US History › Section N · World War II and the early Cold War › Topic N.4
The Pacific war and the atomic bomb
The war against Japan moved from crushing defeats to a slow, bloody advance across the Pacific, and it ended with the only use of nuclear weapons in war. Why the United States dropped the atomic bombs, and whether it should have, remains one of the great debates among historians.
Japan's early victories
In the six months after Pearl Harbor, Japan won a vast empire. It took Guam, Wake Island, Hong Kong, Malaya and the British base at Singapore, the Dutch East Indies with their oil, and Burma. In the Philippines, American and Filipino troops held out on the Bataan peninsula until April 1942. On the forced march that followed, the Bataan Death March, several hundred Americans and thousands of Filipinos died from beatings, heat and starvation. That same month, carrier-launched bombers led by James Doolittle raided Tokyo, doing little damage but lifting American morale.
Coral Sea and Midway
The tide turned at sea in mid-1942. In the Battle of the Coral Sea in May, the first naval battle in which the fleets never sighted each other, the Americans turned back a Japanese invasion force bound for Port Moresby, in New Guinea, which threatened Australia. In June, Japan tried to trap the American fleet at Midway Island. American code-breakers had discovered the plan, and on 4 June American dive bombers wrecked four Japanese aircraft carriers, all of which sank, for the loss of one American carrier. Japan could not replace carriers and veteran pilots as fast as the United States could build and train new ones, and it never regained the initiative.
Island hopping
The first American offensive came at Guadalcanal, in the Solomon Islands, from August 1942 to February 1943. Then two drives converged on Japan: General Douglas MacArthur's through New Guinea towards the Philippines, and Admiral Chester Nimitz's across the central Pacific through islands such as Tarawa and Saipan. Planners bypassed strongly held islands, leaving their garrisons to wither, and seized others that could serve as airfields and naval bases. From the Marianas, taken in 1944, new B-29 bombers could reach Japan. Racial hatred on both sides, and Japan's harsh treatment of prisoners, made the fighting especially merciless, and few prisoners were taken.
Iwo Jima and Okinawa
In October 1944, MacArthur returned to the Philippines, and at Leyte Gulf, the largest naval battle in history, the Japanese navy was effectively destroyed. Japanese pilots began kamikaze attacks, crashing their planes into American ships. In February and March 1945, marines took the small island of Iwo Jima, needed as an emergency airfield; nearly 7,000 Americans and almost all of about 20,000 defenders died. From April to June, the battle for Okinawa killed more than 12,000 Americans, about 100,000 Japanese troops and perhaps 100,000 or more Okinawan civilians. To American planners, these battles previewed what an invasion of Japan itself might cost.
Fire from the sky and blockade
By 1945, American submarines and mines had sunk most of Japan's merchant shipping, cutting off food, oil and raw materials. B-29s from the Marianas switched from high-altitude raids on factories to low-level night attacks with incendiaries on largely wooden cities. The raid on Tokyo on the night of 9 to 10 March 1945 killed an estimated 80,000 to 100,000 people, roughly as many as the Hiroshima bomb killed at once. Firebombing went on to burn large parts of more than sixty cities. Many Japanese leaders saw that the war could not be won, but the military insisted on fighting on to win better terms.
The Manhattan Project
In 1939, Albert Einstein signed a letter warning Roosevelt that Germany might build an atomic bomb. From 1942, the secret Manhattan Project, run by General Leslie Groves with J. Robert Oppenheimer as scientific director, employed well over 100,000 people at sites including Oak Ridge in Tennessee, Hanford in Washington and Los Alamos in New Mexico, at a cost of about $2 billion. Truman learned the full details only after becoming president in April 1945. The first test, at Alamogordo, New Mexico, succeeded on 16 July 1945. Ten days later, the Potsdam Declaration demanded the unconditional surrender of Japan's armed forces, warning of "prompt and utter destruction" but not mentioning the bomb or the emperor's future.
