Sociology › Section K · Race and ethnicity › Topic K.4
Intergroup relationships
When groups share a territory, they can live side by side as equals, merge, be pushed apart, be driven out or, at the very worst, be destroyed. Sociologists arrange these patterns on a spectrum and measure how far real societies sit along it.
A spectrum of relations
Intergroup relations are the patterns of contact between racial, ethnic or religious groups within a society. Sociologists often arrange them from the most accepting to the most destructive: pluralism, assimilation and amalgamation, then segregation, expulsion and genocide. The spectrum is a tool, not a timeline: a country can treat different groups in different ways at once. The psychology topic Prejudice and discrimination explains what reduces hostility between groups at the individual level, such as equal-status contact; this topic looks at whole societies and the policies that shape them.
Pluralism
Pluralism, or cultural pluralism, is an arrangement in which groups keep distinct identities while holding equal standing and sharing common institutions. Its image is the salad bowl: each ingredient stays recognisable yet adds to the whole. Switzerland, with four national languages, German, French, Italian and Romansh, is often cited as an example, because language communities have strong local self-government within one state. Pluralism needs mutual respect and protection of minority rights, and true equality is hard to achieve. Policies of multiculturalism, such as Canada's from 1971, aim at a pluralist ideal, though critics argue such policies can harden group boundaries.
Assimilation
Assimilation is the process by which a minority group takes on the culture of the dominant group and becomes less distinct. In the 1920s Robert Park of the Chicago School described a race relations cycle of contact, competition, accommodation and, eventually, assimilation. Milton Gordon (1964) separated several dimensions, among them cultural assimilation, adopting language and customs; structural assimilation, entering the dominant group's schools, jobs and social circles; and marital assimilation, widespread intermarriage. Assimilation usually changes the minority much more than the majority, and discrimination can block it, especially structural assimilation.
Segmented assimilation
Park's cycle implied one straight path into the mainstream. Alejandro Portes and Min Zhou (1993) argued instead for segmented assimilation: the children of immigrants may follow different paths depending on their parents' resources, the reception their group receives and the neighbourhoods they grow up in. Some move into the middle class; some keep strong ethnic ties that help them succeed; others face discrimination and poor schools and experience downward mobility. Richard Alba and Victor Nee (2003) replied that the mainstream itself changes as groups join it, so assimilation remains the most common outcome over generations. The debate continues, with evidence on both sides.
Amalgamation
Amalgamation is the blending of groups into a new culture and population, the melting pot popularised by Israel Zangwill's 1908 play of that name. Unlike assimilation, it changes everyone involved. In the United States its biological form, intermarriage, was long blocked by antimiscegenation laws, which banned marriage across racial lines in many states until the Supreme Court struck them down in Loving v. Virginia (1967). Intermarriage has risen steadily since; the Pew Research Center reported that about one in six newlyweds in 2015 had a spouse of a different race or ethnicity. Many observers note, though, that the American melting pot often meant assimilation into an Anglo-Protestant culture.
Segregation
Segregation is the physical and social separation of groups, in housing, schools, work and public places. De jure segregation is required by law. In the US South, Jim Crow laws were upheld by Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) until Brown v. Board of Education (1954) declared segregated public schools unconstitutional; South African apartheid lasted from 1948 to the early 1990s. De facto segregation arises without such laws, through housing markets, past lending practices, income gaps and personal choices. It can persist long after legal segregation ends, which is why many US neighbourhoods and schools remain highly segregated today.
Worked example: measuring segregation
The index of dissimilarity, \(D\), measures how unevenly two groups are spread across neighbourhoods:
A town has 1,000 Black and 3,000 white residents in three districts. 1. District shares of Black residents: 700, 200 and 100, or 0.70, 0.20 and 0.10. 2. Shares of white residents: 300, 1,200 and 1,500, or 0.10, 0.40 and 0.50. 3. Differences: 0.60, 0.20 and 0.40, summing to 1.20. 4. Halve and scale: \(D = 60\). 5. Interpret: 60% of either group would have to move for every district to match the town's overall mix. Values of 60 or more are usually read as high segregation.
Expulsion
Expulsion is the forced removal of a group from a territory by the dominant group. The Indian Removal Act of 1830 led to the forced relocation of the Cherokee, Choctaw, Creek and other nations west of the Mississippi; thousands of Cherokee died on the Trail of Tears in 1838 and 1839. In 1942, after the attack on Pearl Harbor, Executive Order 9066 led to the forced removal and incarceration of about 120,000 people of Japanese ancestry, about two-thirds of them US citizens, with no evidence of disloyalty. Many historians now prefer "incarceration" to "internment" for this. The Civil Liberties Act of 1988 apologised and paid $20,000 to each surviving person.
Genocide
Raphael Lemkin coined the word genocide in 1944. The 1948 UN Genocide Convention defines it as acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, including killing members, causing serious harm and forcibly transferring children. Intent is central. In the Holocaust, Nazi Germany murdered about six million Jews, as well as Roma, disabled people and others. In Rwanda in 1994, an estimated 500,000 to 800,000 or more people, mostly Tutsi, were killed in about 100 days. Historians debate how far the destruction of Native nations in North America fits the legal definition; many argue that episodes such as the killings in 1850s California clearly do.
Worked example: placing cases on the spectrum
Place each case. 1. A city's schools stopped assigning pupils by race in the 1970s, but most still serve one racial group because of housing patterns: de facto segregation. 2. Third-generation Korean Americans speak only English, work in mainstream firms and often marry outside the group: cultural, structural and marital assimilation in Gordon's terms. 3. A government forces an ethnic minority across a border with no intent to kill, though many die on the journey: expulsion; it would become genocide only with intent to destroy the group. 4. A federation guarantees schooling in three languages and shares power between language regions: pluralism. 5. Check: each placement rested on a defining feature, such as law, culture, force or intent.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating assimilation and amalgamation as the same: assimilation changes the minority, amalgamation creates something new for everyone. Second, assuming segregation ended when segregation laws did: de facto segregation can last for generations. Third, calling any mass death genocide: the legal definition requires intent to destroy a group. Fourth, assuming that every immigrant group follows one path into the mainstream; segmented assimilation shows different outcomes. Fifth, reading the spectrum as a fixed sequence that every society passes through. Sixth, misreading the dissimilarity index: 60 means 60% would have to move, not that 60% of residents are from one group.
Key takeaways
Intergroup relations run from pluralism (distinct groups, equal standing) through assimilation (adopting the dominant culture) and amalgamation (a new blend) to segregation, expulsion and genocide. Park described a race relations cycle; Gordon (1964) split assimilation into cultural, structural and marital forms; Portes and Zhou (1993) proposed segmented assimilation. Segregation is de jure (Jim Crow until Brown, 1954; apartheid, 1948 to the early 1990s) or de facto, and the dissimilarity index measures it. The Indian Removal Act (1830) and Japanese American incarceration (1942) were expulsions. Genocide, defined in 1948, requires intent to destroy a group.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Patterns of contact between racial, ethnic or religious groups
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Over three generations, an immigrant family switches to English, enters mainstream jobs and marries outside the group, while the wider culture barely changes. This is best described as:
Question 2 of 5
A city's dissimilarity index for two groups is 70. What does this mean?
Question 3 of 5
What distinguishes genocide from other mass deaths under the 1948 UN Convention?
Question 4 of 5
Schools in a district were desegregated by law decades ago, but most remain largely one race because of housing patterns. This is:
Question 5 of 5
Portes and Zhou's theory of segmented assimilation argues that:
