Sociology › Section E · Socialization › Topic E.1
Theories of self-development
Nobody is born knowing who they are. This topic sets out how sociologists, above all Charles Horton Cooley and George Herbert Mead, explain the way a sense of self grows out of everyday contact with other people.
Where does a self come from?
A newborn has genes, a body and a temperament, but not yet a self: a person's distinct sense of identity, including the ability to think about themselves as others might see them. Sociologists argue that this ability is built through social interaction. Self-development is the first chapter of socialisation, the lifelong process of learning a society's norms, values and beliefs. Evidence that contact matters comes partly from isolation studies, such as Harry Harlow's work with monkeys, described in the psychology topic Stages of development; the next topic weighs nature against nurture.
Looking inward and looking outward
Psychologists and sociologists both study how a self develops, but they tend to look in different directions. Psychologists usually look inward, at the mind: memory, emotion and reasoning as they change with age. Sociologists usually look outward, at the relationships, groups, institutions and cultural norms that surround a person. Neither view is complete alone. A child's growing confidence involves both a maturing brain and the reactions of parents, teachers and friends.
Psychological stage theories, briefly
Three psychologists shaped how stages of growth are described. Sigmund Freud linked adult personality to early childhood experience and pictured the mind as the id (drives), the superego (internalised conscience) and the ego, which balances them against reality. Erik Erikson proposed eight psychosocial stages running from infancy to old age, each centred on a social conflict, such as identity versus role confusion in adolescence. Jean Piaget traced four stages of cognitive development, from the sensorimotor stage of infancy to abstract formal operational thought. The psychology topic Lifespan theories explains each, with the evidence for and against. Sociologists take from them the idea that the self changes over time, then focus on the social relationships that drive the change.
Cooley's looking-glass self
Charles Horton Cooley (1864-1929), who taught at the University of Michigan, proposed in 1902 that we see ourselves partly in the mirror of other people's reactions. He called this the looking-glass self, and it has three steps. First, we imagine how we appear to another person. Second, we imagine how that person judges what they see. Third, we feel something about ourselves as a result, such as pride or embarrassment. The key word is imagine. Our self-image rests on what we think others think of us, and that guess can be wrong. A self built this way is social from the start.
Mead: the self is a social process
George Herbert Mead (1863-1931), a philosopher at the University of Chicago, took Cooley's idea further. For Mead the self is the ability to treat yourself as an object: to step outside your own view and look back at yourself as others do. That ability is not inborn. It develops through taking the role of the other, imagining a situation from another person's position, and it depends on language and other shared symbols. His best-known account, Mind, Self, and Society (1934), was compiled after his death from students' notes of his lectures. His work became a foundation of symbolic interactionism.
Mead's stages of role-taking
Mead described a sequence in which children learn to take more and wider roles. Textbooks often begin with a preparatory stage, when very young children copy gestures and words without understanding them. In the play stage, children act out one role at a time, such as a parent or a shopkeeper, and so begin to see the world from that person's position. In the game stage, they keep several roles in mind at once and follow shared rules, as in a team sport where each player must anticipate everyone else's moves. Finally they form a generalised other: a sense of the expectations of society as a whole, which they use to judge their own conduct.
The I and the me
Mead divided the self into two parts in constant conversation. The "I" is the spontaneous, acting side: the impulse to laugh, argue or try something new, which can never be fully predicted. The "me" is the social side: the attitudes and expectations of others that a person has taken in and uses to see and judge themselves. The "I" acts, the "me" reflects, and the next action takes that reflection into account. So people are neither robots programmed by society nor wholly free of it. Socialisation supplies the "me", but the "I" leaves room for creativity, rebellion and change.
Moral development: Kohlberg and Gilligan
Part of becoming a self is learning what a society counts as right and wrong, called moral development. Lawrence Kohlberg described three levels of moral reasoning: preconventional, judging by punishment and reward; conventional, judging by approval, rules and laws; and postconventional, judging by principles that can stand above the law. Carol Gilligan, in In a Different Voice (1982), argued that his early research, based largely on boys and men, missed an ethic of care centred on relationships and responsibility. Later reviews found only small average differences between the sexes, and sociologists read such differences as products of gender socialisation, not fixed traits.
Worked example: one child, Mead's stages
Trace Maya's development using Mead's sequence. 1. At 18 months she holds a toy phone to her ear and babbles, copying her mother: imitation, the preparatory stage. 2. At 4 she plays at being a vet, bandaging a stuffed dog and telling it to be brave: one role at a time, the play stage. 3. At 9 she plays shortstop and knows where to throw because she tracks the batter, the runners and her teammates together: the game stage. 4. At 15 a cashier gives her too much change, and she hands it back because "that's what people expect": the generalised other. 5. Check: each step takes in a wider circle of viewpoints.
Worked example: a mirror that misleads
Jordan gives a class presentation and sees several classmates looking down at their phones. Apply Cooley's three steps. 1. Imagined appearance: Jordan pictures himself as nervous and dull. 2. Imagined judgement: he decides they think he is boring. 3. Self-feeling: he feels embarrassed and resolves never to volunteer again. 4. Test the reflection: a classmate later says she was looking up a source he had mentioned, so the judgement existed only in his imagination. 5. Conclusion: the looking-glass self explains his feelings even though his reading was wrong. Reviews of the research, such as one by J. Sidney Shrauger and Thomas Schoeneman (1979), found that self-views match what people believe others think more closely than what others actually think.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the looking-glass self depends on how others really see us: it depends on how we imagine they see us. Second, confusing the play stage, one role at a time, with the game stage, several roles at once within rules. Third, treating the generalised other as one important person: it is the expectations of society in general. Fourth, reversing the "I" and the "me": the "I" is spontaneous, the "me" is the socialised part. Fifth, presenting Gilligan's claim of a distinct female moral voice as a settled finding.
Key takeaways
The self develops through social interaction. Psychologists tend to look inward at the mind, sociologists outward at the social world. Cooley's looking-glass self (1902): imagined appearance, imagined judgement, self-feeling. Mead: the self is the ability to take the role of the other, growing through imitation, the play stage, the game stage and the generalised other, and made up of the spontaneous "I" and the socialised "me". Kohlberg described three levels of moral reasoning; Gilligan (1982) added an ethic of care, though later research found only small sex differences.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A person's distinct sense of identity, including seeing oneself as others might
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
According to Cooley, which of these most directly shapes a person's self-image?
Question 2 of 5
A 10-year-old playing football passes to a teammate because she knows where the defenders and her teammates will move. Which of Mead's stages does this show?
Question 3 of 5
In Mead's theory, the "me" is best described as:
Question 4 of 5
A teenager decides not to cheat, thinking, "People just don't do that." Which concept fits best?
Question 5 of 5
What did Carol Gilligan argue about Lawrence Kohlberg's theory of moral development?
