US History › Section G · Reform and a decade of crisis › Topic G.3

Addressing slavery: the abolition movement

By 1830 about two million people were enslaved in the United States. Americans who wanted slavery to end disagreed sharply about how, and the most radical answer, immediate abolition, provoked fury in the North as well as the South.

Three answers to slavery

By 1804 every northern state had abolished slavery or begun gradual emancipation, but in the South slavery was growing with cotton. The 1830 census counted about two million enslaved people. Opponents of slavery offered very different solutions. Colonizationists wanted to free enslaved people gradually and send Black Americans abroad. Some enslaved and free Black Americans called for resistance, by force if needed. Abolitionists demanded an immediate end to slavery and equal rights for Black Americans, and they tried to win public opinion with moral argument. Each answer reveals a different view of whether Black and white Americans could live together as equals.

Colonization

The American Colonization Society, founded in 1816 and 1817, aimed to move free Black Americans to Africa. Leading politicians such as Henry Clay and James Madison supported it, and an 1819 act of Congress, meant to return Africans rescued from illegal slave ships, channelled federal money to its project. The society founded the colony of Liberia in West Africa in 1822; its capital, Monrovia, was named after President James Monroe. Many supporters believed the races could never live together as equals, and some slaveholders hoped to remove free Black people who might encourage resistance. Most free Black Americans rejected the plan: as early as 1817, a mass meeting in Philadelphia declared the United States their home. Only about 10,000 to 15,000 emigrants went before the Civil War.

Walker's Appeal and the shock of 1831

In 1829 David Walker, a free Black clothing dealer in Boston, published his Appeal to the Coloured Citizens of the World. It condemned colonization, attacked the hypocrisy of Christian slaveholders and urged enslaved people to resist, by force if necessary. Southern states tried to keep it out. Then, in August 1831, came Nat Turner's revolt in Virginia, which, as an earlier topic showed, killed about 55 to 60 white people and led southern states to harsher slave codes. Many white southerners blamed northern writers such as Walker and Garrison. Defenders of slavery hardened their case: in 1837 John C. Calhoun of South Carolina called slavery a positive good, not a necessary evil.

Worked example: comparing three answers to slavery

Compare the American Colonization Society, David Walker and William Lloyd Garrison. 1. Goal: the society sought gradual emancipation and the removal of free Black people; Walker and Garrison demanded freedom now. 2. Belonging: the society assumed Black Americans could never be equals at home; Walker and Garrison insisted the United States was their country. 3. Method: the society lobbied the powerful; Walker accepted force if needed; Garrison relied on persuasion and rejected violence. 4. Audience: the society addressed white leaders, Walker spoke mainly to Black Americans, and Garrison aimed at the conscience of all. 5. Conclusion: the deepest divide was over equality, not just timing. 6. Check: Garrison himself began as a colonizationist before rejecting it.

Garrison and immediatism

William Lloyd Garrison of Massachusetts had once supported colonization but came to see it as racist. On 1 January 1831 he began publishing The Liberator in Boston, promising in its first issue that he would not retreat and that he would be heard. Garrison demanded immediatism: slavery was a sin, so it must end now, without compensation to slaveholders. In 1833 he helped found the American Anti-Slavery Society, which rejected violence and relied on moral suasion, appealing to the conscience of the public. By about 1838 it claimed hundreds of thousands of members in well over a thousand local societies. Many of The Liberator's early subscribers were free Black northerners.

Tactics and the backlash

Abolitionists printed newspapers, pamphlets and the life stories of formerly enslaved people. In 1835 they mailed antislavery literature into the South, where a Charleston mob seized and burned it and many postmasters refused to deliver it. They flooded Congress with petitions, and in 1836 the House adopted a gag rule that tabled them unread until 1844; former president John Quincy Adams led the fight against it. Most northerners rejected abolition, and many feared racial equality or competition for jobs. A Boston mob dragged Garrison through the streets in 1835, a mob in Alton, Illinois, killed the editor Elijah Lovejoy in 1837, and a crowd burned Pennsylvania Hall in Philadelphia in 1838.

Frederick Douglass and Black abolitionists

Black Americans were the movement's core. Frederick Douglass, born into slavery in Maryland in about 1818, escaped in 1838 and became a powerful speaker. His Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass (1845) named the men who had enslaved and abused him, so he left for Britain to avoid recapture; British supporters then bought his freedom. In 1847 he founded the North Star newspaper in Rochester, New York. Other Black abolitionists included Henry Highland Garnet, who in 1843 urged enslaved people to resist, and members of vigilance committees, such as William Still in Philadelphia, who sheltered people escaping slavery.

Women in the movement

Women raised money, organised petitions and boycotts of slave-made goods, and wrote and spoke. The Philadelphia Female Anti-Slavery Society, founded in 1833 by Black and white women including Lucretia Mott and Sarah Mapps Douglass, ran for over three decades. Sarah and Angelina Grimké, daughters of a South Carolina slaveholding family, moved north and became Quakers and abolitionists. In 1837 they lectured to mixed audiences of men and women, which many people, including some clergy, condemned as improper. In 1838 Angelina spoke to a committee of the Massachusetts legislature. Attacks on their right to speak led many women to question their own unequal status.

Splits and political abolition

In 1840 the American Anti-Slavery Society split. Garrison's supporters backed women's full participation and shunned ordinary politics; Garrison later called the Constitution a pro-slavery bargain. Opponents left to form a rival society and to pursue abolition through elections. They founded the Liberty Party, whose candidate, James G. Birney, a former Kentucky slaveholder who had freed the people he enslaved, won only about 2 percent of the vote in 1844. Many Liberty voters later moved to the Free-Soil Party. Douglass also broke with Garrison in about 1851, deciding that the Constitution could be used against slavery.

Worked example: reading The Liberator's first issue

In his first issue, Garrison ended a defiant passage with the words "I will be heard." 1. Source: a newspaper editorial by a white Boston printer, aimed at northern readers, published on 1 January 1831. 2. Purpose: to announce that he would refuse moderate, gradual language about a moral evil. 3. Tone: urgent and uncompromising, matching the revival belief that sin must be abandoned at once. 4. Audience reaction: free Black readers supported the paper, while many white northerners found it reckless and southerners called it incendiary. 5. Limits: it shows Garrison's intentions, not how many people he persuaded.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, colonization was not abolitionism: most colonizationists wanted Black Americans removed, while abolitionists wanted equality at home. Second, most northerners were not abolitionists; the movement was a small, often hated minority in the 1830s. Third, Garrison's society rejected violence; calls for armed resistance came from others, such as Walker and Garnet. Fourth, Black Americans were not passive recipients of white help; they led, wrote, funded and protected. Fifth, abolitionists did not all agree: they split over women's roles, politics and the Constitution.

Key takeaways

Opponents of slavery divided over colonization, resistance and abolition. The American Colonization Society founded Liberia, but most free Black Americans rejected it. Walker's Appeal (1829) and Nat Turner's rebellion (1831) frightened the South into harsher slave codes and a positive-good defence of slavery. Garrison's Liberator (1831) and the American Anti-Slavery Society (1833) demanded immediate abolition by moral suasion and met a fierce backlash. Douglass and other Black abolitionists led the cause, women widened it, and the movement split in 1840.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Colonization

The plan to resettle free Black Americans abroad, chiefly in Africa

American Colonization Society, 1816-1817.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did most free Black Americans respond to the American Colonization Society?

Question 2 of 5

What did Garrison mean by immediatism?

Question 3 of 5

What was the congressional gag rule of 1836 to 1844?

Question 4 of 5

Why did Frederick Douglass leave for Britain soon after publishing his Narrative in 1845?

Question 5 of 5

Why did the American Anti-Slavery Society split in 1840?

← Previous topicNext topic →