US History › Section N · World War II and the early Cold War › Topic N.5

The challenges of peacetime

Victory in 1945 brought relief but also anxiety: would the Depression return once war spending stopped? This topic follows how Harry Truman's America brought millions of veterans home, fought over prices, unions and civil rights, and tried to extend the New Deal.

Bringing the troops home

When the war ended, about 12 million Americans were in uniform, and families and soldiers demanded rapid demobilisation. Despite warnings from military leaders that the nation's strength abroad would suffer, the forces shrank to about 1.5 million by mid-1947. Many Americans feared that so many returning men, with defence plants closing, would bring back Depression unemployment. Women war workers were often dismissed to make room for veterans, although surveys found that most wanted to keep their jobs. Many left, yet women still made up nearly a third of the workforce in the 1950s. Veterans themselves faced the strain of returning, including the psychological wounds of combat.

The GI Bill

Congress had prepared for the veterans' return. The Servicemen's Readjustment Act of June 1944, known as the GI Bill, gave veterans unemployment pay of $20 a week for up to a year. It paid college or vocational-school tuition and a living allowance, and it guaranteed low-interest loans to buy homes, farms and businesses. About 2.2 million veterans went to college with its help, and millions more took job training. In 1947 veterans made up roughly half of all college students. The law spread education and home ownership and helped many working-class families enter the middle class, while keeping a flood of job seekers off the labour market.

Worked example: who did the GI Bill help?

Question: did the GI Bill help all veterans equally? 1. The law itself made no distinction by race. 2. But it was run by local officials and private institutions: Southern colleges were segregated, and the historically Black colleges were too few and too crowded to take everyone who applied. 3. Loans depended on banks; in 1947 in Mississippi, of more than 3,000 home, farm and business loans guaranteed for veterans, only two went to Black veterans. 4. Others were excluded or delayed: some 9,000 gay and lesbian veterans discharged for their sexuality were denied benefits, and Mexican American veterans in Texas faced obstacles, leading to the founding of the American GI Forum in 1948. 5. Conclusion: the GI Bill was transformative, but historians such as Ira Katznelson argue that it widened racial gaps in wealth and education.

Japanese Americans return

In December 1944 the army announced the end of the exclusion of Japanese Americans from the West Coast, from January 1945, and the camps closed over the following months; the last, Tule Lake, shut in 1946. Families returned to find homes vandalised, farms ruined and belongings left in storage stolen or sold. Some faced boycotts of their businesses, threats and even shootings at their homes, and many settled in new places such as Chicago instead. Japanese American veterans of the 442nd Regimental Combat Team came home to the same prejudice. The Evacuation Claims Act of 1948 repaid only a small fraction of property losses, and a fuller reckoning waited until the redress of 1988.

Prices and the strike wave of 1946

Converting the economy back to peacetime production was rough. Wartime savings and pent-up demand chased scarce goods, and when most price controls ended in 1946, prices rose by nearly 30 percent over the next two years. Workers who had kept a no-strike pledge in wartime now demanded higher pay to match rising prices. In 1946 nearly five million workers went on strike, in steel, cars, coal and the railways. When railway workers struck, Truman threatened to draft them into the army. Frustrated voters punished the Democrats: in the 1946 elections, Republicans won control of both houses of Congress for the first time since the early 1930s.

The Taft-Hartley Act

The new Republican Congress, working with conservative Southern Democrats, set out to limit union power. The Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 banned the closed shop, in which employers could hire only union members, and let states pass right-to-work laws forbidding contracts that required workers to join a union. It allowed the president to seek a court order delaying, for 80 days, a strike that endangered national health or safety, and it required union leaders to swear they were not communists. Truman vetoed the bill, calling it unfair to workers, but Congress passed it over his veto. Unions denounced it as a slave-labour law; business groups saw it as restoring balance.

Truman and civil rights

Black veterans returned determined to claim the rights they had fought for, and some were met with violence. In February 1946, South Carolina police beat and blinded Isaac Woodard, a Black army sergeant still in uniform, on his way home. Shocked by such attacks, Truman created a President's Committee on Civil Rights in December 1946. Its 1947 report, To Secure These Rights, called for laws against lynching and the poll tax and an end to segregation. Truman became the first president to address the NAACP. In July 1948, Executive Order 9981 ordered equal treatment in the armed forces, which were largely desegregated by 1954, and another order banned discrimination in federal jobs.

Worked example: the 1948 election

Why did Truman win a race he was expected to lose? 1. Division: after the Democratic convention adopted a civil rights plank, Southern segregationists walked out and formed the States' Rights (Dixiecrat) Party behind Strom Thurmond, while Henry Wallace led a Progressive Party to Truman's left. 2. The favourite: Republican Thomas Dewey ran a cautious campaign, and polls showed him far ahead. 3. Strategy: Truman toured the country by train, attacking the Republican-led "do-nothing" Congress for blocking housing, price and labour measures. 4. Coalition: workers, farmers and Black voters in Northern cities rallied to him. 5. Result: Truman won, Thurmond carried only four Southern states, and the Chicago Daily Tribune's early headline "Dewey Defeats Truman" became famous for being wrong.

The Fair Deal

In January 1949, Truman named his programme the Fair Deal, building on the New Deal. Some of it passed: Congress raised the minimum wage from 40 to 75 cents an hour, brought about 10 million more people into Social Security, and passed the Housing Act of 1949, which funded public housing and slum clearance. Much more failed. A coalition of Republicans and Southern Democrats blocked national health insurance, which the American Medical Association attacked as "socialized medicine," along with federal aid to schools, laws against lynching and the poll tax, and a permanent Fair Employment Practices Committee. Rising Cold War fears soon drew attention away from domestic reform.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming the GI Bill benefited all veterans equally; local administration and banks shut many Black veterans out. Second, thinking Truman desegregated the military through Congress; he used an executive order, because Congress would not act. Third, confusing the New Deal with the Fair Deal; the Fair Deal was Truman's postwar programme. Fourth, believing Truman supported the Taft-Hartley Act; he vetoed it. Fifth, assuming all women left the workforce in 1945; many were dismissed, but women remained nearly a third of workers.

Key takeaways

Rapid demobilisation and fears of depression marked 1945 and 1946. The GI Bill paid for education, unemployment support and loans, lifting millions into the middle class, but Black, gay and many Mexican American veterans gained far less. Japanese Americans returned to damaged homes and hostility. Inflation and the 1946 strike wave helped Republicans win Congress, which passed the Taft-Hartley Act over Truman's veto. Truman's civil rights committee and Executive Order 9981 broke new ground. He won the 1948 election despite a three-way split, but Congress passed only parts of his Fair Deal.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Demobilisation

Shrinking the armed forces after the war, from about 12 million to 1.5 million by 1947

Driven by pressure to bring the troops home.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which benefits did the GI Bill of 1944 offer veterans?

Question 2 of 5

Why did many Black veterans gain much less from the GI Bill than white veterans?

Question 3 of 5

What did the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 do?

Question 4 of 5

What did Executive Order 9981 of July 1948 do?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best describes the 1948 presidential election?

← Previous topicNext topic →