Statics › Section D · Moments and static equivalence › Topic D.7

Statically equivalent systems and resultants

However many forces and couples act on a rigid body, their combined external effect can be captured by one resultant force and one resultant moment. Finding that simplest equivalent system tells an engineer the total load and where it effectively acts.

Loading systems

A loading system is the whole collection of forces and couple moments acting on a body: the loads on a floor beam, the wind and weight on a sign, the pulls of several cables on a mast. Using the equivalent transformations of "Moving forces: force-couple systems", any loading system can be replaced by a much simpler one with the same external effect. This topic shows how to find it, how to simplify it further, and how to tell whether two different loadings are statically equivalent.

Resultant force and resultant moment

The resultant force is the vector sum of every force, \(\mathbf{R} = \sum \mathbf{F}\). The resultant moment about a chosen point O is the sum of the moments of all the forces about O plus every couple moment:

\mathbf{M}_O = \sum (\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F}) + \sum \mathbf{C}

Together, R acting at O and \(\mathbf{M}_O\) form a force-couple system equivalent to the whole loading. Choosing a different point leaves R unchanged but changes the moment. If both R and \(\mathbf{M}_O\) are zero, the loads balance and the body is in equilibrium; if not, the supports must supply the opposite.

The reduction procedure

1. Choose a convenient reference point O, often a support or a corner. 2. Add all the forces, component by component, to get R. 3. Find the moment of every force about O, with signs, and add every couple moment, to get \(\mathbf{M}_O\). 4. Replace the whole loading by R at O together with \(\mathbf{M}_O\). 5. If possible, simplify further by moving R to a line where its own moment about O equals \(\mathbf{M}_O\), so no couple is needed. In two dimensions this last step is always possible unless R is zero.

Worked example: loads on a beam

An 8.0 m beam carries downward loads of 12 kN at 1.0 m, 18 kN at 4.0 m and 6 kN at 7.0 m from its left end A. Find the single equivalent force. 1. The loads are parallel, so \(R = 12 + 18 + 6 = 36\) kN downwards. 2. Moments about A, all clockwise: \(12(1.0) + 18(4.0) + 6(7.0) = 126\) kN·m. 3. A single 36 kN downward force at distance x from A must give the same moment: \(36x = 126\), so \(x = 3.5\) m. 4. Check: the result lies between the loads, nearer the two heavier ones at 1.0 m and 4.0 m than the light one at 7.0 m. The beam's supports react exactly as they would to the three loads.

Locating the line of action

For a general set of forces in the xy-plane, the resultant has components \(R_x\) and \(R_y\), and the total moment about the origin is \(M_O\). A single force R reproduces \(M_O\) if it acts at any point (x, y) on the line

M_O = xR_y - yR_x

This is the 2D moment formula applied to R. Every point on this line gives the same answer, as transmissibility promises. Setting y = 0 gives where the line crosses the x-axis, \(x = M_O/R_y\), and setting x = 0 gives where it crosses the y-axis, \(y = -M_O/R_x\).

Worked example: a loaded plate

A plate, with origin O at one corner, carries: 200 N in the +x direction at (0, 1.0) m; 300 N in the −y direction at (2.0, 0) m; \(\langle -100, 150 \rangle\) N at (3.0, 0.5) m; and a 120 N·m counterclockwise couple. 1. \(\mathbf{R} = \langle 100, -150 \rangle\) N, magnitude 180 N, pointing 56.3° below +x. 2. Moments by \(xF_y - yF_x\): \(-200\), \(-600\) and \(3(150) - 0.5(-100) = +500\) N·m, plus the couple, +120. So \(M_O = -180\) N·m. 3. Single force: on the x-axis, \(x = M_O/R_y = (-180)/(-150) = 1.2\) m. 4. Check: at (1.2, 0), \(1.2(-150) = -180\) N·m, as required.

Testing two loadings for equivalence

Two loading systems are statically equivalent when they have the same resultant force and the same resultant moment about one point; then their moments agree about every point. For example, on a beam with left end A, system 1 is 50 N downwards at 2.0 m plus a 40 N·m clockwise couple, and system 2 is 50 N downwards at 2.8 m. Both have R = 50 N down. About A, system 1 gives \(-100 - 40 = -140\) N·m and system 2 gives \(-50(2.8) = -140\) N·m, so they are equivalent. A 50 N load at 1.2 m, giving −60 N·m, would not be.

Four special cases

Concurrent forces reduce to a single force through their common point, with no couple, because each has zero moment there; that is why particles needed only force equations. Parallel forces reduce to a single force equal to their sum, located so its moment matches theirs, unless the sum is zero. Coplanar forces reduce to a single force in the plane, unless R = 0, in which case a non-zero moment leaves a pure couple. In three dimensions, a general system cannot usually be reduced to one force at all.

The wrench

The simplest form of a general 3D system is a wrench: a force R together with a couple moment parallel to it, like the push and twist on a screwdriver. To find it, split \(\mathbf{M}_O\) into a part \(M_\parallel\) along R and a part \(M_\perp\) across it, then move R sideways by \(d = M_\perp/R\) to a point r chosen so that \(\mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{R} = \mathbf{M}_\perp\), which cancels \(M_\perp\). For example, \(\mathbf{R} = \langle 0, 0, 200 \rangle\) N with \(\mathbf{M}_O = \langle 60, 0, 50 \rangle\) N·m becomes R acting through (0, 0.3, 0) m plus a 50 N·m couple along +z. The wrench is positive when the couple and force point the same way.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, forgetting couple moments when adding moments, or adding them only if they act at O. Second, mixing reference points within one moment sum. Third, placing the single resultant at the centre of the beam or at the largest load instead of solving for its position. Fourth, dropping the sign of \(M_O\) or \(R_y\) when finding where the line crosses an axis. Fifth, comparing two systems by their forces alone. Sixth, using a resultant to find internal forces, which depend on the actual loads.

Key takeaways

Any loading system is equivalent to its resultant force R = ΣF at a chosen point O plus the resultant moment about O, which includes the moments of the forces and every couple. Changing O changes the moment, not R. Unless R is zero, a coplanar system or a set of parallel forces reduces to a single force on the line M = xRy − yRx; if R is zero, a non-zero moment leaves a pure couple. Concurrent forces reduce to one force through their common point. Two systems are equivalent when R and the moment about one point both match. A general 3D system reduces to a wrench.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Loading system

All the forces and couple moments acting on a body

Can be reduced to something simpler.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A beam carries downward loads of 10 kN at 1.0 m and 30 kN at 3.0 m from its left end. Where does the single equivalent force act?

Question 2 of 5

A set of forces has a resultant force of zero but a non-zero resultant moment. What is the simplest equivalent system?

Question 3 of 5

Several forces all pass through one common point P. What is their simplest equivalent system?

Question 4 of 5

A beam carries 60 N downwards at 1.5 m from end A plus a 36 N·m clockwise couple. Which single load is statically equivalent to it?

Question 5 of 5

A coplanar system has Rx = 60 N, Ry = −80 N and a resultant moment about the origin of −240 N·m. Where does the single resultant's line cross the x-axis?

← Previous topicNext topic →