Sociology › Section J · Global inequality › Topic J.3
Theories of global stratification
In the early 1960s South Korea and Ghana had broadly similar incomes; today one is a high-income industrial power and the other a lower-middle-income country. Theories of global stratification offer competing explanations for gaps like this, and for what poorer countries can do about them.
The puzzle of divergent paths
The political scientist Samuel Huntington pointed out that in the early 1960s South Korea and Ghana had broadly similar income per person and economies built largely on primary products; he credited the later gap mainly to cultural values, a view many scholars dispute. Within a few decades South Korea had become an exporter of ships, cars and electronics, and it is now a high-income country, while Ghana is classed by the World Bank as lower-middle income. Why do some countries grow rich while others do not? Sociologists and economists answer with several theories. Each stresses different causes, internal or external, cultural or institutional, and each implies different policies. This topic sets out the main perspectives, their evidence and their critics.
The three sociological lenses
The three classic perspectives each ask a different question about global inequality. A functionalist asks how inequality between countries arises from differences in adapting to technology and markets, and might stress that foreign firms bring jobs, wages and infrastructure to poorer countries. A conflict theorist asks how powerful countries and corporations create and keep their advantage, for example by paying overseas workers far less than at home. A symbolic interactionist studies the meanings people attach to work and poverty. The journalist Leslie T. Chang's Factory Girls (2008), which follows young women who left villages for factory jobs in Dongguan, China, shows how migrants experience the global economy in daily life.
Modernisation theory
Modernisation theory holds that poor countries are poor mainly because they have not yet industrialised, and that they can develop by adopting the technologies, institutions and values of rich ones. Its best-known version is the economist W. W. Rostow's The Stages of Economic Growth (1960). Rostow described five stages: traditional society; the preconditions for take-off; take-off, when investment and industry surge; the drive to maturity; and the age of high mass consumption. Modernisation theorists stressed cultural change towards saving, achievement and innovation, and they favoured foreign aid, investment and technical assistance from rich countries to speed the passage through the stages.
Criticisms of modernisation theory
Critics argue that modernisation theory is ethnocentric: it treats the Western path as the only one and assumes every country wants to follow it. It blames poverty on the culture of poor countries while ignoring their history, especially colonial rule that reorganised economies to serve European powers. It also assumes that all countries start from the same position, when latecomers must compete with established industrial powers. Supporters reply that the rapid growth of East Asian economies, which invested heavily in education and industry, shows that modernisation can work, and that improvements in health and life expectancy have followed industrialisation almost everywhere.
Dependency theory
Dependency theory arose largely in Latin America in the 1950s and 1960s as a response to modernisation theory. The Argentine economist Raúl Prebisch argued that countries exporting raw materials tend to face falling prices relative to the manufactured goods they import, so they must export ever more to buy the same machines. The economist Andre Gunder Frank, in a 1966 essay, coined the phrase "the development of underdevelopment": poor countries were not simply behind but had been made poor by their integration into a world economy that drained surplus to rich metropolitan centres. Many Latin American governments responded with import-substitution industrialisation, protecting local industries behind tariffs.
Worked example: falling terms of trade
A hypothetical country exports coffee and imports tractors. 1. Year 1: coffee sells for $2.00 a kilogram and a tractor costs $20,000, so one tractor costs \(20{,}000 \div 2.00 = 10{,}000\) kg of coffee. 2. Year 20: coffee has fallen to $1.50 and a tractor has risen to $30,000, so one tractor costs \(30{,}000 \div 1.50 = 20{,}000\) kg. 3. The country must export twice as much coffee to buy the same machine. 4. Interpret: this is the pattern Prebisch described, a decline in the terms of trade for primary exporters. 5. Check: the ratio of export price to import price fell from \(2 \div 20{,}000\) to \(1.5 \div 30{,}000\), halving from 0.0001 to 0.00005.
Criticisms and the world-systems revision
Critics of dependency theory point out that the fastest-growing poor economies since the 1960s, such as South Korea, Taiwan and later China, grew by integrating into world trade and exporting manufactures, not by withdrawing from it. Import substitution often produced costly, uncompetitive industries and contributed to debt crises. Former colonies with similar histories have also had very different outcomes, so dependency alone cannot explain them. Immanuel Wallerstein's world-systems approach, introduced earlier in this section, kept dependency theory's focus on a single world economy but added the semi-periphery and allowed countries to move between zones, which fits cases such as South Korea better.
Institutions and the 2024 Nobel Prize
A more recent approach centres on institutions. The economists Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James Robinson, who shared the 2024 Nobel memorial prize in economic sciences, argue that inclusive institutions, which protect property rights, enforce contracts and spread political power broadly, encourage investment and innovation. Extractive institutions concentrate power and wealth in a small elite and discourage effort. They link these patterns partly to colonial history: where European settlers faced high death rates, colonisers tended to set up extractive systems that later rulers inherited. Critics argue that geography, disease and culture also matter, and that institutions are partly a result of prosperity, not only its cause.
Worked example: South Korea and Ghana
Apply each theory to the two countries. 1. Modernisation: South Korea invested heavily in schooling and moved through take-off into industry, while Ghana remained centred on cocoa and minerals. 2. Dependency: Ghana's economy was organised under British rule to export cocoa, and it stayed exposed to swings in cocoa prices after independence in 1957. 3. World-systems: South Korea rose from periphery towards core, helped by Cold War aid and access to the US market. 4. Institutional: South Korea's land reform and capable state contrast with Ghana's series of coups from 1966 to the early 1980s. 5. Verdict: each theory highlights a real factor, and most scholars combine several rather than relying on one.
Comparing the theories
The theories differ chiefly on where they locate the causes of poverty. Modernisation theory looks mainly inside poor countries, at their technology and values. Dependency and world-systems theories look mainly at relations between countries, at trade, investment and power. Institutional theory looks at the rules that govern economic and political life, shaped by both internal choices and colonial history. Their policy advice differs too: aid and investment; protection or a fairer world economy; and reform of governance. Evidence from the last sixty years gives each some support, which is why debate continues.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating modernisation and dependency theory as mere opposites with nothing in common: both accept that industrialisation raises incomes, but they disagree about whether ties to rich countries help or harm. Second, crediting Rostow with dependency theory: Rostow was the leading modernisation theorist. Third, assuming dependency theory says trade always harms poor countries; its claim concerns unequal terms and power. Fourth, forgetting that East Asian growth challenges dependency theory. Fifth, treating institutions as the only cause: geography, history and culture are also debated.
Key takeaways
Modernisation theory (Rostow, 1960, five stages) holds that poor countries can develop by industrialising and adopting modern values; critics call it ethnocentric and blind to colonial history. Dependency theory (Prebisch; Frank, 1966) holds that poor countries were made poor by unequal integration into the world economy, shown by falling terms of trade; East Asian growth challenges it. World-systems theory adds the semi-periphery and mobility. Acemoglu, Johnson and Robinson, Nobel laureates in 2024, stress inclusive versus extractive institutions. Most scholars combine several explanations.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Similar incomes in the early 1960s, very different paths since
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement best summarises modernisation theory?
Question 2 of 5
Coffee falls from $2.00 to $1.50 a kilogram while a tractor rises from $20,000 to $30,000. How much more coffee must be exported to buy one tractor?
Question 3 of 5
Who coined the phrase "the development of underdevelopment"?
Question 4 of 5
Which evidence most directly challenges dependency theory?
Question 5 of 5
According to Acemoglu, Johnson and Robinson, which kind of institutions encourage long-run prosperity?
