Sociology › Section I · Social stratification › Topic I.4
Theoretical perspectives on stratification
Is inequality the price a society pays for getting its hardest jobs done, a system the powerful build to protect themselves, or something people act out every day in what they wear and buy? Each of sociology's main perspectives gives a different answer.
One fact, several explanations
Every society ranks people, but why? The earlier topic "Theoretical perspectives in sociology" introduced three lenses: structural functionalism, conflict theory and symbolic interactionism. Applied to stratification, they ask different questions. Functionalists ask what purpose unequal rewards might serve for society as a whole. Conflict theorists ask who benefits from inequality and how they keep their advantage. Symbolic interactionists ask how people display, read and respond to class in everyday life. Each highlights some evidence and plays down other evidence, so sociologists test them against data rather than choosing one by loyalty.
The Davis-Moore thesis
In 1945 the American sociologists Kingsley Davis and Wilbert Moore offered the best-known functionalist account. They argued that every society must fill some positions that are especially important and that require scarce talent or long, costly training. To persuade capable people to make those sacrifices, societies attach greater rewards to such positions, in income, prestige and comfort. Stratification, on this view, is a device that matches the most capable people to the most important jobs. The thesis predicts that rewards should rise with a position's functional importance and with the scarcity of people able to fill it.
Worked example: testing Davis and Moore
Apply the thesis to three hypothetical jobs. 1. A surgeon trains for about 13 years after high school and holds lives in their hands: high importance, scarce skill. The thesis predicts high pay, and surgeons are indeed among the best-paid workers. 2. A professional basketball star has rare skill but arguably modest importance to society's survival; the thesis struggles to explain pay many times a surgeon's. 3. A childcare worker does work that is vital to the next generation, yet is among the lower-paid workers in the United States. 4. Evaluate: case 1 fits, cases 2 and 3 do not, which suggests that market demand, bargaining power and cultural values, not just importance, shape rewards.
Tumin's critique
In 1953 Melvin Tumin published a sharp reply. First, functional importance is hard to measure: is a factory engineer more important than the workers without whom nothing is built? Second, stratification limits the discovery of talent, because children from poor families rarely get the education needed to show their abilities. Third, the rewards attached to positions often reflect inheritance and the power of those who hold them, not their contribution. Fourth, inequality can be dysfunctional, breeding resentment, distrust and conflict among those at the bottom. Supporters of Davis and Moore replied that Tumin attacked unequal opportunity, not the basic idea that rewards attract people to demanding roles.
Marx: class and the means of production
Conflict theories of stratification begin with Karl Marx, who, writing as factories spread in the nineteenth century, defined class by relationship to the means of production: land, machinery and factories. The bourgeoisie, or capitalists, own them; the proletariat, the working class, owns only its labour, which it must sell for wages. Marx argued that profit comes from paying workers less than the value they create, so the two classes have opposed interests. He described workers as alienated from their work and its products. He expected that once workers developed class consciousness, an awareness of their shared interests, they would overthrow capitalism, a prediction that has not come true in the richest capitalist countries.
Weber: class, status and party
Max Weber, writing in the early twentieth century, accepted that economic position matters but argued that stratification has three distinct dimensions. Class is a person's economic situation in the market, which shapes their life chances, the likelihood of good health, education and income. Status is social honour or prestige, often tied to a lifestyle shared by a status group. Party refers to power exercised through organisations such as political parties, unions and lobbies. These can diverge: a respected religious leader may have high status but little money, while a newly rich criminal may have money but little honour. Weber's view underlies the modern idea of socioeconomic status.
Worked example: three dimensions
Rank three hypothetical people high, medium or low on Weber's dimensions. 1. A small-town pastor: class low to medium, status high in the community, party medium through church networks. 2. A lottery winner who left a warehouse job: class high, status medium at best, party low. 3. A long-serving state senator from a modest background: class medium, status medium to high, party high. 4. Compare: no two profiles match, and none is uniformly high or low. 5. Interpret: ranking by property alone, as Marx did, would miss these differences, which is Weber's point. 6. Link: mixed profiles like these show low status consistency.
Symbolic interactionism: class in daily life
Symbolic interactionists work at the micro level, studying how class shapes and is shaped by everyday interaction. People tend to live, work, socialise and marry among others of similar standing, so class is reinforced through ordinary choices about neighbourhoods and friends. People also read class cues, such as accent, clothing, cars and vocabulary, and adjust how they treat one another. The economist and sociologist Thorstein Veblen, in The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899), coined the term conspicuous consumption for buying goods mainly to display status. A luxury car and an ordinary one both provide transport, but only one announces its owner's rank.
Worked example: one pay gap, three lenses
A hypothetical firm pays its chief executive $15 million and its median worker $50,000. 1. Ratio: \(15{,}000{,}000 \div 50{,}000 = 300\), so the executive earns 300 times as much. 2. Functionalist: does the pay attract scarce talent to a role whose decisions affect thousands of jobs? 3. Conflict: who sets executive pay, and does a board dominated by other executives and large shareholders reward itself at workers' expense? 4. Interactionist: how do workers interpret the gap, and how does the executive display rank through offices, cars and clubs? 5. Check: each lens poses a question evidence could answer; together they give a fuller picture.
Weighing the perspectives
Critics argue that functionalism can drift into justifying whatever inequality exists and cannot explain why similar jobs are paid very differently across countries. Conflict theory is said to underplay real mobility, the rise of a large middle class and the role rewards play in motivating effort; Marx's forecast of revolution in advanced capitalism did not come true. Symbolic interactionism is criticised for describing the display of class without explaining the structures that create it. Many sociologists today also stress intersectionality, a term the legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw coined in 1989, which holds that class combines with race and gender to shape people's positions.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Davis and Moore said every inequality is fair: their claim concerns rewards for important, hard-to-fill positions. Second, defining Marx's classes by income: he defined them by ownership of the means of production. Third, treating Weber's three dimensions as always moving together: his point is that they can diverge. Fourth, crediting conspicuous consumption to Marx or Weber: Veblen coined it in 1899. Fifth, assuming one perspective must win: each answers a different question, and evidence can favour different lenses for different cases.
Key takeaways
The Davis-Moore thesis (1945) holds that unequal rewards attract scarce talent to important positions; Tumin (1953) replied that importance is hard to measure, inequality hides talent, and rewards often reflect power and inheritance. Marx defined class by ownership of the means of production and saw class conflict at the heart of capitalism. Weber distinguished class, status and party, which can diverge. Symbolic interactionists study class in daily life, including Veblen's conspicuous consumption. Each perspective has critics, and many sociologists combine them.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Greater rewards attract scarce talent to functionally important positions
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
According to the Davis-Moore thesis, why do some positions receive greater rewards?
Question 2 of 5
Which point was part of Melvin Tumin's 1953 critique of Davis and Moore?
Question 3 of 5
For Karl Marx, what determines a person's class?
Question 4 of 5
A respected religious leader has little money but great social honour. Which idea best explains this?
Question 5 of 5
A shopper buys an expensive designer bag mainly so that others will notice her rank. A symbolic interactionist would call this:
