of poorer countries.

Early models of global ranking

Older textbooks sort the world into the first, second and third worlds, or into more developed and less developed countries. These labels were convenient but crude: "third world" lumped together countries as different as oil-rich states and the poorest farming economies, and "less developed" implied that every country should copy the industrial West. Today researchers prefer income-based groups and models of a world economy with a core and a periphery. The next section of this course, beginning with "Global stratification and classification", examines these systems in detail, including the World Bank's income groups and Immanuel Wallerstein's world-systems approach.

Inequality among the world's people

Treating the world as one population gives a striking picture. The World Inequality Report 2022, by Lucas Chancel, Thomas Piketty and colleagues, estimated that the richest 10% of people received about 52% of global income while the poorest half received about 8.5%; for wealth the figures were about 76% and 2%. The same report found that over recent decades the gap between the top 10% and bottom 50% within countries had widened from about 8.5 to 15 times, so that inequality within countries now exceeds inequality between them. Estimates of this kind rest on patchy data for many countries and carry wide margins of error.

The elephant curve

The economists Christoph Lakner and Branko Milanovic ranked the world's people from poorest to richest and asked how each group's real income changed between 1988 and 2008. The resulting graph resembles an elephant. Its back is a large hump: people around the middle of the global distribution, many of them in China and other Asian economies, saw the biggest gains. The trunk rises again at the far right, where the global top 1% also gained strongly. In between, the dip near the trunk shows weak growth for people around the 80th percentile, many of them working- and lower-middle-class people in rich countries. Later studies with newer data suggest the shape has changed since 2008.

Worked example: between and within

Two hypothetical countries start with average incomes of $2,000 (country P) and $40,000 (country R). Over ten years P grows 8% a year and R grows 2% a year. 1. P's new average: \(2{,}000 \times 1.08^{10} \approx \$4{,}320\). 2. R's new average: \(40{,}000 \times 1.02^{10} \approx \$48{,}760\). 3. The ratio falls from \(40{,}000 \div 2{,}000 = 20\) to \(48{,}760 \div 4{,}320 \approx 11.3\): between-country inequality narrows. 4. Suppose that in P the richest tenth's share of income rises from 30% to 40%: within-country inequality widens. 5. Interpret: both trends can happen at once, a simple version of what happened as China and India grew.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming global stratification is only about countries: it has between-country and within-country dimensions. Second, comparing living standards at market exchange rates without noting that PPP figures are higher for poorer countries. Third, reading a high income per capita as proof that everyone in a country is comfortable: an average hides distribution. Fourth, confusing GDP, produced within borders, with GNI, earned by residents. Fifth, treating the elephant curve as permanent: it describes 1988 to 2008, and newer data tell a somewhat different story.

Key takeaways

Global stratification ranks countries, and people across countries, by wealth, power, prestige and security, both between and within nations. The gap widened sharply with industrialisation after about 1800, the Great Divergence. GDP measures output within borders, GNI income earned by residents; per capita figures divide by population, and PPP adjusts for local prices. In the WIR 2022 estimates, the richest 10% received about 52% of global income and the poorest half about 8.5%. The elephant curve showed big gains for the global middle and top 1% from 1988 to 2008.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Global stratification

Unequal distribution of wealth, power, prestige and security among countries

Between and within nations.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A country's GNI per capita is 500,000 rupees. The market rate is 100 rupees per dollar, and a basket costing $1 in the US costs 25 rupees there. What is GNI per capita at PPP?

Question 2 of 5

Why are income gaps between rich and poor countries smaller in PPP terms than at market exchange rates?

Question 3 of 5

What did the elephant curve of Lakner and Milanovic show for 1988 to 2008?

Question 4 of 5

Poor country P grows much faster than rich country R, while the richest tenth of P takes a larger share of P's income. What happens?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement correctly distinguishes GDP from GNI?

← Previous topicNext topic →