Sociology › Section I · Social stratification › Topic I.1
What is social stratification?
Every society sorts its members into higher and lower positions, and those positions shape who gets the best schools, jobs and health care. Social stratification is the sociological name for that layered system, and societies differ enormously in how rigid their layers are.
Society in layers
Borrowing the geologist's word for layers of rock, sociologists define social stratification as a system in which a society ranks categories of people in a hierarchy, giving them unequal access to valued resources. Four resources are ranked most often. Income is money received over a period, such as wages or dividends; wealth is the value of everything owned minus debts; power is the ability to get your way even against resistance; and prestige is the respect a position commands. A person's combined standing on income, education and occupation is called their socioeconomic status (SES). The key word is categories: stratification concerns patterned groups, not individuals.
Four features of every system
Sociologists commonly describe stratification by four features. First, it is a trait of society, not simply of individuals: a child born poor in a poor neighbourhood shares structural odds with millions of others, whatever their talent. Second, it persists across generations, because parents pass on money, connections and expectations. Third, it is universal but variable: every known society ranks people, but what is ranked, and how steeply, differs. Fourth, it rests on beliefs. Every system has an ideology, a set of ideas that makes its inequalities seem natural, fair or divinely ordained, and so helps people accept them.
Ascribed and achieved status
A status is a recognised social position. An ascribed status is assigned without choice, such as the family or caste a person is born into. An achieved status is gained through one's own actions, such as becoming a nurse or a business owner. Societies differ in how much ascribed status decides adult position. In a closed system, birth fixes position almost completely, movement between layers is rare and contact across them is restricted. In an open system, achievement counts for more, people can move up or down, and they can mix and marry across levels.
Closed systems: slavery and estates
The most extreme closed system is slavery, in which some people legally own others as property, often with the status passed to children. A second closed form is the estate system of medieval Europe. In France before the 1789 revolution, society was formally divided into three estates: the clergy, the nobility, and everyone else, from rich merchants to peasants. Noble rank was inherited, often by rules of primogeniture that passed land to the eldest son. Each estate had different legal rights, taxes and duties, justified by the idea of a God-given order of ranks.
Caste: the case of India
A caste system ranks people by birth into hereditary groups, and that rank governs occupation, marriage and social contact for life. In India, the classical texts describe four broad varnas, but daily life was organised around thousands of local birth groups called jatis. Marriage was expected within one's own group, a rule called endogamy, and ideas of ritual purity kept groups apart. Those placed outside and below the system, once called "untouchables" and now usually called Dalits, suffered severe exclusion. India's 1950 constitution abolished untouchability and allowed reserved places in government jobs and legislatures for disadvantaged castes, and a 1951 amendment extended reservations to education. Caste still shapes marriage and life chances, especially in rural areas, though cities have loosened it.
Class systems
A class system ranks people mainly by economic position, such as wealth, income, education and occupation, and it combines birth with achievement. It is open: people can rise or fall relative to their parents, and there are no legal barriers between classes. Marriage across class lines, an exogamous union, is permitted, and many people choose partners for love and compatibility. Yet most people still marry someone of similar education and background, so endogamy persists informally. Most industrial societies, including the United States, have class systems. The next topic maps the American classes and asks how often people really move between them.
Meritocracy: an ideal
A meritocracy is a system in which position depends entirely on personal talent and effort. The British sociologist Michael Young coined the word in his satire The Rise of the Meritocracy (1958), which imagined a future Britain ranked by tested intelligence. Young meant it as a warning: an elite convinced it had earned its place could look down on everyone else with a clear conscience. No real society is a pure meritocracy, because family resources, discrimination and luck always matter. Modern societies contain meritocratic elements, such as exams, and belief in meritocracy can itself act as an ideology, suggesting that people at the bottom deserve to be there.
Status consistency
Status consistency is the degree to which a person's rank is the same across the different dimensions of stratification. Someone with a doctorate, a prestigious job and a high income has high status consistency; someone with high rank on one dimension and low rank on another has low status consistency. Closed systems produce high consistency, because birth fixes education, occupation and wealth together. Open class systems produce more inconsistency, because people can gain money without schooling, or schooling without much money.
Worked example: measuring status consistency
Assess three hypothetical people. 1. Aisha has a PhD, teaches part-time at two colleges and earns about $34,000 a year. Education is high, occupational prestige is fairly high, income is low: low status consistency. 2. Tom left school at 16, built a roofing firm and earns $250,000. Education is low, income high, prestige middling: low status consistency again, in the opposite direction. 3. Priya is a surgeon whose parents were both doctors. Education, prestige, income and family background all rank high: high status consistency. 4. Interpret: in an open class system the dimensions can separate, as Aisha and Tom show; a closed system would rarely allow it. 5. Check: consistency describes agreement between ranks, not their level.
Worked example: open or closed?
Classify a society from evidence. A historian reports that in one region in 1700: almost every son followed his father's trade; marriage outside one's rank was forbidden by law; land passed by law to the eldest son; and preachers taught that each rank was ordained by God. 1. Mobility: sons inheriting trades shows little movement between generations. 2. Contact: legal bans on marriage across ranks restrict interaction between layers. 3. Inheritance rules: law, not effort, decides who holds wealth, so status is ascribed. 4. Ideology: religious teaching makes the order appear sacred, the fourth feature of every system. 5. Verdict: a closed, estate-like system; one merchant buying a title would not change that.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, explaining stratification only by individual effort: sociologists look for patterns among categories of people. Second, treating income and wealth as the same: income is a flow over a period, wealth is a stock of assets minus debts. Third, assuming India's caste system vanished in 1950: the constitution banned untouchability, but caste still affects marriage and opportunity. Fourth, calling any modern society a meritocracy: the term names an ideal, and Young coined it as a warning. Fifth, confusing low status consistency with low status: it means a person's ranks disagree, not that they are all low.
Key takeaways
Social stratification ranks categories of people unequally by income, wealth, power and prestige; SES combines income, education and occupation. Stratification is a trait of society, persists across generations, is universal but variable, and is justified by ideology. Ascribed status comes from birth, achieved status from action. Closed systems, such as slavery, European estates and the Indian caste system, fix position at birth; open class systems allow mobility. Meritocracy, a word Michael Young coined in 1958, is an ideal no society meets. Status consistency measures how closely a person's ranks agree.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A system ranking categories of people in a hierarchy with unequal access to resources
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A woman with a doctorate earns a low income as a part-time college teacher. How would a sociologist describe her position?
Question 2 of 5
Which feature most clearly marks a society as having a closed stratification system?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Michael Young coin the word "meritocracy" in 1958?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about caste in India is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
Preachers in a society teach that every rank was ordained by God. Which feature of stratification does this illustrate?
