Sociology › Section K · Race and ethnicity › Topic K.1
Racial, ethnic, and minority groups
Race, ethnicity and minority status are three of the most powerful labels a society hands out, and in everyday talk they blur together. Sociologists keep them apart, because each one points to a different thing: perceived physical difference, shared culture, and unequal power.
Three labels, three questions
Ask someone to describe their background and you may hear a mix of answers: "Black", "Korean American", "Catholic", "from Ohio". Sociologists sort such answers with three separate questions. Race asks which physical differences a society has decided to treat as meaningful. Ethnicity asks which culture a person shares with others: language, ancestry, religion, customs and a sense of common history. Minority status asks how much power a group holds compared with the dominant group. Everyone can be placed by all three questions, and the answers do not have to line up.
Race as a social construction
A race is a category of people that a society treats as distinct because of perceived physical traits such as skin colour or hair texture. Biology does not supply these boundaries. Human genetic variation changes gradually across geography, and in 1972 the geneticist Richard Lewontin estimated that about 85% of it lies within local populations and only about 6% between conventional races; later studies broadly agree. Skin colour also varies independently of most other traits. For these reasons the American Sociological Association and the American Association of Biological Anthropologists describe race as socially constructed. Constructed does not mean unreal: racial categories have shaped laws, wealth, housing and health for centuries, and they still affect lives today.
Categories change across time and place
If race were fixed by nature, every society would draw the same lines. They do not. In 1795 the German anatomist Johann Blumenbach divided humanity into five "varieties", a scheme long since rejected. Several US states wrote versions of the one-drop rule into law, classing anyone with any known African ancestry as Black; Virginia's Racial Integrity Act of 1924 is an example. Brazil's official statistics instead use colour categories that include pardo, a broad mixed category. Some historians argue that Irish and southern Italian immigrants were not fully accepted as white in the nineteenth century, although the law counted them as white. Even the words change: APA style capitalises both Black and White, while AP style and many newspapers capitalise Black but not white, the convention this course follows.
Ethnicity: shared culture
Ethnicity refers to shared culture and ancestry: language, religion, food, festivals, customs and a sense of common origin. It centres on what a group does and remembers, not how its members look. People of one race can belong to many ethnic groups; white Americans include people of Irish, Polish, Lebanese and Greek descent. Ethnicity is also different from national origin, the country where a person or their ancestors were born. Nigeria, for instance, is home to more than 250 ethnic groups, among them the Yoruba, Igbo and Hausa, so "Nigerian" names a nationality, not one ethnicity. Many people hold several ethnic identities, and they may stress different ones in different settings.
Symbolic ethnicity and pan-ethnicity
Herbert Gans (1979) described symbolic ethnicity among later generations of European immigrants: heritage expressed on chosen occasions, such as a holiday meal or a parade, without shaping work, marriage or neighbourhood. Mary Waters (1990) added that white Americans often have ethnic options, choosing which ancestry to stress, while people seen as non-white are usually labelled by others whatever they choose. A different process creates pan-ethnic identities, which group many related ethnicities under one label. "Asian American" grew in the late 1960s as activists from different origins organised together, and "Hispanic" or "Latino" covers people with roots in many countries. Some people embrace these umbrella labels; others prefer a specific origin, such as Mexican American.
Minority and dominant groups
In sociology a minority group, also called a subordinate group, is one whose members have less power and receive unequal treatment because of their physical or cultural traits. The dominant group is the one with the most power and privilege, which lets it shape the society's institutions and norms. Size is not the test. Louis Wirth (1945) defined minorities by differential treatment, not by numbers. Under apartheid in South Africa, from 1948 to the early 1990s, Black South Africans were the large majority of the population yet were a minority group in this sense. In 1951 Helen Hacker argued that women in the United States also met the definition, despite being half the population.
Five features of a minority group
Charles Wagley and Marvin Harris (1958) listed five features that minority groups usually share. 1. Unequal treatment and less power over their own lives. 2. Distinguishing physical or cultural traits, such as skin colour or language, that others use to identify them. 3. Involuntary membership: people are usually born into the group rather than choosing it. 4. Awareness of subordination, which often builds solidarity within the group. 5. A high rate of marriage within the group, partly by choice and historically often enforced by law. The list is a guide rather than a strict test, and sociologists also apply it to religious minorities, disabled people and LGBTQ+ people.
Worked example: sorting the labels
Ada was born in Lagos to a Yoruba family, moved to Houston at 12, became a US citizen and is a practising Anglican. Sort her labels. 1. Race: in the US she would usually be classed, and may identify, as Black, a category based on perceived appearance. 2. Ethnicity: Yoruba, her shared language, ancestry and customs; she might also say Nigerian American. 3. National origin: Nigeria, her birthplace. Her religion is part of her culture but says nothing about her race. 4. Minority status: as a Black woman in the US she belongs to groups that sociologists analyse as subordinate, because of power, not numbers. 5. Check: each answer came from a different question, and none could be inferred from another.
Worked example: the multiracial jump
The share of people reporting two or more races in the US census rose from 2.9% in 2010 to 10.2% in 2020, about 33.8 million people. Did the country suddenly become far more mixed? 1. Real change: intermarriage has risen for decades, so some growth is genuine. 2. Measurement change: in 2020 the Census Bureau improved the race question and coded write-in origins more fully, so more people were counted in more than one group. 3. Weigh them: the Bureau credited both demographic change and its redesign and cautioned against direct comparison; many analysts think the method explains much of the jump. 4. Conclusion: a change in the numbers can be a change in counting, and official categories are themselves social constructions.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating race as a biological fact: societies draw the boundaries, though the effects are real. Second, using race and ethnicity interchangeably: one rests on perceived appearance, the other on culture. Third, confusing ethnicity with national origin or nationality. Fourth, assuming a minority group must be numerically small: the defining feature is lack of power, as apartheid South Africa shows. Fifth, reading every change in census figures as a change in the population, without checking whether the question changed. Sixth, assigning someone an identity label they have not chosen; where possible, use the terms people use for themselves.
Key takeaways
Race is a category built on perceived physical traits; most human genetic variation lies within so-called races, so race is socially constructed but has real consequences. Racial categories differ across time and place, as the one-drop rule and Brazil's colour categories show. Ethnicity is shared culture and ancestry, distinct from national origin; it may be symbolic (Gans, 1979) or pan-ethnic. A minority or subordinate group is defined by unequal power and treatment, not size (Wirth, 1945). Wagley and Harris (1958) listed five common features. Census categories, such as the 2020 multiracial count, are themselves social constructions.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A category of people a society treats as distinct because of perceived physical traits
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why do sociologists describe race as a social construction?
Question 2 of 5
A woman was born in Ghana, has Ashanti heritage and now lives in Canada. Which label describes her ethnicity rather than her national origin?
Question 3 of 5
Under apartheid, Black South Africans were most of the population. Why do sociologists still call them a minority group?
Question 4 of 5
The share of Americans counted as multiracial rose from 2.9% in 2010 to 10.2% in 2020. What is the best interpretation?
Question 5 of 5
A fourth-generation Italian American cooks a family recipe at Christmas but says her heritage plays no part in her job, friendships or choice of partner. This is an example of:
