Sociology › Section K · Race and ethnicity › Topic K.3
Prejudice, discrimination, and racism
Psychology asks how one person comes to hold a biased attitude. Sociology adds a harder question: how can unequal outcomes by race persist even when few people say they want them? The answer lies in how prejudice, discrimination and racism work through institutions as well as individuals.
From attitudes to structures
The psychology topic Prejudice and discrimination set out the basics: a stereotype is an oversimplified belief about a group, prejudice is an unjustified, usually negative attitude, and discrimination is unfair treatment, with implicit bias operating below awareness. Sociologists accept those definitions and widen the frame. They ask how attitudes and actions are shaped by norms, laws and organisations, and how rules can disadvantage a group with no hostile person involved. Racism, in the sociological sense, covers both levels: beliefs that one race is superior, and practices and structures that advantage one racial group over others. This topic follows that move from the individual to the institution.
Merton's four types
In 1949 Robert K. Merton pointed out that prejudice and discrimination do not always go together, and he crossed the two to produce four types. The unprejudiced non-discriminator holds no prejudice and does not discriminate. The unprejudiced discriminator holds no prejudice but discriminates when it is convenient or expected, for instance by following a biased company policy. The prejudiced non-discriminator holds prejudice but does not act on it, often because laws or social pressure forbid it. The prejudiced discriminator holds prejudice and acts on it. The typology shows why changing norms and laws matters: behaviour can change even before attitudes do, and good attitudes alone do not stop discrimination.
Individual and institutional discrimination
Individual discrimination is unfair treatment by a particular person: a landlord who will not rent to a family because of its race, or a shop guard who follows only certain customers. Institutional discrimination is built into the normal workings of organisations and laws. Stokely Carmichael and Charles Hamilton introduced the term institutional racism in Black Power (1967) to describe disadvantage that flows from established practices rather than individual acts. Examples include hiring through personal networks in a workforce that is already mostly white, or school funding tied to local property values in segregated areas. The rules may say nothing about race, yet the outcomes still divide along racial lines.
Forms of racism
Sociologists distinguish several forms. Interpersonal racism occurs between individuals, from slurs to biased decisions. Systemic or structural racism is inequality produced by the way institutions such as housing, schooling, policing and lending fit together. Racial profiling is treating people as suspects because of their race; the US Justice Department's 2015 report on Ferguson, Missouri, found that Black residents, about two-thirds of the population, made up about 85% of people stopped in traffic. Colourism is discrimination based on skin tone within or across racial groups, with lighter skin often favoured. Cultural racism is the assumption, built into a culture, that one group's ways are superior. Historical racism refers to present inequality caused by past discrimination.
Colour-blind racism
Eduardo Bonilla-Silva, in Racism without Racists (first edition 2003), argued that after the civil rights era open racism gave way to colour-blind racism: a way of talking that avoids racial language while explaining inequality as the result of markets, culture or individual choice. Phrases such as "I don't see race" or "it's just about where people want to live" can leave existing inequalities unexamined. Bonilla-Silva's account is influential but debated. Supporters of a colour-blind ideal, including many legal conservatives, argue that treating everyone identically regardless of race is the fairest principle; Bonilla-Silva replies that ignoring race in an unequal society tends to preserve the inequality.
Privilege and its critics
Privilege refers to unearned advantages that come from belonging to a dominant group. In a 1989 essay Peggy McIntosh listed everyday advantages she believed she had as a white woman, such as seeing her race widely represented in the media, and described privilege as invisible to those who hold it. Sociologists stress that privilege is a feature of social arrangements, not a verdict on any individual's character or effort. The concept is contested. Critics argue that it can overlook large differences in class and region among white people and can feel like collective blame; defenders reply that naming advantages is a precondition for seeing how inequality works.
Redlining and the wealth gap
Housing shows how past discrimination is carried forward. In the 1930s the federal Home Owners' Loan Corporation drew maps grading neighbourhoods by lending risk, often marking Black and immigrant areas in red, and federal mortgage insurance largely avoided such areas. Redlining, refusing loans in minority neighbourhoods, was banned by the Fair Housing Act of 1968, but homes are the main store of wealth for most families and wealth is passed between generations. Melvin Oliver and Thomas Shapiro (1995) called this the sedimentation of racial inequality. In the Federal Reserve's 2022 Survey of Consumer Finances, median wealth was about $285,000 for white families and about $44,900 for Black families, roughly six to one.
Worked example: applying Merton's types
Classify each person. 1. A restaurant manager privately dislikes Latino customers but serves them politely because the chain fires staff who discriminate: holds prejudice, does not act on it, so a prejudiced non-discriminator. 2. A recruiter holds no racial prejudice but, as instructed, only searches for candidates at three nearby universities whose students are overwhelmingly white: no prejudice, but the practice discriminates, so an unprejudiced discriminator, and an example of institutional discrimination. 3. A landlord who believes one group is untrustworthy and refuses to rent to its members: a prejudiced discriminator. 4. Check: in case 2 the harm came from a rule, not an attitude, which is exactly the gap Merton's typology exposes.
Worked example: reading an audit study
Devah Pager (2003) sent two pairs of trained young men, one pair Black and one white, with matched CVs to apply for entry-level jobs in Milwaukee. 1. Design: within each same-race pair, one applicant reported a fictional drug conviction, taking turns, so the effects of race and record could be compared. 2. Results: white applicants without a record were called back about 34% of the time and Black applicants without one about 14%. White applicants with a record were called back about 17% of the time, slightly more than Black applicants with no record. 3. Interpretation: because the applicants were matched, the gap measures discrimination by employers. 4. Limits: one city, one period and entry-level jobs, so later studies were needed to test how far the finding generalises.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking racism exists only when someone intends harm: institutional practices can produce racial disadvantage without hostile intent. Second, assuming that if prejudice declines, discrimination must disappear: Merton's types show the two can separate. Third, treating privilege as a personal accusation rather than a description of social arrangements. Fourth, believing that because redlining was outlawed in 1968 it no longer matters: wealth passes between generations. Fifth, reading one audit study as the whole story; look at many studies and their settings. Sixth, presenting contested ideas, such as colour-blind racism or privilege, as settled facts without noting their critics.
Key takeaways
Sociology extends the psychology of prejudice to institutions. Merton (1949) crossed prejudice and discrimination to give four types, showing that each can occur without the other. Individual discrimination is by persons; institutional discrimination is built into rules, a concept Carmichael and Hamilton named institutional racism (1967). Forms of racism include interpersonal, systemic, racial profiling, colourism, cultural and historical racism. Bonilla-Silva's colour-blind racism and McIntosh's privilege are influential but debated. Redlining from the 1930s helped produce a racial wealth gap of roughly six to one in 2022. Audit studies such as Pager (2003) measure discrimination directly.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Beliefs in racial superiority plus practices and structures that advantage one race
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A hotel clerk holds no racial prejudice but follows a manager's instruction to give the worst rooms to guests with certain surnames. In Merton's typology, the clerk is a:
Question 2 of 5
A company fills jobs only through referrals from current staff, and its staff are mostly white. Nobody intends to exclude anyone, yet few Black candidates are hired. This is best described as:
Question 3 of 5
Why do sociologists argue that redlining still matters, even though it was banned in 1968?
Question 4 of 5
In Devah Pager's 2003 Milwaukee audit study, what was the most striking finding?
Question 5 of 5
Eduardo Bonilla-Silva's idea of colour-blind racism refers to:
