US History › Section G · Reform and a decade of crisis › Topic G.2
Communal experiments and health reform
Some antebellum reformers tried to build perfect societies from scratch in small communities. Others set out to perfect the human body, starting with a national war on drink.
Perfecting society and the body
Around 1815, most Americans still lived on family farms and made much of what they used. The market revolution changed that: more people bought goods, worked for wages and moved away from kin, and many found the change unsettling or unjust. Dozens of groups responded by founding experimental communities, often called utopian, where members shared property and work in the hope of a more equal, harmonious life. The movement peaked in the 1840s. At the same time, reformers inspired by revival religion turned to the body, campaigning against alcohol and promoting new ideas about diet and health.
Religious communities: Ephrata and the Rappites
Most communal experiments were religious, and many members had been shaped by revivals. German Protestant migrants founded some of the earliest. The Ephrata Cloister in Pennsylvania, founded by Conrad Beissel in the 1730s, combined prayer, disciplined work and encouragement of celibacy. In 1805 George Rapp led several hundred followers, known as Rappites or Harmonists, to found Harmony, Pennsylvania. They held all goods in common, practised celibacy and sold their surplus goods to outsiders. They moved to Indiana in 1814 and 1815, building a second Harmony on the Wabash River, then sold it in 1825 and returned to Pennsylvania to found the town of Economy.
The Shakers
The Shakers, formally the United Society of Believers in Christ's Second Appearing, grew from an English group led by Ann Lee, who brought a few followers to New York in 1774. Followers called her Mother Ann and taught that God had both male and female natures. Shaker communities treated women and men as spiritual equals, a radical idea at the time, and shared all property. They practised strict celibacy, so they grew only by converts and by taking in orphans. Their worship included ecstatic dancing, which gave them their nickname. At their peak in the 1830s and 1840s, several thousand Shakers lived in communities from Maine to Kentucky.
Oneida and the Latter-day Saints
John Humphrey Noyes, inspired by revivals, preached perfectionism: the belief that people could become free of sin. In 1848 he founded the Oneida Community in New York, which shared property and practised complex marriage, in which members were treated as married to the whole group rather than to one spouse. It dissolved in 1881. Joseph Smith published the Book of Mormon in 1830 and founded the church whose members became known as Mormons. Members gathered in Ohio and Missouri, where hostile neighbours drove them out, then built Nauvoo, Illinois. After a mob killed Smith in 1844, Brigham Young led most members to the Salt Lake Valley from 1847.
Secular communities
Not every experiment was religious. Robert Owen, a Welsh-born manufacturer who ran model cotton mills at New Lanark in Scotland, believed reason and cooperation could end the misery of industrial workers. In 1825 he bought the Rappites' Indiana town and renamed it New Harmony, but quarrels over work and property broke it apart within about two years. In 1841 the transcendentalist George Ripley founded Brook Farm near Boston, where members mixed farm labour with study; the writer Nathaniel Hawthorne was briefly a member. Brook Farm later adopted the plans of the French thinker Charles Fourier, whose followers founded dozens of communal phalanxes in the 1840s.
Worked example: why did the Shakers outlast New Harmony?
The Shakers lasted for well over a century; New Harmony collapsed in about two years. 1. Shared purpose: Shakers joined for a religious mission, while New Harmony drew a mixed crowd with different hopes. 2. Authority: Shaker elders settled disputes; Owen was often absent, and members argued over who did the work. 3. Economics: Shakers sold seeds and well-made furniture, while New Harmony never paid its way. 4. Commitment: joining the Shakers meant giving up marriage and private property, which filtered out the half-hearted. 5. Conclusion: shared belief and firm discipline mattered more than ideals alone. 6. Check: Brook Farm, secular and short of money, also failed.
The temperance movement
Many reformers saw drink as the nation's worst problem. Historians estimate that in about 1830 adult Americans drank roughly three times as much alcohol per person as today, much of it whiskey and rum. Heavy drinking was linked to poverty, violence at home and lost work. Early societies, such as two founded in Massachusetts and Connecticut in 1813, urged moderation. In 1825 the Presbyterian minister Lyman Beecher preached six famous sermons calling for total abstinence from spirits, and the American Temperance Society followed in 1826. By the mid-1830s most societies demanded teetotalism, giving up beer and wine as well, a step that divided the movement.
Washingtonians, women and the law
In 1840 a group of working men in Baltimore formed the Washington Temperance Society. Often reformed drinkers themselves, the Washingtonians reached out to heavy drinkers with personal stories, parades and picnics. Hundreds of thousands took their pledge, though many later relapsed. Women joined in large numbers, because a drunken husband could waste a family's income and wives had little legal protection. Reformers then turned to law. Massachusetts limited small sales of spirits in 1838, and in 1851 Maine passed the first statewide ban on making and selling alcohol. About a dozen states followed in the 1850s.
Worked example: from persuasion to law
Trace why temperance reformers turned to legislation. 1. Starting point: early reformers relied on moral persuasion, sermons and voluntary pledges. 2. Problem: pledges were easy to break, and many who signed went back to drinking. 3. Reasoning: if individuals could not be relied on to resist temptation, the law could remove the temptation by stopping sales. 4. Action: reformers lobbied town and state governments, producing the Maine Law of 1851. 5. Consequence: drink became a political issue, often pitting native-born Protestants against German and Irish immigrants. 6. Check: several states soon repealed or weakened their bans.
Diet, water cures and phrenology
With no effective medical regulation, health advice went in many directions. Sylvester Graham, a Presbyterian minister and lecturer, preached a plain diet of vegetables, fruit and coarse whole-wheat bread, with no meat, alcohol or spices, and warned against sexual excess. The graham cracker is named after him. Hydropathy, the water cure, treated illness with baths and wet wraps and was popular in the 1840s and 1850s. Phrenology, developed by the German physician Franz Joseph Gall, claimed that the shape of the skull revealed a person's character. It is now rejected as pseudoscience and was used to support racist ideas, but Gall's notion that brain regions have different functions endured.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, not all utopian communities were religious: New Harmony under Owen, Brook Farm and the Fourierist phalanxes were secular. Second, the Indiana town had two lives: the Rappites' Harmony, then Owen's New Harmony from 1825. Third, temperance did not always mean banning alcohol; early reformers wanted moderation, and teetotalism came later. Fourth, the Maine Law of 1851 was a state law, not a national one; national prohibition came only in the twentieth century. Fifth, phrenology was popular, but it was never sound science.
Key takeaways
Unsettled by the market revolution, reformers founded communities, peaking in the 1840s. Religious groups included the Rappites, the celibate Shakers, Oneida and the Latter-day Saints. Secular experiments such as New Harmony, Brook Farm and the phalanxes mostly failed quickly. Temperance moved from moderation to teetotalism, gained working-class and female supporters through the Washingtonians, and won state laws such as Maine's in 1851. Graham's diet, water cures and phrenology show a wider search for health and self-knowledge.
Flashcards
Flashcard
An experimental community seeking a more equal, harmonious way of life
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which community was founded on secular ideas rather than religious ones?
Question 2 of 5
Which practice most set the Shakers apart from mainstream American society?
Question 3 of 5
What did teetotalism ask temperance supporters to do?
Question 4 of 5
In 1851 Maine passed a famous temperance law. What did it do?
Question 5 of 5
Why did many women join the temperance movement?
