Sociology › Section U · Social movements and change › Topic U.2

Social movements

Votes for women, the weekend, seat belts and smoke-free restaurants all exist partly because organised groups of ordinary people pushed for them. Social movements are how people outside formal power try to change society, or to stop it changing.

What is a social movement?

A social movement is an organised, sustained effort by a large group of people to bring about or resist social change. Unlike the brief, loosely structured episodes described in "Collective behavior", movements last for months or years, develop leaders and organisations, and pursue shared goals. They use many tactics: petitions, lobbying, lawsuits, boycotts, marches, strikes and civil disobedience, the deliberate, usually nonviolent breaking of a law seen as unjust. Movements operate at every level. A local campaign may fight to save a library; a state-level movement may push a ballot measure; national and global movements address issues such as labour rights, climate change or poverty, often through nongovernmental organisations.

Types of movement: Aberle's grid

The anthropologist David Aberle (1966) classified movements by two questions: whom do they aim to change, individuals or society, and how much change do they seek, limited or total? Alternative movements (Aberle's own word was alterative) seek limited change in individuals, such as campaigns encouraging people to quit smoking. Redemptive movements seek total change in individuals, such as religious movements calling for spiritual rebirth. Reformative movements seek limited change in society, such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving, founded in 1980 to toughen drunk-driving laws. Transformative, or revolutionary, movements seek total change in society, as in the revolutionary movements in Russia in 1917. Many sociologists add resistance movements, which try to prevent or reverse a change.

Stages of a movement

Building on work by Herbert Blumer, Armand Mauss and Charles Tilly, sociologists often describe four stages. In emergence, people become aware of a problem and early leaders appear, but there is little organisation. In coalescence, people join together, form groups, develop strategy and seek publicity. In bureaucratisation, also called institutionalisation, the movement becomes formal organisations with paid staff, budgets and lobbying power. In decline, mass activity fades. Decline can follow success, when goals are won; failure; co-optation, when leaders are absorbed into the establishment; repression by authorities; or the movement becoming mainstream. Its organisations may survive long after the street protests end.

Why movements arise: deprivation and resources

Relative deprivation theory holds that movements arise when people feel deprived compared with others or with what they believe they deserve. The feeling matters more than the absolute level of hardship. Yet grievances are common and movements are rarer, so something else is needed. Resource mobilisation theory, set out by John McCarthy and Mayer Zald (1977), argues that movements succeed when they can gather and use resources: money, time, members, leaders, meeting places and communication networks. They named the parts: a social movement organisation (SMO) is a single group; all the SMOs pursuing similar goals form a social movement industry; and all the industries in a society make up the social movement sector.

Political process theory

Political process theory, developed by Doug McAdam in a study of the civil rights movement (1982) and by Charles Tilly and others, adds the role of political opportunity. Movements are more likely to grow when the political system opens up: when elites are divided, when new allies gain power, when courts become sympathetic or when repression weakens. It also stresses existing networks that can be mobilised, such as churches, colleges and unions, and the shared sense among participants that change is both necessary and possible. The theory helps explain timing: why a long-standing grievance produces a mass movement in one decade and not in another.

Framing

Framing theory, developed by David Snow, Robert Benford and colleagues from the 1980s, studies how movements interpret issues so that people will act. Diagnostic framing defines the problem and who is responsible. Prognostic framing offers a solution and a strategy. Motivational framing gives the call to action and reasons to take part now. Movements also link their frames to potential supporters' views through frame alignment. Bridging connects people or groups who already share a view but are not organised. Amplification appeals to widely held values such as fairness or safety. Extension broadens a frame to take in other concerns. Transformation changes old meanings to create new ones.

New social movements and digital activism

From the 1970s, European scholars such as Alain Touraine and Alberto Melucci developed new social movement theory to explain movements that seemed different from the labour movement. Environmental, peace, feminist and LGBTQ+ movements focused on identity, values and quality of life rather than mainly on economic class, and were often loosely networked. Social media has since changed how movements form. The phrase "Me Too", first used by the activist Tarana Burke in 2006, spread as a hashtag in 2017. Zeynep Tufekci, in Twitter and Tear Gas (2017), argues that digital tools let movements mobilise quickly but can leave them without the organisational strength that slower organising builds.

Worked example: the Montgomery bus boycott

Explain why the Montgomery bus boycott of 1955-1956 succeeded. 1. Grievance: Black residents faced segregated buses and humiliating treatment, a relative deprivation sharpened by national ideals of equality. 2. Precipitating event: in December 1955 Rosa Parks, a trained NAACP activist, was arrested for refusing to give up her seat. 3. Resources: Black churches supplied meeting places, communication and leaders, including Martin Luther King Jr., and organisers ran a car-pool system so boycotters could still get to work. 4. Political opportunity: after Brown (1954), federal courts were more open to challenges; in 1956 the Supreme Court affirmed a ruling against bus segregation. 5. Conclude: grievance alone was not enough; resources and opportunity combined.

Worked example: framing a local campaign

Residents campaign for a protected cycle lane on a busy road. Identify their frames. 1. Diagnostic: "The road is dangerous because the city designed it for speed, not safety": it names the problem and who is responsible. 2. Prognostic: "Build a protected lane and lower the speed limit": a solution and a plan. 3. Motivational: "Come to Tuesday's council meeting before the budget vote": a call to act now. 4. Amplification: they stress child safety, a value most residents share. 5. Bridging: they invite a parents' group and a local business association that already want safer streets. 6. Check: each frame is matched to its function.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating any crowd or protest as a movement: movements are organised and sustained. Second, assuming hardship alone creates movements: resource mobilisation and political process theories show that resources and opportunities are also needed. Third, thinking decline always means failure: movements often decline after success. Fourth, confusing the parts of resource mobilisation: an SMO is one group, an industry is many groups with similar goals, and the sector is all of them. Fifth, assuming social media makes movements stronger in every respect.

Key takeaways

Social movements are organised, sustained efforts to promote or resist change, at local, state, national and global levels. Aberle (1966) classed them as alternative, redemptive, reformative or transformative; resistance movements oppose change. Stages run from emergence through coalescence and bureaucratisation to decline. Relative deprivation, resource mobilisation (McCarthy and Zald, 1977), political process theory (McAdam, 1982), framing (Snow and Benford) and new social movement theory explain movements' rise and success.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Social movement

An organised, sustained effort by many people to promote or resist social change

Longer-lasting than collective behaviour.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A campaign urges individual people to give up meat for health reasons but does not seek to change any laws. In Aberle's scheme this is a:

Question 2 of 5

Which idea is central to resource mobilisation theory?

Question 3 of 5

A movement's leaflet says, "Join us at city hall on Friday to demand action." Which kind of frame is this?

Question 4 of 5

A movement wins its main legal goal, and within a few years its mass rallies stop while a small professional organisation continues. What does this show?

Question 5 of 5

Why does political process theory help explain the timing of the civil rights movement's growth in the 1950s?

← Previous topicNext topic →