US History › Section E · Industry and Jacksonian democracy › Topic E.3

A new social order: class divisions

The market and industrial revolutions created great new wealth, but shared it very unevenly. In northern cities between about 1820 and 1860, Americans sorted into classes with their own neighbourhoods, values, entertainments and opinions about slavery.

A society sorting itself by class

In a colonial town, a master craftsman, his journeymen and apprentices often lived under one roof, and wealth differences were smaller. Industrialisation pulled these groups apart. Employers moved to quieter streets, wage workers crowded into rented rooms near the docks and mills, and a growing group of clerks, shopkeepers and professionals filled the space between. Historians describe three broad layers in the urban North: an economic elite, a middle class, and a working class. The lines were never sealed, and race, sex and birthplace cut across all three.

Old money: the merchant elite

At the top in Boston, New York and Philadelphia stood families whose fortunes came from colonial and early national trade in goods such as tea, sugar and textiles, and in some cases enslaved people. After 1815 their heirs moved into banking, insurance, shipping and factory ownership; the Boston Associates who built Lowell were one such group. Junius Spencer Morgan, a Boston merchant who became a banker in London, was the father of J. P. Morgan, the leading American financier of the late 1800s. Elite families married into one another, built houses in exclusive districts and founded private clubs such as the Philadelphia Club of 1834, all ways of keeping wealth and influence within a narrow circle.

Self-made manufacturers

A second elite rose from humbler beginnings. Peter Cooper of New York made money in glue, then in iron, and in 1830 built the Tom Thumb, an early American steam locomotive, for the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad. Men like Cooper celebrated hard work and thrift rather than pedigree, and older families often shut them out of their clubs. In 1859 Cooper founded the Cooper Union in New York, which offered free education in science, engineering and art, open regardless of sex or race. The figure of the "self-made man" became a powerful American ideal, even though most wealthy Americans of the time had inherited at least some of their advantages.

The middle class and its values

Between the rich and the wage workers grew a middle class of shopkeepers, small manufacturers, master craftsmen, clerks, teachers, ministers and other professionals. Without great fortunes to fall back on, they feared slipping into wage labour, so they prized self-control, punctuality, sobriety, education and good manners. Their children went to school rather than to work. Families also became smaller: historians estimate that the average number of children born to a white American woman fell from about seven in 1800 to about five and a half by 1850, with the steepest fall in the urban middle class. Each child now needed costly schooling and no longer brought in income.

Separate spheres

Middle-class culture idealised separate spheres. Men were to compete in the public world of business and politics; women were to make the home a moral refuge, raise virtuous children and manage the household. Historians sometimes call this ideal the cult of domesticity. It was not a description of reality: middle-class wives did hard unpaid work, often with a servant, frequently a young Irish immigrant woman. Most working-class and Black women could not afford to stay out of paid labour. The ideal also gave women a claim to moral authority, which many used to justify public work in churches and reform societies.

Religion and reform

The middle class flocked to the revivals of the Second Great Awakening, a later topic in this course. The preacher Charles Grandison Finney, whose revival in Rochester, New York, in 1830 and 1831 drew many merchants and their families, taught that people could choose salvation through their own free will and then had a duty to improve society. That message suited men and women who already believed effort and discipline brought success. Middle-class reformers backed temperance, the campaign against alcohol, along with Sunday schools, moral reform and, for a committed minority, the abolition of slavery, which offended their belief that work, not coerced labour, gave dignity.

Worked example: why employers backed temperance

Explain the link between class and the campaign against drink. 1. In artisan shops, workers had often drunk together on the job, and employers sometimes supplied the liquor. 2. Factories and counting houses needed workers who arrived on time and handled costly machines safely, so drinking now threatened profit. 3. Revivals taught that a converted person should master sinful habits, which framed sobriety as a moral duty. 4. Many middle-class employers therefore joined temperance societies and pressed workers to sign pledges. 5. Some workers did take the pledge, but many saw the campaign as interference. Check: the cause runs from economic change through religion to a reform movement.

The working class

Wage earners formed the largest group in the industrial cities: journeymen whose hopes of becoming masters had narrowed, unskilled labourers, dockworkers and seamstresses. Many lived in crowded districts such as New York's Five Points, home to Irish immigrants and free Black residents, where poverty, disease and fire were constant threats. Working-class children often left school early to earn, and wives took in laundry, sewing or lodgers. Workers built a lively culture of taverns, theatres and fire companies. P. T. Barnum's American Museum, which he took over in New York at the end of 1841, drew huge crowds with cheap admission and often fake curiosities such as the "Feejee Mermaid". Blackface minstrel shows, which mocked Black Americans, were also highly popular.

Free Black northerners and immigrants

Free Black northerners met discrimination in every class. White craftsmen often kept them out of skilled trades, many lost the vote, and mobs attacked Black neighbourhoods, as in Philadelphia in 1834. Black communities built their own institutions, including the African Methodist Episcopal Church, founded under Richard Allen in 1816, and Freedom's Journal, the first Black-owned newspaper, in 1827. Immigration surged in the 1840s and 1850s, as millions of Irish and Germans arrived, many Irish fleeing famine. Most joined the working class, and the Catholicism of many provoked nativist hostility, including the burning of an Ursuline convent near Boston in 1834.

Worked example: three views of slavery

Compare three northerners around 1840. 1. A Boston merchant whose mills used southern cotton: slavery fed his profits, so he disliked abolitionist agitation that might anger southern customers and split the Union. 2. A middle-class reformer in upstate New York: slavery denied the dignity of free labour and offended her faith, so she might join an antislavery society. 3. An Irish dockworker in New York: he feared freed people would compete for his low-paid job, so he was likely hostile to abolition. 4. Conclusion: economic interest and religious belief, more than region alone, shaped northern opinion. Check: these are typical positions, and individuals in every class broke the pattern.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, do not assume the North was united against slavery: many elite and working-class northerners opposed abolition. Second, separate spheres was an ideal, not a description of how most women lived. Third, the self-made man was more myth than rule; many fortunes were inherited. Fourth, class was not the only line of division: race, religion, sex and immigrant status shaped opportunity inside every class.

Key takeaways

Industrialisation split northern society into an inherited merchant elite, self-made manufacturers, a respectability-minded middle class and a large working class. Middle-class families had fewer children, valued education and self-control, idealised separate spheres, and drove reforms such as temperance. Workers built their own public culture but lived precariously. Free Black northerners and Irish and German immigrants faced discrimination. Each class tended to view slavery through its own interests and beliefs.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Class

A group sharing a similar economic position, culture and outlook

Elite, middle class and working class in the urban North.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Peter Cooper, who rose from modest beginnings in glue and iron, was often excluded from older elite clubs. He best illustrates which group?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement best describes the ideal of separate spheres?

Question 3 of 5

Why were many northern wage workers hostile to the abolition of slavery in the 1830s and 1840s?

Question 4 of 5

Charles Grandison Finney's preaching appealed strongly to middle-class northerners mainly because he taught that

Question 5 of 5

Historians link the falling birth rate of middle-class families between 1800 and 1850 mainly to which change?

← Previous topicNext topic →