Sociology › Section D · Society and social interaction › Topic D.3

The social construction of reality

Money, schools, borders and job titles are not facts of nature, yet they shape your life as firmly as gravity. Sociologists explain how people create such realities through repeated interaction, and how the positions and roles we occupy are built in the same way.

Is a $20 bill real?

Physically, a $20 bill is a small rectangle of printed cotton-and-linen paper. Yet it buys a meal, because shopkeepers, banks and governments all act as though it is worth $20. Most money now exists only as numbers in bank computers, which makes the point even clearer: its value rests entirely on shared agreement. The same is true of a border, a degree or a marriage. Sociologists call such things, which exist because people collectively treat them as real, social constructions. Constructed does not mean imaginary; it means made by people rather than given by nature.

Berger and Luckmann

The sociologists Peter Berger and Thomas Luckmann set out the idea in The Social Construction of Reality (1966). Their argument runs in steps. First comes habitualisation: an action repeated often becomes a pattern performed with little thought. When a group shares such patterns and expects them of everyone in a given role, they become institutionalised, turned into established conventions, from greetings to schools. Later generations are born into these institutions and learn them as simply "the way things are". So people create society, society comes to feel like an objective reality, and people are in turn shaped by it.

Money in crisis

Money shows what happens when a shared agreement breaks down. In Zimbabwe in the late 2000s, the government printed money at a soaring rate and people lost confidence in the currency. Prices rose so fast that the central bank issued a note for 100 trillion Zimbabwean dollars in 2009, and shops increasingly refused the local currency in favour of US dollars and South African rand. The notes had not changed physically; trust had collapsed, and in 2009 the country largely abandoned its own currency. A social construction is only as stable as the shared belief and behaviour that keep it going.

The Thomas theorem

The American sociologists W. I. Thomas and Dorothy Swaine Thomas put a related idea into one sentence in The Child in America (1928): "If men define situations as real, they are real in their consequences." People respond not to a situation as an outside observer would see it, but to their own definition of it. A student who believes a teacher dislikes them may stop participating and earn lower marks, whatever the teacher actually feels. Two people who define the same remark differently, as a joke or an insult, may react in opposite ways.

Self-fulfilling prophecies

Building on the Thomas theorem, Robert K. Merton, in a 1948 essay, described the self-fulfilling prophecy: a false definition of a situation that provokes behaviour which makes the original false belief come true. His best-known example is a bank run. A sound bank is rumoured to be failing; worried customers rush to withdraw their savings; because banks lend out most deposits, it cannot pay everyone at once, and it fails. The rumour created the reality it predicted. Merton stressed that the prophecy's success then seems to prove it was right all along, which is why such beliefs are so hard to dislodge.

Worked example: an empty shelf

In March 2020, as COVID-19 spread, shops in several countries ran out of toilet paper, although its supply had not collapsed. Analyse the episode. 1. The definition: news and social media images of empty shelves led many people to define the situation as a coming shortage. 2. The behaviour: shoppers bought far more than usual. 3. The consequence: shelves emptied, a real if temporary shortage, as the Thomas theorem predicts. 4. The prophecy: the shortage seemed to prove the original fear right, so more people stockpiled, a self-fulfilling prophecy. 5. Check: the shortage came from a shared definition and the actions it prompted, not from factories stopping.

Status: the positions we occupy

Constructed realities include the positions people hold. A status is a socially recognised position in a group or society: student, daughter, nurse, retiree. Everyone holds many at once. An ascribed status is one you are born into or acquire without choosing it, such as your age group or your position as someone's son or daughter. An achieved status is earned or chosen, such as being a college graduate, a parent or a convicted offender. The sociologist Everett Hughes, in 1945, described a master status, one that overshadows all the others in how people are seen, such as a famous athlete's sporting fame or a serious illness.

Roles: role sets, strain and conflict

A role is the behaviour expected of someone who holds a status: status is the position, role is the part played in it. Merton noted that one status can carry a whole role set, several roles at once. A teacher plays different roles towards pupils, parents, colleagues and the head teacher. Problems arise in two ways. Role strain is tension within one status, when its demands are too many or pull against each other, as when a manager must be both a supportive mentor and a strict evaluator of the same employees. Role conflict is tension between different statuses, as when a parent's evening work shift clashes with a child's school concert.

Worked example: a student athlete's week

Leila is a college student, a basketball player and a part-time café worker. Analyse her week. 1. Statuses: student and athlete are achieved; her age and her place in her family are ascribed. 2. Role set: as an athlete she plays teammate, captain and the college's face in the media. 3. Role strain: as captain she must encourage a struggling friend on the team and also tell the coach honestly that the friend is not ready, tension within one status. 4. Role conflict: an away game falls on the night before an exam, and her café manager asks her to cover a shift, tension between statuses. 5. Check: strain stays inside one status; conflict crosses between them.

Performing roles

We can never see a role directly, only role performance, the way a person actually carries it out. Theoretical perspectives in sociology introduced Erving Goffman's dramaturgical analysis, with its front stage and back stage. A key part of his account is impression management, the work people do to control how others see them. Performers use props and settings: a judge's robe and raised bench project authority; a doctor's white coat signals expertise. A shared definition of the scene is essential; if a dinner guest acts as if they were the host, the performance breaks down. How such performances build a sense of self is explored further in Theories of self-development.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking socially constructed means fake: money and borders are constructed, yet their effects are real. Second, reading the Thomas theorem as saying beliefs are always accurate: it says beliefs have real consequences, true or not. Third, forgetting that a self-fulfilling prophecy starts with a false belief. Fourth, mixing up status and role: status is the position, role the expected behaviour. Fifth, confusing role strain, which arises within one status, with role conflict, which arises between statuses.

Key takeaways

Social constructions are realities people create and sustain by acting as if they are real, such as money, as Zimbabwe's currency collapse showed. Berger and Luckmann (1966) traced habitualisation into institutionalisation, so created society feels objective. The Thomas theorem (1928) holds that situations defined as real are real in their consequences; Merton's self-fulfilling prophecy (1948) turns a false belief true. Statuses are ascribed or achieved, and one may become a master status. Roles bring role sets, role strain and role conflict, and Goffman's impression management shows roles being performed.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Social construction

Something that exists because people collectively treat it as real

Money, borders, degrees.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A town wrongly believes a new factory will poison its water, so families move away and local shops close. Which idea best explains how the belief produced real effects?

Question 2 of 5

A nurse is also a parent. A hospital asks her to work late on the night of her son's school play. This is an example of:

Question 3 of 5

Which of these is an achieved status?

Question 4 of 5

In Berger and Luckmann's account, institutionalisation refers to:

Question 5 of 5

A job candidate wears a new suit, brings a polished portfolio and rehearses answers to appear confident. Goffman would call this:

← Previous topicNext topic →