Hiroshima, Nagasaki and surrender
On 6 August 1945, the B-29 Enola Gay dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima. Perhaps 70,000 to 80,000 people died at once, and by the end of 1945 the toll reached an estimated 140,000, many from burns and radiation sickness. On 8 August the Soviet Union declared war on Japan, and within hours its armies poured into Manchuria. On 9 August a second bomb destroyed much of Nagasaki, killing about 70,000 by the end of the year. Japan's leaders were deadlocked until Emperor Hirohito urged acceptance of the Allied terms. Japan announced its surrender on 15 August and signed the formal surrender aboard the USS Missouri in Tokyo Bay on 2 September 1945.
Worked example: the case for the decision
Defenders of the decision, holding what is called the traditional or orthodox view, argue in steps. 1. The alternative was invasion: plans called for landings on Kyushu in November 1945 and near Tokyo in 1946. 2. Cost: Iwo Jima and Okinawa suggested huge losses. Wartime estimates varied widely, from tens of thousands of American casualties for the first landing to far more in some staff studies; in 1947 the former Secretary of War Henry Stimson wrote of over a million. 3. Resistance: even after Hiroshima, Japan's war council would not surrender, and some officers tried to stop the emperor's broadcast. 4. Other lives: every month of war also killed many thousands in Japanese-occupied Asia. 5. Conclusion: on this view, the bombs ended the war quickly and saved more lives than they took.
Worked example: the critics' case
Critics, sometimes called revisionists, answer with other evidence. 1. Japan was near defeat: blockade and firebombing had crippled it, and decoded messages showed its government seeking Soviet help to negotiate an end to the war. 2. Alternatives existed: the United States could have promised that the emperor might stay, which it in effect allowed after the surrender; waited for the Soviet attack; or demonstrated the bomb. 3. Timing: Nagasaki was bombed only three days after Hiroshima, giving Japan little time to respond. 4. Motive: some, such as Gar Alperovitz, argue that impressing the Soviet Union mattered to American leaders. 5. Ethics: most of the victims were civilians.
Where historians stand
Many historians, such as J. Samuel Walker, take a middle position: Truman chiefly wanted to end the war fast and save American lives, and after years of bombing cities, few leaders saw a reason not to use the bomb; impressing the Soviet Union was a welcome bonus, not the main aim. Tsuyoshi Hasegawa argues that the Soviet declaration of war did more than the bombs to push Japan towards surrender. Richard Frank, citing decoded Japanese messages, replies that Japan's leaders still meant to fight on, so the bombs were decisive. Evidence alone cannot settle the moral question of killing so many civilians.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, presenting the decision as settled fact in either direction; each side uses real evidence. Second, treating the claim of a million American lives saved as the planners' settled forecast; that round figure became common after the war, and wartime estimates varied widely. Third, forgetting the Soviet declaration of war on 8 August, between the two bombs. Fourth, assuming only the atomic bombs caused mass civilian deaths; one night of firebombing in Tokyo killed roughly as many people as the Hiroshima blast.
Key takeaways
Japan won rapid victories until Coral Sea and Midway in 1942. Island hopping brought American bases within bombing range of Japan, and Iwo Jima and Okinawa showed how costly an invasion might be. The Manhattan Project produced the bomb, used on Hiroshima on 6 August and Nagasaki on 9 August 1945, between which the Soviet Union declared war. Japan surrendered on 15 August, formally on 2 September. Historians debate whether the bombs were necessary: defenders stress the cost of invasion, critics stress Japan's weakness and alternatives.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Forced march of American and Filipino prisoners in the Philippines
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why is the Battle of Midway seen as the turning point of the Pacific war?
Question 2 of 5
What was the main purpose of the island-hopping strategy?
Question 3 of 5
Which argument is central to the traditional defence of using the atomic bombs?
Question 4 of 5
Which point do critics of the decision to use the bombs commonly make?
Question 5 of 5
What happened between the bombing of Hiroshima and the bombing of Nagasaki?
