Sociology › Section E · Socialization › Topic E.2
Why socialization matters
A society survives only if each new generation learns its ways, and a person becomes a person only by learning them. This topic looks at why socialisation matters for both, what cases of severe neglect reveal, and how sociologists approach the debate over nature and nurture.
How a society keeps itself going
Every society loses members to death and gains new ones through birth and migration. If newcomers never learned its language, customs, skills and values, its way of life would vanish within a lifetime. Socialisation, the lifelong process of learning a society's norms, values and beliefs, is how culture passes from one generation to the next. The process is clearest when it breaks down. Linguists record languages whose last fluent speakers are elderly because children were raised speaking something else; once no child learns a language, it cannot survive. The topic Elements of culture sets out what is passed on, from objects to values.
How a person becomes social
Socialisation matters just as much to the individual. Through it we learn language, which we need not only to talk but to think in complex ways. We learn countless practical skills, from dressing and eating to using money, and the unwritten rules about when and where each is appropriate. Above all, interaction gives us a self, the ability to see ourselves as others see us, as the previous topic, Theories of self-development, explained. Note the difference between socialising, spending time with others, and socialisation, the learning that happens through that contact.
Lessons from extreme isolation
Some children have been found after years of severe neglect. In the 1940s the sociologist Kingsley Davis described two American girls, known as Anna and Isabelle, each found at about age six after being shut away. Isabelle, given intensive teaching, reached roughly normal skills for her age within about two years; Anna made limited progress and died young. Genie, found in Los Angeles in 1970 at 13, learned many words but never mastered grammar, as the psychology topic Language describes. Such cases suggest that early interaction is vital, but they are weak evidence on their own: abuse, malnutrition and possible disabilities present from birth are tangled up with the isolation.
Evidence from orphanages
Stronger evidence comes from children raised in large institutions with many children per carer. The Bucharest Early Intervention Project, begun in 2000 by Charles Nelson, Nathan Fox and Charles Zeanah, studied young children living in Romanian orphanages. Because Romania then had almost no foster care, the researchers created a foster care network and randomly assigned about half the children to it. On average, children moved to foster families developed better in thinking, language and emotional attachment than those who stayed, and those placed before about age two gained most. Random assignment makes the comparison fairer than isolation cases, though the study's ethics are still debated.
Nature versus nurture
How much of who we are comes from nature, the genes and biology we inherit, and how much from nurture, the social environment we grow up in? Earlier thinkers often treated these as rivals. Researchers today see them as constantly interacting: genes shape how a child responds to surroundings, and surroundings shape how genes are expressed. A child born with a lively temperament may draw more conversation from adults, which in turn builds language. The useful question is not "which one?" but "how do they work together, and under what conditions?"
What twin studies show
Identical twins share all their genes, so twins raised apart offer a natural test of nature. The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart, begun in 1979, found that such twins were often strikingly similar in personality, interests and test scores, pointing to a substantial genetic contribution. Yet they were never identical, and the differences are the part shaped by experience. Critics add that separated twins were often placed in similar homes, which can inflate apparent genetic effects. The psychology topic The source of intelligence explains heritability and how to read these figures.
The sociological interest in nurture
Sociologists accept that biology matters but ask a different question: how do social conditions shape what any given set of abilities becomes? Social class, race, gender, religion and historical era all affect which talents are noticed, encouraged and rewarded. Even the influence of genes can depend on context. Eric Turkheimer and colleagues (2003) reported that genes explained much less of the variation in children's test scores in very poor US families than in better-off ones, a pattern later found more consistently in the United States than in Western Europe or Australia. The same potential can flourish or be stunted depending on circumstances.
Three perspectives on socialisation
Each main perspective explains socialisation's importance differently. Functionalists stress that it keeps society running: it trains members for their roles and passes on the shared culture that holds them together. Conflict theorists stress that it reproduces inequality, because children of different classes, races and genders are taught different expectations, which shape their later chances. Symbolic interactionists study the small exchanges through which meanings are taught. In a well-known study by John and Sandra Condry (1976), adults watching the same infant on video were more likely to describe its reaction as anger if told the baby was a boy, and as fear if told it was a girl.
Worked example: weighing an isolation case
Claim: "Genie's case proves that children who miss early social contact can never learn language." Evaluate it. 1. Evidence: after rescue at 13, Genie learned many words but never mastered grammar, which fits the claim. 2. Confound: she also suffered severe abuse and malnutrition, either of which could explain her difficulties. 3. Unknown starting point: some researchers suspected she had developmental problems before the isolation, which cannot now be checked. 4. Sample: one case cannot establish a rule, and Isabelle's rapid recovery points the other way. 5. Verdict: the case is consistent with early interaction mattering, but stronger evidence comes from controlled studies such as the Bucharest project.
Worked example: three lenses on household chores
In one family, the daughters are taught to cook and clean while the son mows the lawn and is excused from the kitchen. Analyse it. 1. Functionalist: the family is passing on practical skills each child will need, and dividing tasks keeps the household running smoothly. 2. Conflict: the pattern trains girls for the larger share of unpaid daily housework, reproducing a gender inequality into the next generation. 3. Interactionist: listen to the words used, such as a boy "helping" with dinner but a girl "doing" it, which tell children what is normal for each sex. 4. Check: each lens adds something real, and none alone gives the full picture.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing socialisation, the learning of culture, with socialising, spending time with friends. Second, treating isolation cases as proof: abuse, malnutrition and unknown starting conditions confound them. Third, framing nature and nurture as either-or: they interact. Fourth, reading strong similarities between twins raised apart as showing that environment does not matter: the twins still differ, and their homes were often alike. Fifth, assuming the three perspectives disagree about whether socialisation matters: they agree that it does, and disagree about whom it serves.
Key takeaways
Socialisation lets a society pass on its culture, and lets each person gain language, everyday skills and a self. Isolation cases such as Anna, Isabelle and Genie suggest early interaction is vital but are confounded; the randomised Bucharest project found that early foster care helped orphanage children most. Nature and nurture interact, and twins raised apart are similar but never identical. Functionalists see socialisation as passing on culture, conflict theorists as reproducing inequality, and interactionists as meaning taught in everyday exchanges.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The lifelong process of learning a society's norms, values and beliefs
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why do sociologists treat cases such as Genie's as weak evidence on their own?
Question 2 of 5
What made the Bucharest Early Intervention Project stronger evidence than isolation cases?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement best reflects the current view of nature and nurture?
Question 4 of 5
A sociologist argues that working-class and wealthy children are taught different expectations at home, which shapes their later chances. Which perspective is this?
Question 5 of 5
Identical twins raised apart are often very similar, but never the same. What do the differences between them mainly suggest?
